Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu

sponsored by
Business


CONSUMER COMPLAINTS: Vehicle repairs draw inquiry

Nevada attorney general expands number of stores under investigation

The Nevada attorney general's Bureau of Consumer Protection has expanded the number of local Purrfect Auto Service locations it has named in a deceptive-practices lawsuit.

The agency has added seven Purrfect stores to the four in its original complaint. The complaint also now includes 18 defendants who own or manage the stores, up from five defendants in the initial case.


Most Popular Stories
  • Mayor calls Lady Luck casino 'carcass'
  • CASINOS IN COURT: Testimony heard in Wynn case
  • Consolidated Resorts files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy
  • Players turned away at WSOP
  • Area economy hits 'pause' period, economist says
  • Fontainebleau files motion to leave offices
  • NEVADAN AT WORK: Local gaming veteran sees opportunity in small Henderson casino
  • FOURTH OF JULY TOURISM: Las Vegas is the place for bargain seekers
  • ONLINE GUY: Palm Pre promising but not ready to replace Apple iPhone in pocket
  • Job hunt is brutal for older workers




  • The attorney general's office alleges that the owners and managers of the Purrfect Auto Service locations in question sold unnecessary repairs to consumers and charged customers for parts that were never installed.

    The attorney general's office claims that defendant Shafik Hirji, who works for Purrfect franchisor Francare in Las Vegas, "controls in one way or another" all 32 Purrfect Auto Service outposts in Nevada, either through befriending investors and controlling managers or through reselling franchises to new investors after prior franchisees refuse to participate in the Purrfect operational model.

    Purrfect's operational platform required that locations sell additional services to at least six out of every 10 customers who responded to a low-cost repair ad, the attorney general's complaint said.

    The attorney general's Bureau of Consumer Protection, along with the Consumer Affairs Division of the Nevada Department of Business and Industry, launched a sting in November designed to find illegal sales of car-repair and maintenance services.

    Investigators took a test car to four Purrfect stores and determined that Purrfect failed to perform most services for which the company charged.

    Kathleen Delaney, a senior deputy attorney general, said the investigation into Purrfect's business practices is ongoing, and that it's possible other Purrfect locations could be added to the complaint.

    "If there are consumers out there who have had problems and want to file complaints, we need them to contact our office," Delaney said.

    Consumer complaints must be in writing. The attorney general's office does not accept complaints over the phone. Consumers can obtain complaint forms at www.ag.state.nv.us, or they can call 486-3194 and request the paperwork.

    The Bureau of Consumer Protection and the Consumer Affairs Division have received more than 250 complaints against Purrfect.

    Delaney said the case is scheduled to go to trial in February, though it's difficult to predict whether that date will hold given the ongoing investigation and the expanded complaint.

    Shafik Hirji did not return a phone call to Francare's Sahara Avenue office.

    Hirji formerly owned Paisa Inc., which was the franchisor of Purrfect Auto Service until it went bankrupt in 1999. Francare replaced Paisa as the Purrfect franchisor in May 1999.

    Several other defendants named in the lawsuit did not return phone calls by late Tuesday.

    One owner of a Purrfect location named in the complaint did speak with the Review-Journal, but he said he has owned his store for just three months and wasn't involved in the operational model the attorney general's office alleges the defendants used.

    Mouhamad Hamey, president of the Purrfect store at 3101 N. Rancho Drive, said representatives of the attorney general's office have not contacted him regarding the case. He also said he was not associated with Hirji, nor did he know how to reach Hirji.

    Setrak Mardirossian, the store's previous owner, is named in the attorney general's complaint.

    "I have built great customer relationships," Hamey said. "We do everything by the books, the honest way and the old-fashioned way. The customer has no obligation to do any services if he doesn't want to. The customer seems very comfortable with us, and we have been doing really good on our own."

    Hamey said he was concerned that news of the Purrfect investigation might hurt his business, but he hoped consumers would understand that each Purrfect owner operates the business differently.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 16 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Raymond S. Hinson wrote on November 15, 2008 05:42 PM: Dear Sir :
    I am writing this email requesting that you place Henderson Chevy on your watch list. I took my car in to have a problem address, however, upon picking up my car the problems were not completed and my transmission had only one gear. I had Henderson to work on my car two times both bills were about $1500.00 each time within 8 months.Presently, I am not requesting your assistance, however, I would like to inform you of this problems so that other customers will not be cheated the way I was. My son is the owner of the vehicle now and the car is running well ater I had a new transmission installed with a few minor repairs that was to be done by Henderson Chevy.
    So please keep your eye on The Henderson Chevy Auto Mall. I was also called by a sales person to see if I wanted to purchased a new chevy which service informed sales that my transmission was out. Thank you


    JH wrote on August 01, 2007 03:37 PM: J. Not everyone at minimum wage gets tips. Try working in fast food.


    strad wrote on August 01, 2007 03:25 PM: Stuff like this is why I put my tools to use and work on my own car. Would you believe last time I had my car in for tire balance, the shop told me my fuel filter was "rusty." I had replaced that part with my own two hands less than six months prior -- no way was it corroded! I'm sure they'd have loved to charge me an hour's labor to "replace" it though!


    John O'Neill wrote on August 01, 2007 03:01 PM: The Nevada AG will do this but will not investigate the fraud going on in the Nevada State government office of MAnufactured Housing.

    The director of manufactured housing accepts payoffs from park owners who sell mobile homes of deliquent space renters and never publish the sale date or never provide the home-owners with the cash that they collect in excess of money owed...a true criminal enterprise being run by a state employee and the AG does not care.


    John O'Neill wrote on August 01, 2007 03:01 PM: The Nevada AG will do this but will not investigate the fraud going on in the Nevada State government office of MAnufactured Housing.
    The director of manufactured housing accepts payoffs from park owners who sell mobile homes of deliquent space renters and never publish the sale date or never provide the home-owners with the cash that they collect in excess of money owed...a true criminal enterprise being run by a state employee and the AG does not care.


    wbsacto wrote on August 01, 2007 02:54 PM: Since 1996, California's Bureau of Automotive Repair has caught 15 Purrfect Auto Service shops selling unnecessary repairs during undercover investigations. Ten of the shops had their state licenses permanently revoked. Purrfect Auto is a chain of about 100 shops (mostly franchises) located in Arizona, Nevada, and California. Their practices are similar to those of Econo Lube N' Tune with a heavy emphasis on low-priced ads for oil changes, tune-ups, brakes, smog inspections, and other services.


    Danielle wrote on August 01, 2007 02:40 PM: I know for a fact that Pep Boys on Sunset is also deceptive by selling parts not needed and not putting on parts that customers paid for. In this day and age it's hard to find a trustworthy mechanic, even the dealerships will rip you off. You just have to beware of who you go to. Get an oil change at Walmart, they won't try to tell you that your serpentine belt needs to be replaced.


    The Attorney General Will Do Nothing wrote on August 01, 2007 12:30 PM: Being in criminal court virtually every day, it is well known that the Attorney General's office does not aggressively pursue cases. They negotiate almost everything down to misdemeanors or gross misdemeanors. Crimes were committed. Consumers were ripped off. I bet Purrfect Auto will get fined, and that is it. No jail time for anyone. They can change their corporate name and continue to do business. At least the District Attorney's office will actually prosecute and take a case like this to trial for the citizens of Las Vegas to render a verdict, and it won't be the anticipated gross misdemeanor. The AG's office needs some new blood in its criminal division, in my opinion.


    LAC wrote on August 01, 2007 11:47 AM: I currently work for a "franchise" repair shop here in the valley. I know for a fact that in our centers, customers are NEVER pushed to purchase services or parts THEY DON'T NEED. It's not an honest way to do business and I'm fully aware that the three my boss owns run according to Corporate and professional standards. He will also personally contact customers who are unhappy with their services or customer services and do his 100% best to keep them happy. Ask around, ask your friends, ask your realtor, ask your coworkers. And you can always contact the Better Business Bureau to see if there are complaints on a particular shop you're interested in using. If you do get ripped off, based on the amount of consumer comments here, you didn't do your homework.


    Kristin wrote on August 01, 2007 11:16 AM: Many car owners are lucky enough to have a trusted and honest local mechanic or dealership to bring their vehicle to when repairs are needed. But if you're new in town or just don't know a good mechanic, it's best to ask around for a reliable repair shop. Another option is a product like CarMD (www.CarMD.com). It's designed to give average drivers a second opinion on what repairs are needed and how much you should fairly pay for them. It costs under $90, which is about what a repair shop's going to charge you anyway. And it can easily save you from getting ripped off on car repairs.


    Read All Comments