Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue

sponsored by
News


BLOOD-BORNE DISEASES: Patients on clinic's bottom line

Investigators look at two dates in cluster of hepatitis C cases

In a city known for its games of chance, something resembling Russian roulette in its potential for disaster played out quietly for years in the operating rooms of a Las Vegas endoscopy clinic.

To pad the bottom line, medical professionals knowingly engaged in practices that risked spreading incurable communicable diseases among patients who were unaware of the gamble others were taking with their health, authorities say.


Most Popular Stories
  • Traffic accident claims life of longtime, successful lawyer
  • TRAFFIC STOP: Shooting accounts conflict
  • One motorcyclist killed, another critically injured in accident
  • THE FACES OF JOBLESSNESS: Family had to get help for first time
  • NORM: Buchanan called 'larger than life'
  • NORM: Marie Osmond, manager battling
  • Nurseries fence out day laborers
  • Second person dies after being restrained by police
  • REFUSING THEIR OWN MEDICINE: Vaccination policy spurs legal action
  • NORM: Agassi reveals bad vibes with Shields




  • In July and September, however, the daily dangerous gamble at the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada was lost. Six clinic patients were infected with hepatitis C, a disease that could cost them their lives.

    That cluster of blood-borne disease cases, all painstakingly traced recently by public health investigators to procedures done at the clinic on July 25 and Sept. 21, forced health care officials Wednesday to alert 40,000 Nevadans they may have been exposed to HIV and hepatitis strains B and C.

    It was the largest notification of its kind in U.S. history.

    "When you realize that we average two cases of hepatitis C in this area per year -- sometimes we have none -- you realize just how rare what happened on those two days is," said Brian Labus, a senior epidemiologist at the Southern Nevada Health District.

    The clinic was shut down Friday by city officials worried that even more disease could spread, but work on the case is far from over for Labus and staffers with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

    What happened on those two days in 2007 is a major focus. The reason: Your risk of contracting a blood-borne disease increases if an infected patient is treated before you on the same day.

    "We are getting in touch by phone and letter as fast as we can with all 120 people who had procedures on those days," Labus said. "We want them to come in."

    An investigation into the standard of care at the facility at 700 Shadow Lane by public health care professionals determined that patients who visited the center between March 2004 and Jan. 11, 2008, should get tested for the diseases as soon as possible.

    The practice of reusing syringes to administer medications and the improper cleaning of colonoscopy equipment went on at least that long.

    Labus said he and other researchers believe something far different must have happened on two days in 2007. Five people were infected on Sept. 21, one on July 25.

    "You have to remember that only 20 to 30 percent of the people infected with hepatitis C ever show acute symptoms," he said. "These have shown up quickly. Does this mean that we have many more cases on the way? I hope not. What could have possibly caused so many acute cases on the same day?"

    Labus said the 120 people called in will first receive the same kind of blood test that all 40,000 Nevadans who were exposed should get. If they test positive, genetic testing will follow to try and detect the specific strain of the virus.

    "We want to identify the source. What we're doing is medical detective work. There's no other way to put it.

    "Was the source a patient who somehow was more highly infectious? If so, why? How did it go to multiple patients so quickly on that day in September? Those are questions we want to answer."

    All employees at the clinic have been tested, he said. None was positive.

    What makes the detective work particularly challenging for public health investigators is the difficulty in determining where people were infected with hepatitis C.

    Strains of the virus mutate quickly, making it more difficult to pin down the point of transmission, according to Dr. Scott Holmberg with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Division of Viral Hepatitis.

    Las Vegas attorney Ed Bernstein has filed lawsuits on behalf of two women who say they have contracted hepatitis C while undergoing colonoscopies at the Shadow Lane center, but Labus said their infections have not yet been connected to the center. One of the women, Deborah Hall-Hilty, said her procedure was on Oct. 20, 2006.

    A woman contacted the Review-Journal Saturday and said she, too, had a colonoscopy on Oct. 20, 2006.

    "Do you think I have hepatitis?" she asked, adding she will get tested Monday.

    Holmberg explained last week that "unless we see a clear clustering ... it will be hard to impute transmission in the clinic setting."

    Labus said the health district's interviewers are trained to deal with those who receive bad news.

    "So far, I'd say we've received every kind of emotion from the people we've contacted," he said.

    Some people break down in tears, while others' anger is off the charts, he said.

    After a joint investigation by the Nevada State Board of Licensure and Certification and the health district, it was determined that syringes, not needles, and the use of vials of anesthesia medication on multiple patients were potential sources of infection.

    A syringe would become contaminated by the backflow of blood when patients with a blood-borne disease were injected with medication, health officials said. That syringe, in turn, would be reused to withdraw medication from a different vial. That vial could become contaminated and result in infection.

    While vials were inappropriately used at an affiliate of the Shadow Lane center, Desert Shadow Endoscopy Center at 4275 Burnham Ave., health officials found that syringes were not reused and no contamination resulted.

    What angers Labus is that medical professionals who took oaths that they would not harm people are behind the outbreak that he says has captured the attention of public health officials around the globe.

    "This didn't happen by accident," Labus said. "What happened here is something that every nursing and medical school teaches its students not to do. There is nothing they can possibly say that can justify what they've done."

    Contact reporter Paul Harasim at pharasim @reviewjournal.com or (702) 387-2908.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 28 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    No1uNo wrote on April 26, 2008 02:09 AM: Have you ever researched infornation about the HCV AND HIV problems that they had with the tainted blood ALONG TIME AGO? They have the CBER FDA CDC meetings online. I think it was called "LOOKING BACK" MAYBE "LOOK BACK"
    They had alot of tainted blood, my mother ended up contracting HCV. We found out about it in 2002. They sent her to the office on Flamingo. They KNEW the moment we walked in the office why we were there, the did all the test for it. She got it from Blood transfussions. The meetings are very informative,


    Report abuse

    Pamela Wells wrote on March 05, 2008 05:24 PM: This story has been CENSORED everywhere outside of Nevada. Gee, I wonder WHY? :-)

    Nevada has no laws that are enforced. Read the statues, people! If a sitting judge decides he doesn't like the statute, he doesn't have to follow it!

    There will be no punishment, and, as usual in Nevada, it's the powerless who will pay --- in this case, maybe with their lives.

    Welcome to Nevada, folks! This is Nevada to a T!


    Report abuse

    Bloodborne Disease wrote on March 03, 2008 09:10 AM: I had a procedure at this same clinicl. The nurses, Doctors and everyone was wearing gloves. Why do you suppose they were wearing gloves? Because they know that diseases are transmitted through the blood and bodily fluids and they did not want to catch something from me. Yet they put my life at risk by exposing me to other peoples blood. The Doctor, the nurses, the anthesiologists and anyone who worked at clinic should go to jail. They knew better, they went to school and learned about bloodborne diseases and yet they don't care. I think that everyone who worked there must have been getting paid extra to keep thier mouth shut or someone would have told of thier illegal practices.


    Report abuse

    Carmella Michelli wrote on March 03, 2008 12:30 AM: I am a 66 yr old women, lived a clean hard life raised 6 children, I was sent to this clinic with a appointment, well the doctor was 2 hours late, people were sitting like cattle waiting, the doctor shows up and I get ten minutes of his time, telling when to setup a appointment for the first procedure, the day comes hes late again,haven't ate since the day before, they take me to another room where 20 people are sitting in growns ( men and women )waiting for their turn.. The procedure was the same! I felt like they were doing it for free and you just had to wait for as long as they wanted you to wait, starving for food and something to drink for hours, nice treatment!!! and now I am one of these people that have to pay to see my doctor, then go to a lab to get tested and pay them. coming out of my little social sucurity check while the big wigs go play golf and let these lawyers handle their mistakes and greed!!! They should lose everything and go to jail!!! Doctor Desai and his partners should be ashamed of what they did, This disease can show up 1 or 2 years from now and it will be forgotten about...I'm beside myself, Can't eat, Can't sleep, and guess what none of 40,000 people did nothing wrong!!! I wonder what these doctors would do if this happened to one of their family? Dr Desai has a wife who is also a doctor and children, how would he feel if this happen to one of them? disgusting !!!! I will wonder until wednesday my blood test, what will it read? All these hospitals need to be cleaned up!!!!


    Report abuse

    really now wrote on March 02, 2008 07:45 PM: this is one case where the people should not settle for the money. They will, because in our country today.....that is what law suits are about, getting a little money. Sadly enough but they will settle for money rather than justice. This guy has the cash and connections to slide out of this unharmed. If you put a price on someone's life, as we do, then it sends a message that these things are ok in our society. DON'T SETTLE FOR THE MONEY.......SEE JUSTICE BE DONE AND SEND THIS GUY TO PRISON.


    Report abuse

    one of wrote on March 02, 2008 07:39 PM: I agree, everyone should take the money and be done with it. I'm sure this Dr. won't do this again under a different entity.....he knows better now, he got caught. Just settle this and give the people sy $50,000 each and be done with it all. he can afford to settle this.....i'm sure he's already thought about 'the day he gets caught'. He is probably surprised it took the stupid state of Nevada so long to catch on.

    TAKE THE MONEY AND RUN.


    Report abuse

    Money for mah honey wrote on March 02, 2008 07:36 PM: shelling out a couple of million to settle this case is a drop in the bucket to these Doctors. Why do you think they did this in the first place.

    I say, these people sue him for 3 million, let him be on his way. He will apply for licensing under a different entity and all is good.

    Settle for the money honey. Let him go free!!!!!!!! People like this can buy their way out of trouble. OJ did it, so can Desai. Only the poor serve time in prison. Prison is for the poor. All others 'connected' or 'vested' turn money over to the county in fines and patients for their 'inconvenience' and everyone's happy!!!!!!!!!!

    Happy endings = $$$$$$$$


    Report abuse

    vs Dr. wrote on March 02, 2008 07:17 PM: please don't take offense to this, but i see something like this happening.

    Class action case......Dr. agrees to settle with the patients for say......$2,000,000.00 (price of his parking lot)....the people settle. The doctor never goes to trial. Everyone's happy....money to be had. To Dr., this is like paying a traffic ticket to you and me.

    What I'd like to see is this........Class action and then some, attorney presents this as attempted murder, goes to trial.....the Dr. gets life.

    People....tell me the difference between the two cases I mention:

    Ronald Jayne didn't intentionally kill 8 people. He knew that drinking and driving might put others' lives at risk, but he decided to drive anyways. Because he has not money to offer the victims, he goes to prison for 64 years on charges of murder.

    Dr. didn't intentionally kill 40 people. he knew that using dirty vials and syringes might put others' lives at risk, but he dicided to do it anyways. Because he has money.......he gets to pay monetarily for his immoral decision. No prison time served.

    This Dr. cannot get off by paying his way. PLEASE DO NOT LET THIS HAPPEN.


    Report abuse

    John wrote on March 02, 2008 06:53 PM: As I sit here and read my textbook, "Calculate with Confidence" the college textbook in a nursing school curriculim, I am AMAZED!
    You see, I'm pretty sure the "profrssionals" who were drawing up those meds at this place were not professionals at all; but rather, cheap medical technician labor that made 7 or 8 bucks an hour...that way you see, the docs who own the prectice make more money. If they don't have to pay $35 or $40 an hour for a college educated health care professional, then they can buy a slightly larger boat or a faster airplane.
    My mother in law is one of the 40K and she vividly remebers how unprofessional the staff was. They were rude, aloof, and treater her like she were just another cow going to slaghter.
    I hope all those neat toys, houses, luxo cars, and McMansions are in somebody elses name docs!


    Report abuse

    Mike wrote on March 02, 2008 03:02 PM: Let me stipulate that what the doctors and staff did at the clinic is morally reprehensible and they should be punished to the full extent of the law. And yes, I am one of the 40K.

    However, my wife has Hep C and she had the disease for 25-30 years before receiving a liver transplant last year. During 20 of those years, unaware that she had Hep C, she drank alcohol excessively, a known
    contributor to more rapid disease progression.
    In spite of this, she led a completely normal life up until a couple of years ago.

    We have been married 16 years and I have never contracted the disease. It is very difficult (though not impossible) to transmit Hep C through sexual contact in a monogomous relationship.

    My point here is only to alleviate some of the panic being experienced by my fellow victims. Hep C is a dangerous disease, and should be monitored closely, but most people can live normal lives for many many years with no symptoms or ill effects.

    We learned an important lesson in dealing with my wife's illness: don't waste your energy thinking "what if this or that terrible event happens?" Take it one day at a time.


    Read All Comments