Home subscribe manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue

News


PUBLIC HEALTH CRISIS: Clinic outcry grows

Affiliated center cited for 'similar deficiencies'



Photo by K.M. Cannon

Las Vegans who underwent medical procedures at a local clinic that reused syringes reacted angrily to news that they should seek testing for hepatitis strains and HIV, calling Thursday for the Shadow Lane facility to be shut down.

But that won't happen, state officials said, even as they revealed that an affiliated center that performs colonoscopies has been operating with "similar deficiencies."

Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

Most Popular Stories
  • NORM: Phelps galpal gets exposure on Web
  • NORM: Robin Gibb in airport standoff
  • NORM: Web site shows life of Mazzeo
  • NORM: Britney-LV buzz hard to nail down
  • NORM: Wynn coveted cathedral's land
  • DOUG ELFMAN: Comedian says his arrest a joke
  • Las Vegas police use saturation strategy to cool 'hot spots' of crime
  • 2-year-old boy dies in dog attack
  • Fresh-faced trio wows throng of youthful fans at MGM Grand
  • DOUG ELFMAN: Cab, limo drivers take pulse of tourists



  • The unspecified deficiencies, noted at Desert Shadow Endoscopy Center at 4275 Burnham Ave., near Flamingo Road, were discovered in recent weeks by the state's Bureau of Licensure and Certification. They do not rise to the level of the health risk that caused officials to send out 40,000 letters to Las Vegans about the practices of the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada at 700 Shadow Lane.

    The Burnham Avenue facility has until Monday to turn in a corrective plan of action.

    The Southern Nevada Health District is urging patients who underwent procedures at the Shadow Lane facility between March 2004 and Jan. 11 to get tested for HIV and hepatitis B and C.

    The health district was flooded with calls Thursday from patients asking about testing. Local doctors' offices were busy answering patient queries too.

    Some patients went a step further.

    Marco Cuevas, a 42-year-old construction worker, showed up at the doorstep of the Shadow Lane facility at 7:30 a.m.

    "These people have to be shut down. What they've done to people is disgusting and horrendous. I've got a wife and three kids, and I'm so worried that I'm going to pass something on to them," he said.

    Cuevas, who thinks the clinic should pay for his testing, also directed harsh comments to the doctor who is a majority owner of the facility, Dipak Desai.

    "He is a coward, a man without guts," said Cuevas, who had a colonoscopy at the facility in 2006. "He hires a public relations firm to try and make things look good while I have to worry whether I have HIV. How is this place allowed to stay open?"

    Desai has not spoken publicly about the incident. The facility on Wednesday expressed concern for its patients and said corrective action had been taken.

    Lisa Jones, chief of the licensure bureau, said the community should not expect either center to close. She said the Shadow Lane facility would receive a sanction, which will be disclosed later.

    Jones said the agency is confident that both centers will follow corrective plans.

    A third Desai-owned ambulatory surgery center, which recently opened, has been inspected too. It did not have any deficiencies.

    A Centers for Disease Control and Prevention investigator said Thursday that he did not expect good news out of Las Vegas anytime soon.

    "We're waiting for the next wave of cases from this particular clinic," Scott Holmberg said of the Shadow Lane facility. Holmberg has communicated with local health authorities, and the CDC is performing lab work in the case.

    Other developments Thursday included the following:

    • Rep. Shelley Berkley, D-Nev., called for a congressional hearing on tainted medical clinics, but she did not single out the Las Vegas facility.

    • The first lawsuit was filed in District Court by two former Endoscopy Center patients.

    • Las Vegas Mayor Oscar Goodman called for the clinic to be shut down.

    • The state's Board of Medical Examiners disclosed an investigation of physicians involved in the Shadow Lane cases.

    • Attorney general spokeswoman Nicole Moon said the office is reviewing the incident to determine whether it has jurisdiction to investigate.

    On Wednesday, District Attorney David Roger said his office "will look at all the facts and circumstances of the Health District investigation" before deciding whether criminal charges are warranted.

    The health district announced the large-scale notification on Wednesday after an investigation into how six people were infected with hepatitis C after undergoing procedures at the Shadow Lane facility between June and September 2007. Five of the individuals had undergone procedures at the center on the same day.

    After an investigation, health officials learned that the patients might have been exposed to the disease when staff reused syringes to administer medications.

    The Endoscopy Center, across from Valley Hospital Medical Center, is a high-volume gastrointestinal practice where colonoscopies are frequently performed.

    The reuse of syringes at the facility was a "common practice" undertaken by everyone from doctors to technicians, health officials said Wednesday.

    The business also was found to have engaged in other unsafe practices such as not properly cleaning endoscopic equipment used in colonoscopies and upper gastrointestinal procedures.

    The CDC's Holmberg said French scientists have found that poorly cleaned endoscopic equipment can cause an infection producing hepatitis. But he said that risk is much less than that caused by reusing syringes.

    He emphasized that everyone notified should practice safe sex and use condoms.

    The medical facility was open for business Thursday.

    Lawyers for the facility will have to go to work also.

    A lawsuit filed on behalf of Michael Cordero and Richard Taylor seeks compensation to cover the cost of blood testing and cash damages for mental anxiety while having to "wait around and wonder if your life is going to end," said their attorney, Will Kemp.

    The lawsuit names the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada as the only defendant and is intended only for patients who were not infected, he said.

    "Everybody's really distressed and dismayed," Kemp said. "The general reaction is, 'How could this happen in the United States?' This is Third World medical practice."

    Dr. Sidney Wolfe, a physician with Public Citizen, the advocacy group begun by Ralph Nader, said Thursday that the clinic "should pay for all the blood tests people need to have because it caused the problem."

    "We are talking about gross negligence on the part of this clinic," he said. "Why should people pay out of pocket or have their insurance pay for this? If this clinic is truly concerned about detecting diseases caused by its negligence, one of the best ways to show that is to pay for every test and urge people to get it done in the next week."

    Wolfe also said the Board of Medical Examiners should either suspend the licenses of the center's physicians or place them on probation, under which they could work only under the supervision of state-sanctioned medical professionals.

    "These doctors have done something that is a breach of any kind of medical practice," he said.

    Tony Clark, executive director of the Nevada Board of Medical Examiners, said the fact the center on Shadow Lane already has corrected deficiencies might mean the board cannot summarily suspend physicians.

    Clark said the board needs "hard evidence" to suspend a physician's license or place a doctor on probation.

    He said investigators will comb through the report issued by the state board of health for violations by doctors. He added that the board has subpoenaed the medical records of the six patients who contracted hepatitis C.

    The normal complaint process that can lead to a physician having his license suspended often takes months, Clark said.

    "We have to determine which doctors did what to whom," he said.

    Clark continued: "If there is not sufficient evidence to indicate a present danger by a doctor continuing to practice, then we probably will not go the summary suspension route.''

    During his weekly news conference at City Hall, Goodman called the situation a "horror show" and "unforgiveable.''

    Asked if he wanted the clinic shut down, Goodman said, "I do."

    "I have to find out if I have the authority to do it,'' he said. "If I have the authority to do it, I'm going to bring an order to show cause."

    Inspections of medical facilities such as the Endoscopy Center are required once every six years under federal guidelines, a state official said Thursday.

    And such inspections, performed by the licensure bureau under contract for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, would not normally turn up inappropriate medical practices such as those used at the Las Vegas facility, said Steve George, a spokesman for the state Department of Health and Human Services.

    The state inspections, which are unannounced, focus on interviews with staff on how they perform procedures, George said. They do not involve observing the delivery of medical care, he said.

    Inspections can occur more often than every six years, and they can be initiated if a complaint is received about a facility, he said.

    Jack Cheevers, a San Francisco-based spokesman for Medicare and Medicaid in Nevada, said the plan of correction filed by the Endoscopy Center has been accepted. A follow-up surprise inspection will occur to ensure the plan is being followed, he said.

    At that point, the federal agency will decide what, if any, sanctions will be imposed, Cheevers said. Those sanctions could include a loss of federal funding for Medicaid and Medicare patients, he said.

    Physicians' offices were busy Thursday receiving calls from their patients about where they could get testing and what the risks were.

    Dr. Constantine George, a Las Vegas internal medicine physician, said that by early afternoon, six people had come to his office requesting information.

    "They were nervous, anxious, upset and aggravated,'' he said. "We reiterated to them what the health district has said, that 'look, you may have been exposed. Now you need to be calm and get tested.'''

    George said his patients will be tested within the next day or so either at LabCorp or Quest Diagnostics. Neither of the testing centers returned repeated phone calls Thursday.

    Shelli Miller, 54, a registered nurse suffering from breast cancer, could not get in for a blood test Thursday. But she hopes to do so today.

    "I'm pretty aggravated right now. This place should have been closed years ago,'' she said about the clinic, where she had a colonoscopy in recent years.

    Review-Journal writers Sean Whaley, Brian Haynes and Alan Choate contributed to this report. Contact reporter Paul Harasim at pharasim@reviewjournal.com or (702) 387-2908. Contact reporter Annette Wells at awells@reviewjournal.com or (702) 383-0283.



    Leave Your Comment 134 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Sister Terri wrote on March 19, 2008 11:44 AM: May God continue to bless us all through this. Most people will come out fine, THANKS TO HIM! In the meantime the most important thing in life is seeking and serving God wholeheartedly. Just think of the other clinics and dr. offices who haven't been caught or won't be caught for similar atrocities? They also ruin it for the legit dr's etc. Remember the golden rule: Do unto others as you would have them to unto you. Praise God for his continued goodness through our (mankind) frailties and refusal to acknowledge Him daily as he deserves. These type of sins will continue until Jesus comes back because of our lack of wisdom to follow Him. Come Jesus Come!! Amen.


    David Smith wrote on March 16, 2008 09:53 PM: Once again the news media runs a carpet
    bombing type blame game. All of the
    doctors and nurses are guilty without a
    trial or hearing. Your story is full of misleads and lack of truths. If I were to believe your story that all are guilty, I would never go to any doctors office again, they all lack any integerity and will be careless with my health concerns.


    marv unell wrote on March 15, 2008 06:49 PM: How can I find a copy of the letter the drs wrote to the public on thurs march 12th . I was a a paid advertisment

    Thank you Marv Unell


    dj wrote on March 09, 2008 09:56 AM: The most likely scenario is that a multi-dose bottle of a medication used for anesthetic purposes such as a narcotic or benzodiazepine was contaminated. The probably occurred when a syringe was contaminated with blood that had backed up an IV line. This syringe was then used to draw medication from the multidose vial (a huge protocol violation, only a sterile needle and syringe should be used when drawing for a mulit-dose vial.) The patients that subsequently received doses from the same vial would then be at risk. I just don't see that the same syringe or needle was used over and over, it's just inconceivable that reusing syringes and needles saves any significant money. This sort of thing only happens in places where the needles and syringes are not available at all and the choice is give the medicine or not with an old syringe. The FDA may ban all multidose vials, or at least severely limit the number of doses a multidose vial can have based on this. All that it took was one careless person to cause this. The other possibility is that it was done on purpose by a deranged person (i.e. David Acer, DDS.) It is a huge leap to blame the whole cinic and everyone that works there or state that it was clinic policy to do this.


    Patient wrote on March 08, 2008 06:04 AM: Dipak Desai disciplined by Nevada State Medical Examiners:

    As managing partner of Gastroenterology Center of Nevada, charged with advertising the practice of medicine in a false, deceptive or misleading manner by stating that certain members of the medical group were Board Certified Gastroenterologists when in fact they were not board certified in Gastroenterology. Stipulated settlement: Dr. Desai to pay the sum of $2,500 as disgorgement of payments which may have been received by the group as a result of false advertising.


    kellie wrote on March 07, 2008 09:53 PM: just pay for 40,000 blood tests? ok money bag doctors,sell your toys, the lives of these innocent patients should be paid for,treatment,pain and suffering,and possibly their funerals,and the care of their families. Iam shocked and horribly saddend for all these patients.God give them strength to get through this torment. love to all of you.


    Dee wrote on March 07, 2008 04:39 PM: Davis ( you wrote) about posting the name of the attorneys. well they are already advertising the class action suits on the tv saw the ad this morning but my view is contact Bernstein,& Bernstein Attorney. They are probably the best well known Attorney. There was someone else who posted who lives in texas now who had proceedure, hope they find the attorneys too.


    Dee wrote on March 07, 2008 04:36 PM: oh and another thing now the fbi is in this and feds cause they are now reviewing the Medicare billing. All the older folks who had proceedures there probably had things done to them that were unecessary and they billed the medicare max amounts, i read. NOW when money becomes involved with the govt maybe there will be sufficient justice. Im so at a loss for the injustice of allowing these facilities to even open any of them connected to Dr.dip****.


    Dee wrote on March 07, 2008 04:30 PM: Yes thank god others feel like me these people should be brought up on attempted murder charges! they did this practice with intent to commit harm to victims. Intent coming from knowingly doing things that only happen in 3rd world countries!
    I advise everyone reading comments to write to the mayor and any other politicians you see named on stories about this. I have written the Mayor and some of the local columists on who to write to. If the people in charge cant do something maybe the voters of this city and state and nation will ban together to force some sort of actions being done to prevent this ever from happening and being sure that Justice is done for the criminals who threw out ethics and morales and Oaths for a few extra dollars! We must show the world we are not gonna stand for slaps on the wrist. We want justice for the friends and families involved in this tragedy.


    john k wrote on March 07, 2008 02:09 PM: My thouhts and prayers are with the patients and families.I totally condemn the clinics practices.

    Let's not do ethnic bashing as not all the doctors from india are bad. it is worth noting that the source of hepatitis contamination is from only one patient and this patient was under the care of DR. Carrol(along with Dr. desai and others) and he should have taken utmost precautions had he known that the clinic he partially owns had been participating in bad policy. So please folks, try to identify that only few doctors, nurses were involved here and we will ask the authorities to take imediate action. Please dont blame all the doctors and nurses from usa or other country.

    Most of the doctors and nurses are committed to the noble proffession and will uphold the oath.

    It seems some other clinics not owned by indians were engaged n similar practice, so there could be other explanation for hep-c outbreak other than this infamous syrenge-reuse theory.
    Let us hold our horses untill all the facts come out, I hope the public health officials dont keep patients panick by giving premature information to cover their defficiancy like not inspecting the facility for 7 years.

    I hope the media and lawyers take this issue in non biassed manner.


    Read All Comments