Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu

sponsored by
Business


More damaged sites discovered at Rio

Structural metal may have been hurt during remodeling

Three more sites have emerged in a Rio guest tower where structural metal elements embedded in concrete may have been damaged during improper remodeling.

While inspecting Jacuzzi tubs on the 19th floor of the Rio's Ipanema tower, county building inspectors discovered three guest rooms that appear to have "post-tension cables and/or rebar broken or damaged," according to an inspection report dated Tuesday.


Most Popular Stories
  • Mayor calls Lady Luck casino 'carcass'
  • CASINOS IN COURT: Testimony heard in Wynn case
  • Players turned away at WSOP
  • Area economy hits 'pause' period, economist says
  • NEVADAN AT WORK: Local gaming veteran sees opportunity in small Henderson casino
  • Consolidated Resorts files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy
  • FOURTH OF JULY TOURISM: Las Vegas is the place for bargain seekers
  • Fontainebleau files motion to leave offices
  • ONLINE GUY: Palm Pre promising but not ready to replace Apple iPhone in pocket
  • Job hunt is brutal for older workers




  • "These were not discovered on 18th-floor inspections" of the concrete slab shared by the 18th and 19th floors, the report reads. "These will have be addressed by an additional engineer's report."

    Earlier engineer's reports assessed breaks -- or instances of damage to cable or rebar -- found in nine other Ipanema rooms, and determined the damage did not impair the slabs' ability to bear the load they are required to by code.

    County inspectors spotted the latest batch of damage sites when they asked contractors to open the walls around tubs on the 19th floor to inspect hidden plumbing fittings. The holes into concrete did not run through the slab, and thus were not visible in an earlier inspection from the 18th floor, Stacey Welling, a county spokeswoman, explained.

    Here is a chronological summary of other irregularities discovered at the Rio, 3700 W. Flamingo Road, since officials from the Clark County Department of Development Services or Clark County Fire Department began investigating in late September. Harrah's Entertainment has to fix all violations at the Rio.

    Unless otherwise noted, listings are based on documents issued by the county's building division in Development Services, which is tracking the hotel's remodeling violations from discovery through remediation. The remediation process includes getting approval of required plans, receiving permits, performing work and passing inspections. Reports are ordered from newest to oldest. Text in parentheses provides further explanation when needed.

    •In two suites on Ipanema tower's 19th floor, electrical conduits "are entering the room by first penetrating the airshafts. The electrical system needs to be rerouted and shaft repaired by approved material and methods." Nov. 7 notice of violation. (If an airshaft is not kept intact, during a fire smoke and fumes can more easily spread to otherwise safe areas of a building.)

    •In four suites on 19th floor of Ipanema, handicap "accessible bathtubs were installed along corridor walls and installation does not meet the 1-hr. (fire) rating for wall." Nov. 5 correction notice.

    •"New soffits will have to be constructed to house a new sprinkler line ... at bedroom entrances" on the Ipanema tower's 19th floor. Nov. 5 correction notice. (A soffit is a structure that extends out from where the ceiling joins a wall. Often the enclosure hides pipes, wiring or a rafter. The need for a new line suggests prior sprinkler arrangement was not adequate.)

    •Another exposed post-tension cable found in a 19th-floor suite in Ipanema. A new engineer's report is required to verify the concrete slab in which it is located hasn't been impaired. Nov. 1 correction notice. (Such concrete-embedded cables are a construction method that strengthens concrete.)

    •"Electrical components secured directly to air shaft in bathrooms" on 19th floor of Ipanema tower. "Shall be removed from shaft and installed by approved methods." Oct. 30 correction notice. (The components' location compromised the shaft's fire-resistance rating.)

    •In a storage room on 18th floor of Ipanema, the fire rating of a wall shared with the corridor was compromised. Also, "electrical receptacles (plug outlets) shall be GFCI-protected within 6 feet of sinks and basins." Oct. 24 correction notice. (A GFCI, or ground-fault circuit interrupter device, prevents electric shock, such as might occur if a hair dryer fell into a sink of water.)

    •In 19th floor corridor, unsealed ceiling and wall penetrations in soffits in front of all suite entry doors. Oct. 25 correction notice. (Unsealed holes allow a fire's smoke or heat to travel within a building.)

    •In 11 Ipanema guest rooms, drainage piping lacks approved fitting installed by approved methods. Oct. 25 correction notice. (Improper installation can lead to leaks and growth of mold.)

    •"GFCI devices not working" in 17 bathrooms or powder rooms on Ipanema's 18th floor. Oct. 23 correction notice.

    •"Emergency evacuation plans are missing throughout (Ipanema 19th) floor." Oct. 23 correction notice.

    •In Rio basement corridor, "ceiling ... to floor penetration near (employee) uniform room without permits or inspection. (Plumbing) line run in plastic piping not permitted in (this type of) construction." Oct. 23 notice of violation.

    •In 16 Carioca suites on various floors of the Ipanema tower, "the addition, relocation and rerouting of plumbing piping and fixtures without plans, permits and required inspections." Oct. 22 notice of violation.

    •In 16 Cariaoca suites on various Ipanema floors, "the addition, relocation of electrical devices, lighting and other electrical components without plans, permits and required inspections." Oct. 22 notice of violation.

    •In 16 Carioca suites on various Ipanema floors, "the addition, relocation and rerouting of mechanical duct work and outlets without plans, permits and required inspections." Oct. 22 notice of violation.

    •On Ipanema tower's 19th floor, all suite entry doors need to be checked for fire-safety ratings. Same applies to doors connecting rooms. Oct. 20 correction notice.

    •Seven rooms on 18th floor of Ipanema's newest wing "have damage to post tension cables and/or rebar." Oct. 20 notice of violation. (The same damage affects the 19th-floor rooms above, which share the slab.)

    •On floors three through 19 in all three Ipanema wings, "use of nonmetallic flex duct." Oct. 19 correction notice. (Metal duct must be used in commercial construction because it better resists flame. Unlike metal, plastic duct can give off toxic fumes when heated.)

    •On Ipanema floors three through 19, "compromising air shaft with combustible materials." Oct. 19 correction notice.

    •In Rio's fire command room, not all required documents are on hand -- such as approved master exiting plan, approved fire alarm plan, approved fire sprinkler plan. "Provide these items no later than Tuesday Oct. 23 by 5 p.m." Oct. 19 fire department inspection record. (Harrah's Entertainment emphasized later it had all the documents, but not all were in the fire command, or in proper order, at the time of inspection.)

    •On floors in Rio's Masquerade tower where the Voodoo Lounge and Voodoo Steakhouse are located, accordion-style fire doors are not working so a fire watch is instituted. Oct. 18 fire department inspection record.

    •In Rio's fire command room, not all controls are labeled. "At the time of this inspection, 52 troubles were on panel -- i.e., smoke detectors troubles, ground faults." Oct. 18 fire department inspection record. (Normal procedure is to check for possible troubles indicated on fire-safety-system monitoring panel, then clear trouble signals from the panel, usually daily.)

    •"Fire doors on floors 13, 11 and 6 don't latch. Repair." Oct. 18 fire department inspection record.

    •Exploratory demolition on Ipanema's 13th and 16th floor "revealed added and/or relocated electrical work at new TV wall locations." Oct. 18 notice of violation.

    •On 18th floor of Ipanema tower, "a shaft wall compromised." Oct. 18 correction notice.

    •On 18th floor of Ipanema, "new or relocated sprinkler heads (found) in new soffits." Oct. 18 correction notice. (Changes to a fire suppression system without a permit can eventually result in a misdemeanor or felony citation to the contractor.)

    •On Ipanema's 18th floor, "in all rooms, the electrical work done above ceiling ... is not to the minimum standard." Oct. 18 correction notice.

    •On Ipanema's 8th floor, "party walls (between adjacent suites) compromised." Oct. 18 correction notice.

    •On Ipanema's 18th floor, corridor walls were compromised on the room side. Oct. 18 correction notice.

    •"Fire watches launched for Ipanema floors three through 17 'due to (unsealed) penetrations for the data cables from the rooms out to the corridors.'" Oct. 17 fire department inspection record. ( A fire watch is a continual foot patrol by personnel with two-way communication to notify onset of a fire. Data cables refer to telephone, cable TV or Internet service.)

    •Construction permits required for remodeling of 19th floor in two newer Ipanema wings. "Standard rooms on the 19th floor have been renovated into larger suites. Items include but not limited to: added doors in party walls; electrical relocation for new plasma TV locations; ... added bar with sink, lighting and electrical devices." Oct. 15 notice of violation.

    •Construction permits required for remodeling in Ipanema's two newer wings. "In standard rooms, light fixtures added over tub and in closet. TV wall has added receptacle and relocated TV low voltage conduit." Oct. 15 notice of violation.

    •In Rio's Masquerade tower, three suites are identified where remodeling without permits involved plumbing fixtures, electrical equipment, wiring and lighting. Also, "possible relocation and added walls." Oct. 13 notice of violation.

    •"Maintain (hotel's) fire alarm panel clear of all 'troubles' that are not for remodel. ... Any discrepancies on fire alarm panel that cannot be corrected will require a fire watch." Oct. 12 fire department inspection record.

    • In two Ipanema guest rooms -- one on fifth floor, one on seventh -- at bathtub locations, "the post-tension cables may have been damaged during remodel work." Oct. 12 notice of violation.

    •"New tubs were installed in all rooms floor 3-17 (in Ipanema's oldest wing) ... which resulted in compromising vertical penetration seals." Oct. 11 notice of violation. (New plumbing damaged original seals of holes drilled through concrete. The seals keep a fire's smoke and heat from traveling.)

    •"Observed new (unpermitted, uninspected) transformer and two new sub panels in the 19th floor electrical room" of Ipanema tower. Oct. 9 correction notice.

    •"Room to room thru penetrations (of walls) and ceiling to floor thru penetrations occur thru-out the 19th floor of Ipanema tower." Oct. 5 notice of violation.

    •"Concrete cores thru reinforced floor slabs made without structural review" on Ipanema tower's 19th floor. Oct. 5 notice of violation. (Core drilling removes a cylinder of concrete from the slab.)

    Contact reporter Joan Whitely at jwhitely@review journal.com or (702) 383-0268.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 14 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Fred Frazzetta wrote on November 21, 2007 06:11 AM: Ex In(s)pector: It is against the law to do remodel work which entails electrical & plumbing work without permits! Your job as an inspector was to enforce the law and more importantly protect the public.

    Josie: Tony Marnell pulled permits for all of his projects...he knows the law and actually abides by it!

    Gonzo: You hit it right on the head - this was all done because of GREED.

    Kenodave: The point of all this is the simple truth that Harrah's put the lives of their valued guests & employees in jeopardy for years - I can forgive the editing.

    Jon: Great idea...I have plenty of information & I will be happy to kick in some money.

    Surprised: Yes, they should be held accountable for their actions.

    Dodgerchuck: The inspector Richard Maddox is still employed by the County...even though he falsified a report for the direct benefit of Harrah's - it might just be me, but isn't the Building Department responsible for protecting the Public?

    Doug: Well spoken! At the Flamingo Hotel a post tension cable was severed again during core drilling a hole, and it blew through the ceiling of the floor below - what did Harrah's do: a soffit was built and the cable was hidden. Harrah's also exposed their workers to asbestos on several occasions at both the Flamingo & Harrah's Hotels, and they intentionally hid the location of the asbestos from their workers at the Flamingo! The people responsible for these remodel projects received bonuses for their stellar work, which left behind multiple now documented Public fire safety hazards.

    J: What about charges being brought against Harrah's for what they have done, and those that tried to cover it up at the County?

    Balto Bob: I concur...a job well done RJ!


    Ex Inpector wrote on November 15, 2007 06:21 PM: The RJ and you others are total BOZOS if you think that ALL hotels have'nt been doing their own remodels without permits FOREVER !!!


    Josie wrote on November 15, 2007 03:08 PM: Betcha Tony Marnell is sitting back laughing his fanny off...the RIo was run right when Tony owned it, before the collection of idiots at Harrahs' got hold of it. Too bad--it was a premier property in LV. Now, it's not even a good locals joint.


    sad wrote on November 15, 2007 02:12 PM: It is not about the safety of the Patron but about the safety of there money. Are there any problems with the count room. No matter, i will still stay at Harrah's properties.


    Gonzo wrote on November 15, 2007 01:07 PM: I can't believe this , I started staying at the Rio just after it was built. I jus loved the place when the original owners had it. When Harrahs bought the Rio it slowly started going down hill. I liked the Ipanema tower because of the strip view.It seems like every time a corporation takes over anything previously privately own they screw it up by greed. This seems to be a good example of pure greed , the director of engineering should be put away for this. These greedy bastards want every pennies , the service suffers, the employees suffer because the company cuts benefits , keeps pay low for the line workers and the big shots line their pockets with bonus's. Harrahs has taken the Rio to new lows. I stayed at the Harrah's on the strip and what a dump , dirty and the employees could care less about service..Just rake that cash in and a give it to upper management. Way to go Harrahs - you really screwed up my favorite hotel. Maybe the original owners will by it back and clean it up and get it back to where it used to be. A great hotel with great service and reasonable rates - also the hottest cocktail servers in the world !!!


    old rocker wrote on November 15, 2007 10:18 AM: Yeah, Jon, I have a thought: Do it yourself.


    kenodave wrote on November 15, 2007 09:29 AM: "These were not discovered on 18th-floor inspections" of the concrete slab shared by the 18th and 19th floors, the report reads. "These will have be addressed by an additional engineer's report."

    Nice editing.


    Jon wrote on November 15, 2007 08:46 AM: SOMEONE should start a cheap website that can easilty be googled up about all of this...Like, HarrahsUnsafe.com, and chronicle these violations. Add all the keywords people would search for when looking at hotels in Vegas, so it gets plenty of visits. Revenue loss is the only thing senior management will listen to when it comes to fixing this issue. Might cost $100 a year to get a 2 year domain name and post up a website template from goddady.com Thoughts?


    Surprised wrote on November 15, 2007 08:11 AM: Surprise, Surprise. Virginia Valentine needs to be fired. UMC and now this. Also, if their grooming Reid for a Governor run, look how he over saw the county. They need to be accountable and removed.


    dodgerchuck wrote on November 15, 2007 07:32 AM: wow,
    all these violations and the guy who was sent out there 2 check things n aug closed his inspection n 1 day?is he still pulling a ck from the county?some heads definately should roll on this 1.


    Read All Comments