Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon

sponsored by
Business


Gibbons' tax stand criticized

Gaming executive says governor should drop 'no taxes' pledge

MGM Mirage Chairman and CEO Terry Lanni believes Gov. Jim Gibbons should withdraw his campaign pledge not to raise taxes during his term in office and support a broad-based plan to fund state government.

Lanni, whose casino company operates 10 resorts on the Strip and is building the massive $7.8 billion CityCenter development, made his comments as the state's casino industry is facing two potential ballot initiatives to raise the gross gaming tax above the current 6.75 percent.


Most Popular Stories
  • Fraud with Portent
  • Expect to pay at Nugget's new tower
  • Debt-ridden casino operators told to expect pressure
  • REAL ESTATE: Las Vegas home prices stabilize as threat of foreclosure flood wanes
  • REAL ESTATE: Short sales on the rise
  • GAMING COMPANY EARNINGS: Station drops $455.4 million
  • THE STRIP: License approved for Aria
  • GLOBAL GAMING EXPO: Recession over? Don't bet on it
  • Foreclosure wave continues
  • Union wants insiders to help pull Station from bankruptcy




  • Las Vegas attorney Kermitt Waters wants the gaming tax to match what casinos are taxed in other states, while the Nevada State Education Association is seeking to increase the tax rate on the state's largest casinos to 9.75 percent.

    Lanni, in an interview after MGM Mirage's third-quarter earnings release, said casino companies have an unjust target on their backs.

    "Any economist will tell you that it's bad government to rely on one industry," Lanni said. "My view is simple; all businesses that we have here -- bankers, retailers, auto dealers -- have to participate. Whether we're ranked 47th in education, 48th or 49th, whatever the number is, that's not a good rate and something needs to be done about it."

    Lanni said the governor and Nevada lawmakers need to find additional sources for revenue, rather than allowing special interest groups to pass tax increases through initiatives. Gibbons, he said, needs to take a leadership role in moving the state toward a more stable tax structure.

    "That's what governors do," Lanni said.

    Gibbons, a Republican, campaigned in 2006 on a promise that he would not raise taxes. Lanni said the governor should abandon his campaign vow and look at other means to fund government services in light of Nevada's potential budget crisis, such as a broad-based tax that covers multiple industries.

    "I think the governor should withdraw that position because that's not necessarily sound government policy," Lanni said. "It's just not sound fiscal policy to tax one industry and put all your eggs in one basket. You're banking our education system on the health of one industry and if there is a downturn, you have serious problems."

    Lanni's criticism of Gibbons was somewhat surprising because of his support for the governor in the 2006 election. Lanni, a Republican, has supported Republican candidates financially on a national scale.

    MGM Mirage and its corporate entities contributed more than $100,000 to Gibbons' campaign. Perhaps equally important, Lanni encouraged others to give.

    Twice, he hosted fund-raisers at the lavish MGM Grand Mansion for Gibbons, including one in the final days of the campaign featuring former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani that raised as much as $100,000 at a time Gibbons' campaign was struggling to fend off multiple scandals.

    Lanni said he hadn't spoken directly to the governor but figures his message will be received.

    Other gaming executives supported Lanni's position.

    Boyd Gaming Corp. President Keith Smith, whose company is spending $4.8 billion on the Echelon development, agreed other industries should be part of any tax solution. Taxing by initiative, Smith said, is not a good way to run the state.

    "Standing behind the no-new tax pledge, with the needs the state is facing today, is not a good way to solve any problems," Smith said. "The governor needs to provide leadership and not allow just one industry to be looked at. We need to get other people around the table."

    International Game Technology Chairman and CEO TJ Matthews also opposes the initiative process.

    While IGT, the industry's largest slot machine maker, does not operate casinos, the company would suffer if casinos cut are forced to cut back on purchasing new gaming equipment.

    "We have sympathy that there are needs in this state," Matthews said. "We would support Terry Lanni's view that there needs to be a broad-based approach. That makes much more sense than penalizing one industry."

    Gibbons' press secretary, Melissa Subbotin, said Friday the governor continues to stand firm against any tax increase.

    "It would be irresponsible in a time of an economic downturn to dip into the pockets of Nevada taxpayers," Subbotin said.

    Last month, in response to projected revenue shortfalls, Gibbons announced that selected state agencies, including higher education, needed to prepare priority lists on how they would cut their budgets by 5 percent, or a combined $184 million. Gibbons exempted public education, the prison system and public safety agencies, such as the Nevada Highway Patrol, from any cuts. On Wednesday, key government leaders are expected to travel to Carson City for a meeting to discuss the budget and economic factors impacting the state.

    Two weeks ago, Senate Majority Leader Bill Raggio said the governor should not immediately make budget cuts and should wait for the Legislature's consent before reducing state government agency budgets.

    "People such as Sen. Raggio are speaking out because they understand we need to have proper balance in the state," Lanni said.

    A state report released in October showed that taxable sales declined 5.7 percent in August compared with August 2006. Gaming and sales tax revenues for the first two months of the fiscal year that began in July were off nearly $35 million from what was projected when the state's two-year budget was approved in June.

    The two taxes made up 60 percent of the revenue going into the state's $6.8 billion budget.

    Lanni said raising casino taxes would send the wrong message to Wall Street and could curtail investment. He said the stable gaming tax has been a reason MGM Mirage has been able to attract joint venture partners to Nevada.

    At CityCenter, the investment of the Persian Gulf state of Dubai has invested $2.7 billion to acquire half of the project. Kerzner international Holdings, which owns the Atlantis Paradise Island resort in the Bahamas, is investing with MGM Mirage and Dubai World in a development on the Strip's northern end.

    "That investment could go somewhere else, which would hurt all of us," Lanni said.

    Contact reporter Howard Stutz at hstutz@reviewjournal.com or (702) 477-3871.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 20 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    rick wrote on November 04, 2007 07:00 PM: Governor Gibbons, please hold the fort. It's time for government to live within thier means just like the private sector. Government opperates with impunity, this has to stop. The school system in clark county is a dismil failure. The answer to this is the proven private sector. Government can not supply a cost effective product. They take much, promising much, while delivering only excuses. And every year the answer is just show me the money. Are tax payers so stupid as to fall for thit line every year? It's time the government of the people operate like the people, within thier budget.


    dawn wrote on November 04, 2007 04:48 PM: Gibbons stinks


    count me in wrote on November 04, 2007 04:47 PM: Terry Lanni, you have had special interest groups representing you for years. So, we peasants are finally catching on and you are boo hooing?

    Do you think we care if your investors go south? When did you care about us? How much were you going to charge for those houses where the landing used to be?

    Since so many are now renters, we can rent in other states with a better quality of life. I will sign the initiative before I leave.

    Was this picture taken on election night? Think back to that night when your boy got elected. Bet you were dancing a jig. We have been living with him for 10 months welcome to our world.


    recall wrote on November 04, 2007 03:23 PM: Funny thing, wasn't it Mr Lanni and his com padres that put Gibbons in office? Didn't Mr Lanni's com padres donate to the Gibbons legal slush fund?
    Can I sign the initiative today?


    NVMojo wrote on November 04, 2007 03:22 PM: Wonder why Carson City wasn't invited to this meeting. They have more people in it then Elko County.


    grumpy wrote on November 04, 2007 03:21 PM: While I was an LV resident (no longer) I always wondered what we got for our taxes. Sales tax at the time was 7.75% which is higher than the national average. Don't get me started on vehicle registration fees which were among the highest in the nation. Fuel taxes were up there too. That said, most services were decidedly substandard (police was ok, fire was actually good). The educational system in my view was an absolute joke. County functions such as traffic management (things like timing traffic lights) was a joke as well. What has been done with all the tax revenue that was collected? Why are all the elected officials whining about insufficient funds? Has an independent outside auditor ever been used? I'd bet a lot of waste would show up.

    Food for thought for my former neighbors: No society ever taxed itself into prosperity. Think about that when you vote at election time.


    LOL wrote on November 04, 2007 02:42 PM: Mr Lanni, you got what you paid for with Gibbons. You know the old casino folks new the key to success was to spread the wealth around. They made sure that housing was affordable and workers lived comfortably. The owners were rich and the people were o.k. The new breed running this town got greedy all the way around. They got rich, we got poor. Well, we have accepted our new lot in life, accept yours. If you are down in he dumps try some comfort food. May I suggest some top ramin. It does grow on you. p.s. In time all the disappointment of big dreams will pass. Like with us, a nice Christmas for our children. For you it might be another million. This is still the wild west, so, Mr Lanni cowboy up.


    stund wrote on November 04, 2007 02:15 PM: Why would the brethren from MGM be disappointed in Gibbons. Didn't Siggie from MGM run Gibbons campaign????? Do you think, Gibbons is paying them back for hiring his buddy Guinn??? I wonder if Gibbons has taken many trip to Venice??? Is this a picture of Mr Lanni or is it Lon Chaney from Phantom of the Opera??? Finally, where do I sign the initiative?????


    joe wrote on November 04, 2007 01:55 PM: Time for you big casino guys to start paying more of your fair share. It seems you have no problem coughing up money for huge projects on the strip. If you feel you are too taxed here and want to take your new projects somewhere else be my guest. We have enough casinos here, go find some other place to suck money out of peoples pockets


    huh wrote on November 04, 2007 10:17 AM: raise the casino taxes now.they pay a lousy 6.75%.the lowest in the country.


    Read All Comments