Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun

sponsored by
Business


Small-town flier finds big-time trouble

Allegiant engine failures raise passenger angst

Officials at Las Vegas-based Allegiant Air are dealing with fallout from three unusual -- and unsettling for passengers -- in-flight engine problems in a little more than 60 days.

Since April 26, three Allegiant flights, two in Fresno, Calif., and another in Allentown, Pa., have been interrupted by engine problems that disturbed passengers and prompted returns to the airport for repairs.


Most Popular Stories
  • Buyout to take casino parent private
  • Chase makes takeover official
  • INSIDE GAMING: Echelon could use some tarp assistance
  • REAL ESTATE: Homebuilders hunt for land
  • TIVOLI VILLAGE: Work intensifies at mixed-use center, with first phase to open in December 2010
  • CityCenter licensing gets own hearing
  • A FEW OF THE PAST YEAR'S BIG LEGAL CASES: Recession leaves lawyers rethinking strategies
  • WORLD SERIES OF POKER: November Nine
  • Vote paves way for LV-style casinos in Ohio
  • Agency closes alterers of loans




  • No one was hurt in any of the incidents. But the loud noises, aircraft shaking and flames as well as the clustering of events have tapped into passengers' anxieties about flying and prompted Allegiant officials to pledge better communication with their customers.

    The incidents generated news coverage in Fresno and Pennsylvania and e-mails from upset passengers that were published online. They demonstrate how even an airline with a safe and profitable system can have trouble keeping pace with the spread of information, particularly if the information is dramatic, like a first-hand account of a troubled commercial jet flight.

    "I heard a loud explosion, loud enough to freak everybody out," said Michael Brush, 33, of Las Vegas about his Allegiant flight on June 21. "The whole plane shook, people started getting frantic."

    Brush said there was light smoke in the cabin and some passengers panicked.

    "Everybody was sort of unnecessarily frantic," he said.

    Airline personnel didn't make Brush and his girlfriend feel any better, he said. After the plane landed, Brush said a worker who greeted passengers said such an incident had never occurred at Allegiant before. Later, Brush was angry when he learned a similar incident had occurred just two months earlier.

    "He wasn't honest with me," Brush said.

    In the incident on April 26, an Allegiant aircraft was en route from Fresno to Las Vegas when passengers reported a loud noise. An engine had failed and the aircraft returned to the airport safely.

    The third incident occurred Sunday in Allentown, Pa.

    In that case, an engine sucked in a piece of tread that had separated from a tire, causing flames to shoot out of the engine before the crew idled it and headed back to the airport.

    No one, including the Federal Aviation Administration nor independent aviation experts, suggests Allegiant, which safely flew more than 10,000 scheduled flights in the past three months alone, is to blame for the incidents.

    The engine type involved, JT8D-200-series model manufactured by Pratt & Whitney, is considered high-quality and is in use on nearly 2,500 jets worldwide, including nearly 1,300 in the United States. Since 1992 the engine series has generated just 35 accident/incident reports with the FAA.

    In most of those incidents the engine in question was shut down and the aircraft returned safely with one engine.

    Two passengers were killed in 1996 when a JT8D-219 engine on a Delta Airlines aircraft broke up during takeoff from a Pensacola, Fla., airport and struck the fuselage, according to the FAA and news reports from the time.

    Allegiant has had no such problems and its performance compares favorably to the industry.

    In the second quarter, Allegiant's cancellation rate for any reason, mechanical or otherwise, was 0.3 percent, compared to the 1.45 percent overall rate at the nation's top 20 airports. Allegiant also has a contract with American Airlines to provide heavy maintenance on its engines, meaning Allegiant workers don't open the engines themselves.

    The engines are maintained on a regular schedule and each one is also tracked for trends that can prompt additional maintenance.

    "You have the schedule set in place, but you also want to keep an eye on everything proactively," said Allegiant spokeswoman Tyri Squyres.

    No cause has been determined for the April 26 and June 21 engine failures in Fresno. Squyres said the engines will be inspected by independent, third-party experts.

    Aviation consultant Michael Boyd of Evergreen, Colo., said the cluster of incidents doesn't indicate a lack of safety, but does show how important it is for airlines to promptly respond to any incident that upsets customers before they transmit their fears and anger to the world by text message, e-mail or cell phones that can broadcast problems in the sky before an aircraft has returned to the airport.

    "Then you have an airline with a superb track record of customer service being made to look like it is a Third World operator, which is unfair," Boyd said. "In this day and age you have to be a whole lot more savvy in dealing with customers."

    With so many instant communication options, passengers can report dramatic in-flight problems so quickly that they can be broadcast globally even before airline officials know they occurred.

    Images from a Jan. 15 U.S. Airways flight that landed on the Hudson River were posted online and picked up by national news networks by the time rescuers were arriving.

    That type of communication puts airline flight crews in the position of not only having to manage the incident, but also on the front lines of how that incident will be perceived by large audiences.

    "We have huge gossip channels now that spread around now," Boyd said. "That is another challenge airlines, and any business, have to deal with."

    The Allegiant incidents, individually and combined, were enough to generate coverage by a Fresno television station and cause passengers to question the airline.

    "This is crazy. ... I can't believe it happened again," one of the passengers on the April 26 flight wrote to Mike Scott, a CBS news anchor in Fresno who reported the incidents in detail on his blog, including 12 excerpts from e-mails and photos he received from passengers after the first mishap.

    Several passengers from the April 26 and the June 21 flights complained they didn't receive enough information from crew to calm them during the incidents or to answer their questions afterward.

    Mary Lucio of Fresno was on the June 21 flight. She said she and her husband were seated in the rear of the plane and, even though the pilot made an announcement to the cabin, she couldn't hear it over cabin noise. And she felt the information was insufficient.

    "I just can't get this whole ordeal out of my mind; we couldn't sleep the whole night; our nerves are really bothering us," she wrote to Scott.

    Another passenger from the June 21 flight who did not want her name used said she has tried to contact Allegiant for an explanation but has yet to hear back.

    She said she "can't put this behind me until I know the facts," and added that a phone number an Allegiant worker told her to call the company went to a voice mail that had no name or identifying information.

    The passenger praised the cockpit crew for landing the plane safely but said after six calls to the Allegiant number no one from the company has called her back.

    Squyres said in addition to multiple third-party inspections of the engines in question, the airline is reviewing its communication procedures in light of the incidents.

    "Based on the first incident in Fresno, we started to review our procedures, duties and communications strategy," Squyres said. "We implemented many changes in the way we communicate with our customers on the second Fresno flight and in Allentown. We recognize that we still have work to do in this area, and are looking at this very closely to provide better support to our customers."

    Contact reporter Benjamin Spillman at bspillman@reviewjournal.com or 702-477-3861.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 16 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Josh wrote on July 03, 2009 11:42 PM: Wow way to put Allegiant down and publish comments from people who don't know about aviation and always think that when a mechanical failure happens on a plane that something horrible is going to happen because the news always makes it seem like an accident will always take place. The only reason fliers are worried is because articels are published like this one. Allegiant is an excellent airline and major airlines have the same incidents taking place. The crews in all three incidents did an excellent job and the articles should be focused more on the crew instead of trying to talk about controversy and mentioning the Delta Airlines accident which took place in Pensacola which does not compare much at all with the Allegiant incidents. Also passengers need to understand that they no longer will get an immediate response from an airline about an accident/incident since anything said can be used in a lawsuit since people sue at every chance they can get.


    Report abuse

    Victoria Castelli wrote on July 02, 2009 06:04 PM: I was on flt 506. I sent a text message to my husband...."We are going down. trouble. I love you. take care". Why? Because the engine failed LOUDLY,the remaining engine began to whine, others on the plane pulled out rosaries, called or texted love ones, began to cry, the flt attendant told us to assume CRASH positions, and the pilot said he would TRY to return to Fresno. I would love to tell this story in all the raw and terrifying details to someone who cares, but Allegiant is not on that list. Arrogant, dismissive, rude, tone deaf, condescending. These words only begin to describe my experience with "Paula" at Allegiant. Lehigh Valley/ Orlando flt 746 6/27/09, (engine caught fire), flt 507 LV/ Fresno (engine quit), plus 506 in the last 3 months. Something is not right. Does someone have to get hurt? " Paula" asked, or should I say hissed, the question, "What do you want"? I really want to be wrong about ours fears that something awful is going to happen. Terrified only begins to describe how I felt. My husband said he never could imagine how people felt on 9/11, but now he does, and it defies description. At least I came home, but for 15 minutes he thought I was dead in a plane that crashed. My doctor says I have PTSD, and my husand probably does too, and we should talk this out. The NTSB is next on my list. Supposedly the engine is in Missouri at a testing facility, and the results are "weeks, months, or maybe years" away according to "Dennis" at Allegiant......years? God look over future flyers.


    Report abuse

    Hey wrote on July 02, 2009 04:28 PM: Didn't the LVRJ have an article sometime back about them contracting their aircraft maintenance to another airline?


    Report abuse

    Brad wrote on July 02, 2009 03:56 PM: I have to agree. AAY is goign to be in a world of hurt if they don't keep things open and transparent with everyone. Yes, it is easy to look for and find a given airline's safety record, but when you don't keep your own employees updated, and the public knows more about the airline than the airline, there will be troubles ahead.

    heh. Something like this happens to a Vegas-based airline, which uses very old gas guzzling rickety MD80s, and yet no-one would help out National, and they had way much better service than Allegiant.


    Report abuse

    casinocon wrote on July 02, 2009 03:47 PM: Hmmm, The comments here are frightening. I have never flown Allegiant, and I will avoid them. I don't understand how all this stuff can happen to a plane, and Allegiant still has such a low incident rating. Losing cabin pressure, and landing gear that won't work??? That, along with the engine trouble sounds pretty serious to me. I'll stick with Southwest.


    Report abuse

    Dan wrote on July 02, 2009 12:58 PM: Joe...after reading all these comments its only a matter of time before an Allegiant accident happens. God forbid that happens, the airline with the best kept secrets, oops best record will be an airline of the past, and no longer in business. Strange that your backing the employee that said it never happened before. You prob work for Allegiant. Put Ensign and his swinger friends on one these plane with engine failure.

    Tony...i agree with your comment!


    Report abuse

    ex-coastie wrote on July 02, 2009 12:26 PM: Anyone who has tried to e-mail or call Allegiant will not find this surprising. You get no answers from them.


    Report abuse

    Joe wrote on July 02, 2009 12:21 PM: Allegiant still has the best record in the industry. There are those that always complain. Saying that, Allegiant does have a communications system that is in need of revamping.

    Obviously the employee that said that it never happened before either gets no information from the company or was misinformed.


    Report abuse

    Kevin wrote on July 02, 2009 11:34 AM: Allegiant has old MD-80 aircraft, a lot of them are from other countries where maintenance standards aren't as high. They are a cheap value airline, and I'm sure maintenance is on a tight budget as well, and American their maintenance contractor has had hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines in the past couple years. Also, allegiant doesn't consider a flight canceled even when my fathers flight left TWENTY ONE HOURS late. Guess you get what you pay for.


    Report abuse

    RANDY wrote on July 02, 2009 10:41 AM: THIS STORY IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN CORPORATIONS DON'T PRACTICE GOOD CUSTOMER-SERVICE PROCEDURES. PEOPLE WANT TO BE INFORMED WHEN IT COMES TO LIFE OR DEATH SITUATIONS. AN ENGINE FAILURE COULD BECOME A TRAGIC DISASTER. THE AIRLINE TRIED TO MINIMIZE THE FACT THERE WAS A ANY DANGER. I HAVE BEEN IN THE CUSTOMER SERVICE BUSINESS FOR MANY YEARS AND IT IS A LOST ART FORM. CORPORATIONS HAVE SENT MANY OF THESE JOBS OVER-SEAS. I BELIEVE AS THE ECONOMY SLIDES, SO DOES CUSTOMER SERVICE. I COULD MAKE A LAUNDRY LIST OF BIG CORPORATIONS AND GOVERNMENT AGENCIES WHOM HAVE NO GOOD CUSTOMER SERVICE.


    Read All Comments