Home Subscribe Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

News


POSSIBLE EXPOSURE TO HEPATITIS, HIV: Endoscopy clinic shut down

City serves suspension order, locks center's doors



Photo by Sara Tramiel.



Photo by Sara Tramiel.




The city of Las Vegas shut down an embattled endoscopy clinic Friday afternoon, two days after an announcement that 40,000 patients could have been exposed to incurable and potentially deadly diseases because of the center's medical practices.

City inspectors entered the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada at 700 Shadow Lane about 3 p.m. to serve an emergency suspension order. After waiting until six patients had completed treatment, all employees left the building and the doors were locked.

The clinic's business license is suspended until further notice, Mayor Oscar Goodman said at a late afternoon news conference.

"The city now has the business license in hand," Goodman said. "They don't have a license to do business in the city of Las Vegas."


Most Popular Stories
  • MOUNT CHARLESTON: Four die in plane crash
  • Two couples died in crash
  • NORM: Steve Wynn goes for mega-yacht
  • FAMILY SERVICES: Three visits preceded boy's death
  • NORM: Kirshner works on big Vegas project
  • NORM: Playboy models in state spotlight
  • Body of diver who jumped off 90-foot Lake Mead cliff found
  • NORM: Playboy 'coed': Dad's OK with it
  • NORM: Elvis fan club will have star its way
  • NORM: Curtain falling on Stage Deli



  • The four doctors who are named on the license can appeal the decision to city staff and, ultimately, to District Court.

    The city also can start the process of revoking the business license outright.

    "We'll see what happens," Goodman said. "They might not ask for a hearing. We may just keep the license in our possession indefinitely.

    "As long as it's closed -- that's what the purpose of this action was."

    Nancy Katz, a spokeswoman for R&R Partners, the public relations firm representing the Endoscopy Center, said she could not comment on the closure "on the advice of legal counsel."

    On Wednesday, health officials said 40,000 people who were treated at the clinic from March 2004 to Jan. 11 of this year should be tested for hepatitis B, hepatitis C and HIV, the virus that causes AIDS.

    According to investigators, clinic staff regularly reused syringes and vials of medication on multiple patients, a practice that risked spreading communicable diseases. Six people who were treated at the clinic -- five on the same day -- have been diagnosed with hepatitis C.

    Practices have been changed at the clinic, but a sharply worded letter from the city's head licensing officer said that's not good enough.

    Clinic staff told health investigators that "they knew this technique fell well below accepted medical practice and was dangerous," wrote Jim DiFiore, the city's business services manager. "They were ordered by administrators ... to engage in this practice in order to save money."

    He added that some nurses and nurse anesthetists followed orders by administrators, principally Dr. Dipak Desai, that put patients at risk. But others refused "because they were unwilling to risk subjecting patients to life threatening diseases."

    "The fact that, once caught, you agreed not to engage in a technique well known to the medical community to subject patients to death or serious illness ... does not persuade me that you won't do it again," DiFiore wrote.

    Although the city's action Friday may ease the minds of some, information provided by the Southern Nevada Health District probably will not.

    Brian Labus, the health district's senior epidemiologist, acknowledged that the March 2004 date used as a baseline for notification of those who may have been exposed to HIV and hepatitis strains B and C at the Endoscopy Center could be off the mark.

    Even more people could have been exposed to blood-borne diseases while under- going colonoscopies and other procedures, he disclosed.

    "It is possible that more people are affected," Labus said. "We can't say what did or did not occur earlier at businesses run there."

    According to records on file with the city's business license division, the same principals -- Drs. Desai, Vishvindi Sharma, Eladio Carrera and Clifford Carrol -- have run endoscopy centers at 700 Shadow Lane since 2000 licensed under the names Endoscopy Center of Nevada Ltd. and Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada.

    The Shadow Lane Endoscopy Center operates under the umbrella of the Gastroenterology Center of Nevada, which has several clinics across the valley. Patients see physicians at the gastroenterology centers, and the tests are done at the endoscopy centers.

    Labus said investigators had access only to personnel and logs that were on hand at the facility since it was remodeled and expanded in March 2004.

    "We also were able to observe what was going on, what their practices have been since 2004," he said. "They (staff) told us that what we saw was common practice since then."

    Before 2004, many different people worked at the clinic, Labus said. "I don't know whether the center operated in the same way in the past as it did recently or not."

    Even if clinic staffers reported the procedures were the same prior to March 2004, Labus said, officials would not have been able to sufficiently document that.

    "We needed more hard evidence," he said.

    What Labus and investigators learned through recently observing center staff work was that syringes -- not needles -- and the use of vials of anesthesia medication on multiple patients were potential sources of infection.

    A syringe would become contaminated by the backflow of blood when patients with a blood-borne disease were injected with medication, health officials said. That syringe, in turn, would be reused to withdraw medication from a different vial. That vial could become contaminated and result in infection.

    By Jan. 12, Labus said, the clinic changed its procedures in line with the accepted standard of care.

    Labus said patients who are fearful of having been exposed to disease at the center before 2004 should contact their primary care physicians.

    Labus said the health district still thinks the March 2004 baseline date is best. "We know what happened since then," he said.

    Lisa Jones, chief of the state's Bureau of Licensure and Certification, said Friday that investigators have determined that deficiencies at an affiliated facility -- Desert Shadow Endoscopy Center at 4275 Burnham Ave. -- do not warrant notifications to former patients.

    The Burnham facility incorrectly allowed multiple use of drug vials. However, staff did not reuse syringes, Jones said.

    "There's no clear evidence of contamination," she said.

    She said she expects the Burnham facility to have the problem corrected by Monday.

    The city scheduled appeal hearings at 1:30 p.m. Monday and Tuesday.

    Contact reporter Alan Choate at achoate@reviewjournal.com or (702) 229-6435. Contact reporter Paul Harasim at pharasim@reviewjournal.com or (702) 387-2908.



    Leave Your Comment 88 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Anita Grace wrote on March 31, 2008 08:11 PM: I am totally shocked to learn that "DOCTORS" would risk people's lives, just to save .7 cents a person!!!!!!!!

    The question is ........................

    "HOW DID THE *DOCTOR'S* HANDLE THEIR ENDOSCOPY'S OR OTHER TESTS FOR THEM ?????"

    IF WE CAN NOT TRUST OUR OWN DOCTOR'S, WHO CAN WE TRUST ???????

    THEY SHOULD SPEND QUITE A FEW YEARS IN JAIL, IF NOT LIFE.

    YOU KNOW THEY PLACED OUR LIVES AT RISK, JUST TO SAVE A FEW PENNIES !!!!

    BUT THOSE SAME DOCTOR'S WOULD NOT PLACE THEIR OWN LIVES IN DANGER !!!!!!!!!

    "SHAME ON YOU !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

    EVERYONE I SPEAK TO ABOUT THIS IS SO ANGRY, IT MAKES ME SICK TO MY STOMACH.

    I AM WAITING FOR MY TEST RESULTS, I GOT TESTED THERE LAST MAY 17TH 2007

    MY DOCTOR "WAS" ELADIO CARRERA, CONNIE KNAPP SENT ME TO HIM.

    OUR HEALTH CARE IN NV IS THE WORST IN THE NATION !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    I HAVE A LAWYER! AND I AM SUING FOR AS MUCH "MONEY" AS I CAN GET.

    SEE THE DOCTOR'S DIDN'T SAVE ANY MONEY AFTER ALL........................

    ANITA March 31, 2008


    jeremy wrote on March 28, 2008 03:29 PM: Oh and please make sure to ask the nurse to open the bag containing the needle right in front of you so that you know it is fresh. I will always request this from now on for me and my wife! Shocked that this happens.


    jeremy wrote on March 28, 2008 03:25 PM: Here is another reason why we need Canadian style Universal Health Care where a hospital would not reuse needles to save money. It is all about the money isn't it. If you look at the health statistics of modern countries that have universal health care you will find that they have the same if not better standards of living AND they are much healthier because they go to the doctor when they are sick. This is all despite higher taxes. The money I save in taxes moving back to the US is spent for health insurance and there is no guarantee that they will stick with you when you are sick. Something needs to change.


    anoymous wrote on March 10, 2008 03:15 PM: i think its alwful putting people at risk is bad enough to sue and having these things is enough for the people to go to jail for life or for murder because they should put others before themselves and obslivouly they havent or they would have made sure ever thing was new and staralized u people out there sue them for all they have and 5fold make there lives miserable


    Kimmie wrote on March 05, 2008 08:35 AM: How dare they. That goes for everyone involved. Especially the ones that knew of the bad protocol and still obeyed it knowing that it was wrong. How could they continue working in a practice knowing what they were doing. As a health care provider, this is outragous for everyone involved. Take everyones licence away!! Not only the doctors but also the other health workers that followed this ridiculous protocol!! We are here to take care of everyone that walks into that door for help. Your standards should be the same across the board. They would not do that to there own families, so why do to others that are there to trust everyone involved.!!


    Patty in Dallas wrote on March 03, 2008 07:36 PM: How dare they?! My mother has had at least one procedure at that facility, in Desai's "care", no less. How can he and his colleagues possibly justify such callous disregard for the health of their patients? Don't give me that sad story of cutting costs in an industry that's dictated by insurance costs...I know it's a fact, but the reality is that the public literally puts their lives in the hands of strangers who swear to uphold an oath to "do no harm". You can bet if any of those doctors or staff was doing the procedure on any of their beloved relatives, they would use pristine tools and unadulterated anesthetic with no chance of contamination from any other patient. My blood is boiling. It's just not right, and I hope they lose their licenses and are never allowed to work in medicine again. That's the very least that should happen.


    Jeannie wrote on March 03, 2008 05:24 PM: I would like to know if there is also concern at the Henderson location as well. My daughter received a shot for her food handlers card before accepting a job with Albertsons in June 2007. I cannot remember the name of the place, but I believe it was on Gibson Rd.


    Jeff wrote on March 03, 2008 10:45 AM: Whats worse is already seeing ed bernstien commercials for class action lawsuits. The sharks will be circling this for a long time.


    harikari wrote on March 02, 2008 04:12 PM: It's slim pickens when it comes to any decent docs in this town for any specialty.

    They also need to go after the manufacture of the syringes and vials - they should be designed for one use only.


    protect the real victims and the future wrote on March 02, 2008 12:21 PM: I see some wise people posting that those who are not infected should not sue. This is good advise from someone who clearly has a heart and a spine. Only those damaged by this should be taken care of. And we should leave it up to them to handle it the way they see fit. There should be a focus on reform, not on lining the pockets of lawyers. Think of the problems we are soon to encounter if they shut down on E.C. locations. One should assume that there are good docs at some of these locations. Take them away and you wont be able to see a GI doc even if you have a real problem. Trust me, it is already slim picking when it comes to GI and urology docs.


    Read All Comments