Home subscribe manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

News


Husband, wife suspect clinic source of infection



Photo by John Locher

For more than a year, Deborah Hilty kept asking herself what she did wrong.

She had hepatitis C and no clue why.

Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

Most Popular Stories
  • NORM: Penthouse wants piece of the Strip
  • RAMPAGE ENDS IN SUICIDE: Man runs amok in Las Vegas
  • ROBBERY-HOMICIDE CASE: Juror sent flirtatious messages
  • Father mourns his daughter
  • NORM: 'Joe the Plumber' too booked for LV
  • Judge asks court to release son arrested after crash that killed girl
  • NORM: Strip club owners, 'Vinny' part ways
  • Police ask: Are there others?
  • Anger over cuts reaches fever pitch
  • Working beneath Lake Las Vegas



  • Every day the 58-year-old day care owner talked about it with her husband, Robert. Every day they were left with more questions than answers -- until last week.

    Robert Hilty, 52, came home from work Feb. 27 and flipped on the television.

    He saw a special news bulletin. Something about contaminated medicine vials and hepatitis and HIV. Then he saw the address, 700 Shadow Lane. He knew that address.

    He rushed to the converted garage where his wife cared for special-needs children. Turn off the cartoons, he said, you have to see this.

    In that moment, Deborah Hilty suddenly had the answer she had been wracking her brain over since January 2007.

    "I thought, 'Oh my God. Somebody gave this to me,'" she said. "Here I am, for a year, thinking I did something."

    Two days later, the couple filed a lawsuit against the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada and the doctors who own it, alleging she contracted the disease during her Oct. 20, 2006, colonoscopy.

    An investigation by state and local health officials found nurse anesthetists at the center reused syringes on infected patients and contaminated single-use vials of medicine that were shared among multiple patients, spreading infection.

    The Southern Nevada Health District has linked six hepatitis C cases to the clinic and has recommended 40,000 patients who were at the clinic between March 2004 and Jan. 11 get tested for HIV and hepatitis strains B and C.

    Two other patients with hepatitis C, including one of the initial six, have filed lawsuits against the clinic, and several Las Vegas law offices said they are preparing lawsuits involving more than a dozen other patients who think they contracted hepatitis C, HIV or other diseases at the clinic.

    Two lawyers said they have cases in which patients died from hepatitis C.

    Before Deborah Hilty's diagnosis, she and her husband didn't worry much about death.

    After 17 years of marriage they looked forward to retirement -- her from the day care business and him from a 30-year carpentry career -- and traveling the country in their fifth-wheel trailer.

    That changed 13 months ago when a blood test turned up elevated liver enzymes. Her doctor confirmed she had hepatitis C.

    She cried her eyes out on the drive home.

    "It was the most horrible ride in my entire life," she said. "How do you go home and tell your husband you contracted a fatal disease, and you may have given it to him?"

    Robert Hilty said he did not get tested because the chance of transmission was low but now is trying to get tested.

    Deborah Hilty plans to get tested for HIV. If she tests positive, she will have to close the day care, where she watches nine children, most of them with autism, she said.

    Her positive hepatitis C test came during a routine blood screening that she gets every six months to monitor a condition in which her pancreas secretes too much acid into her stomach, she said. She takes medication to control the condition, which also required at least two procedures at the endoscopy center in 2005 and 2006, she said.

    She was diagnosed with hepatitis C three months after her last procedure there, she said.

    "I know I couldn't have possibly gotten it anywhere else," she said.

    But health officials might not ever know for sure where or when she contracted the disease, said Brian Labus, the health district's senior epidemiologist.

    Patients with chronic hepatitis C do not show symptoms, making it all but impossible to narrow down the time period when they could have contracted the disease, he said.

    But patients with acute hepatitis C show symptoms within about six months, which gives investigators a narrow time frame to focus on and find the source of the infection, he said.

    That is how health investigators connected the recent outbreak to the endoscopy center, he said.

    Health officials encourage people with the disease to look ahead, not back.

    "For those people, at this point it doesn't matter where you got it," Labus said. "You have it, and you have to focus on protecting your health."

    The Hiltys said they worry about how long she has until the disease takes its toll. Hepatitis C can lead to cirrhosis of the liver and liver cancer.

    They worry that if she undergoes treatment, the fatigue, nausea and other side effects will prevent her from running her day care.

    They worry about finding a doctor in Las Vegas they can trust.

    "I'm not letting anybody touch her now," Robert Hilty said. "If I have to go out of town, I will. None of these whackos here are going to touch her."

    For now they are taking it day by day, searching for answers and hoping their lawsuit holds the medical workers responsible while preventing something like this from happening again, they said.

    "You swear when you enter the medical profession you do no harm," she said. "What happened to that?"

    Contact reporter Brian Haynes at bhaynes@reviewjournal.com or (702) 383-0281.



    Leave Your Comment 29 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Jenny wrote on March 06, 2008 05:07 AM: Depending on the strain of Hep C, and your overall health, there are treatments. I applaud the Hilty family for going public and suing. Hopefully their suit will force the clinic to pay for EXPERT treatment, for ALL the victims.

    I would advise the Hilty's and others to find a PATIENT ORGANIZATION for Hep. patients. They often maintain lists of specialists around the US as well as "centers of excellence". In addition, they generally have a lot of info as well as peer support forums.


    Kent wrote on March 05, 2008 11:35 PM: I checked the website of Nevada Examiners Board of Review the other day and Desai was cited for false information on his employees being board certified several years ago. He was lightly fined.


    JenniferK wrote on March 05, 2008 10:42 PM: Some clever person posted a link to the resumes of the doctors who work at the Endoscopy Center and its related clinics. Dr. Desai's resume is unbelievably prestigious:

    Professor at UNLV Med School, Head of Gastroenterology Department

    Head of Gastroenterology Department at UMC

    Head of Gastroenterology Department at Valley Hospital

    Former head of Gastroenterology Department at Sunrise Hospital, and still has privileges to admit patients there

    I wonder why the news organizations are not making these points? Dr. Desai is not some insignificant immigrant doctor working out of a back street office, seeing a high volume of poor patients. This man holds positions of serious importance in the medical community.


    A Fat Cat wrote on March 05, 2008 06:49 PM: I got my test results back and found I was negative on all three blood pathogens. I did find out I have high cholesterol, but I can live with that.

    I went in for a test on June 16, 2006 and was nervous the past 5 days. They have put 40,000 people through hell and I hope these doctors/nurses get what is deserved to them.


    George wrote on March 05, 2008 06:03 PM: New book released today by Dr. Dipak Kantilal Desai: 40,000 reasons not to visit Las Vegas.


    Hippocrat wrote on March 05, 2008 05:40 PM: Wouldn't a nurse question the practice?


    Ellen wrote on March 05, 2008 05:13 PM: My heart goes out to the family. Actually all of the families. I know 3 people who have recieved letters. I dont think we can comprehend the magnitude of this. The people that infected other people, the blood donated, the babies that were born to infected individuals, ect. The family histories that will be ruined.
    What in the HE11 were these people thinking??? I hope they are sent to prison for the rest of all of their lives.


    art caprario wrote on March 05, 2008 05:02 PM: Doctor Desai needs to have his passport taken away before he trys to leave the country. His worth a great amount of money and had done a great deal of harm. His presents in a courtroom to account for his actions is a necessary. He must not be allowed to escape!
    He should be arrested and charged with murder and attempted murder, as well as all other appropriate charges, such as depravated indifference, etc.


    shirley crockett wrote on March 05, 2008 04:16 PM: How can i find out if i need to get tested i went to and got a test a colon ostiphy by Dr. Quak and i went on shadow lane to blood work


    Sheila wrote on March 05, 2008 03:54 PM: I think this is the most unprofessional act of gross negligence I have ever seen. Both of my parents are patients of these centers and are currently being tested. As a legal Assistant, of course I have recommended them to retain an attorney. Is this the type of medical care that our seniors can look forward to? Is this what the middle-aged generation has to look forward to? I hope they never see daylight again, doctors and nurses alike. Next medical costs will explode. Manufacturers will find a way to produce medical supplies that cannot be cleaned. As hard working citizens and constituents we do not stand a chance. May God bless these patients with a speedy resolution. From the State of Virginia


    Read All Comments