Home Subscribe Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri

News


PUBLIC HEALTH CRISIS: LV patient feels at fault

Hepatitis C carrier says he was at clinic on key date



Photo by Craig L. Moran

Sitting at his dining room table, a patient of the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada tried to comprehend how on Sept. 21, 2007, some of his blood might have made its way into the bloodstream of five other patients, infecting them with hepatitis C.

"I know it wasn't my fault rationally, but you can't help but feel guilty," said the 58-year-old, who underwent a colonoscopy on that key date, one that health officials have definitively linked to a cluster of local hepatitis C cases.

"I was there that day. I was one of the first patients treated. I have hepatitis C. ... Common sense would tell you, it was me."

The patient and his wife spoke to the Review-Journal this week on condition of anonymity, saying they feared for their safety. The man, a sales representative for a national company, was diagnosed with hepatitis C in 2000 by a Las Vegas physician who does not work at the clinic.


Most Popular Stories
  • LANDLORD: AS TENANT, FLEISS FOR THE BIRDS
  • Experience Ending
  • NORM: Owner Jay-Z says 40/40 Club is fine
  • JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE COMMISSION: Panel suspends Halverson
  • 1958 CRASH: DEATH IN DESERT AIR
  • CALICO BASIN: Tranquillity lost
  • NORM: 'Idol' contestant set to go country
  • NORM: Jackson in action possibly in Vegas
  • NORM: Cruise the object of a twin crush
  • NORM: Oprah to tape in LV with Tina, Cher



  • He said he was a patient for the past five years at the Shadow Lane clinic that has come under fire. He had two surgical procedures there. His blood-borne disease, he said, is well-documented at the clinic.

    He and his wife live in a gated community in Summerlin and have three children. They have retained an attorney.

    His physician, he said, was Dr. Clifford Carrol.

    "People see hepatitis like they do lepers," said the man's wife, who works at a casino. "They don't understand that it is only transmitted through blood."

    Though it hasn't been determined exactly where or how her husband contracted the disease, the couple believes transmission occurred during a blood transfusion in the 1980s, when testing blood for diseases wasn't as much of a priority as it is today.

    "It's conceivable that's when I contracted it," said the man, who was born and raised in Long Island, N.Y. "It's a very slow-moving disease. You can have it for years before you become symptomatic."

    There is no vaccine or cure for hepatitis C, which is spread through direct contact with the blood of an infected person.

    After the man was diagnosed with the disease, the couple said, their lives changed dramatically.

    "Precaution," he said. "That's all we know."

    The man does not share personal items with his family such as hair brushes, nail clippers or bath towels.

    "I don't share shavers with my sons," he said, looking in the direction of a computer where a teenager was playing video games. "I have my own towels.

    "You have to be cautious because it is easy to slip up. I get paranoid if I get a little cut."

    He said he wondered how everything would have turned out if the clinic had been as careful.

    Nancy Katz, a spokeswoman for R&R Partners, the public relations firm representing the Endoscopy Center, declined to comment Wednesday.

    Federal and state health officials found that nurse anesthetists at the center reused syringes on infected patients and contaminated vials of medicine that were shared among patients. Six patients have tested positive for hepatitis C. Five of those were treated on Sept. 21; the other patient was treated on July 25.

    Health officials have sent letters to 40,000 of the clinic's patients, urging them to get tested for hepatitis C and B and HIV, the virus that causes AIDS.

    The couple learned of the massive patient notification last week.

    The man's wife recalled: "When I heard that five people may have been exposed on Sept. 21 and they had not yet found the source, I thought to myself, 'He was there in the fall. He had a colonoscopy there.' I went upstairs, grabbed my 2007 calendar, and there it was -- that date.''

    The man said he arrived at the facility between 6:30 a.m. and 7 a.m. for his colonoscopy. His wife went with him. And his medical bills from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Georgia confirm he went to the clinic that day for a colonoscopy.

    Records show that the Endoscopy Center billed Blue Cross $850 for the surgical procedure and its affiliated Gastroenterology Center of Nevada $560 for anesthesia.

    Officials with the Southern Nevada Health District called the couple's home on Friday, they said.

    The health district representative asked the man whether he could come down to its office in late March for blood work. He was told to bring his ID. The Sept. 21 visit to the clinic was brought up during the conversation, the man said, though he couldn't be sure whether the health district representative had been the one who initially mentioned it.

    Dr. Scott Holmberg, an investigator with the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, wouldn't comment specifically about any particular hepatitis C case, nor would he say whether the health agency had contacted Nevadans involved in the spread of the disease. He did say, though, that health officials were contacting individuals who might be "putative index" cases, or sources of the infections, on July 25 and Sept. 21.

    Brian Labus, senior epidemiologist for the Southern Nevada Health District, said the agency is trying to reach known carriers of hepatitis C who had procedures at the clinic on those dates.

    He would not confirm whether the man is on the list of patients the health district was trying to reach, or whether he already had been notified. But, he said, if someone contacted the man about getting a test at the health district, the call probably came from his office, not the CDC.

    "Even though we may know that they may have hepatitis C, we need to do additional genetic tests on the virus that they have to complete our investigation," Labus said. "For those particular days, we're interested in what happened, and we do want to figure out the train of transmission. Overall, there are going to be a lot of people who will have positive results. We just have to figure out if they got it from the clinic. That's going to be difficult."

    As for clinic patients who knew they had hepatitis C, Labus said, they should not feel guilty because it's not their fault.

    "Transmission occurred because of the behavior of people at that clinic," he said. "I don't want anyone to think they did anything wrong. When you go to a medical facility for health care, you should be protected. That did not occur here. No one should feel responsible for the actions of others."

    The Shadow Lane patient called the clinic "a very active place."

    Upon his arrival in September, he noticed a handful of patients in the office. Within 30 minutes, he was called into a room where the procedure was done. It took about 45 minutes, and the couple spent roughly three hours at the facility, his wife said.

    The man said he had follow-up at the clinic about a week later. He was told things had gone well. He had a few polyps, which he said were clipped.

    His wife has a colonoscopy scheduled this month with Dr. Dipak Desai, majority owner of the Shadow Lane clinic.

    "Suffice to say, I won't be going," she said. "I have reservations about getting colonoscopies in general now."

    The man said he doesn't know whether he'll ever be able to get over the fact that his diseased blood might have gotten into someone else's bloodstream.

    People with HIV who knowingly infect others are subject to criminal charges, he and his wife said. Why should this case be any different, they said.

    He said, "Ten words would have saved five people from this horrible disease: Make sure everything is clean and sterile. Do not reuse."

    Contact reporter Annette Wells at awells @reviewjournal.com or (702) 383-0283.

    Links powered by inform.com


    Leave Your Comment 52 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    p wrote on March 07, 2008 06:14 AM: My thouhts and prayers are with the patients and families.I totally condemn the clinics practices.

    Let's not do ethnic bashing as not all the doctors from india are bad. it is worth noting that the source of hepatitis contamination is from only one patient and this patient was under the care of DR. Carrol(along with Dr. desai and others) and he should have taken utmost precautions had he known that the clinic he partially owns had been participating in bad policy. So please folks, try to identify that only few doctors, nurses were involved here and we will ask the authorities to take imediate action. Please dont blame all the doctors and nurses from usa or other country.

    Most of the doctors and nurses are committed to the noble proffession and will uphold the oath.

    It seems some other clinics not owned by indians were engaged n similar practice, so there could be other explanation for hep-c outbreak other than this infamous syrenge-reuse theory.
    Let us hold our horses untill all the facts come out, I hope the public health officials dont keep patients panick by giving premature information to cover their defficiancy like not inspecting the facility for 7 years.

    I hope the media and lawyers take this issue in non biassed manner.


    PSPam wrote on March 06, 2008 11:16 PM: To the Hep C patient - You have no reason to feel guilty. You said the 10 words *"Make sure everything is clean and sterile. Do not reuse."* That was up to the CLINIC to pay attention and follow those guidelines - even if you hadn't disclosed your Hepatitis C status it would still fall onto the clinic! That is the purpose of universal precautions so I do hope that you can get past this guilty feeling quite soon! You were not at fault at all! Think how many people don't know they have this disease and are inadvertently spreading it because they haven't been tested. Everyone should GET TESTED for Hepatitis C! KNOW YOUR STATUS! Ignorance is not bliss! Take care. I know what Hep C feels like. I have cirrhosis.


    Ho Ho Diet wrote on March 06, 2008 10:50 PM: Is Venger really on a Ho-Ho diet? I'm guessing Arnold Awand is on the same diet?


    BarneyFife wrote on March 06, 2008 08:12 PM: Hey Barn, watcha readin'.
    Nothin' Andy. Hey leave me alone.
    Barn, let me see that.
    Awww Andy.
    Holy cow Barn, where'd you get this stuff.
    Geez Andy, don't embarrass me.
    Hey Barn, I think these are great.
    The Neurosurgeon's Guide to Beauty Secrets
    by Ben Venger, MD
    The Neurosurgeon's Guide to Weight Loss and
    Body Sculpting While on a Ho-Ho Diet
    by Ben Venger, MD
    The Gastroenterologist's Guide to Public
    Relations In The Face of a Huge Catastrophe
    by Deepak Desai, MD
    The Surgeon's Guide to Surviving a Second
    Degree Murder Conviction
    by Harriston Bass, MD
    Las Vegas....What Happens Here Stays Here!
    by LVCVA

    Hey Barn, can I read these when you're done.
    Sure Andy, promise me you won't tell anyone about this.
    Pinky promise Barn.
    Andy, you're the best.


    desai's salary wrote on March 06, 2008 07:20 PM: GI Jock Doc:
    I know you are joking, but Desai truly has way more than that. He doesn't have a mortgage; he bought a $3.4 million house CASH. He has 5 cars, one of which is a custom made Benz worth $300,000. He owns a $1.6 million parking lot and, at least in 2006, owned more shares than Andre Agassi and Maloof in a bank (see: http://sec.edgar-online.com/2006/03/06/0000950123-06-002634/Section19.asp). You want to see his "monthly nut"? He gets $865 per colonoscopy, and about $600 for anesthesia per procedure. At 40,000 procedures over 4 years, he does 10,000 per year at roughly $1000 per procedure. That is $10 million per year for the group. Overhead is about $1 million (and yes, they save BIG on cleaning and anesthesia). 10 of the non-owner docs are paid $300k per year, or 3 million per year. Desai gets roughly 65% of 7 million or $4.5 million per year, just from colonoscopies alone. This is the figure he has told people before. Keep in mind he probably made more before 2007 when colonoscopy reimbursement went down. Also keep in mind he is a shrewd business man, and owns banks, parking lots, and gas, stations throughout the valley, which earn him even more money. Plus he has been doing this for years, and by now has tens of millions in stocks, which he gets an 8% return on. So he probably makes $6-7 million / year when all is said and done.


    GI Jock Doc wrote on March 06, 2008 06:58 PM: Hey! I'm a GI Jock Doc and I want all you sniveling little insects to get off my a&&.

    I gotta $10,000 a month mortgage, five cars, and kids in private schools. I'd like to see you little gnats make my monthly nut. I'll flick you away like a little piece of cr@p on my colonoscope.

    Profits before patients! Why in the he11 do you think I went to medical school?

    Hepatitis isn't so bad anyway! It just means you have to see yer GI Jock Doc more often. That's more procedures and more office visits for me, OK?

    It's a win-win for me and mine. I cut the anesthesia and other costs WAY down AND I get more patients at the same time!

    Dr. Ashley, I'm ready for the UNLV School of Business to bestow my honorary MBA now.

    Vegas butts is full o' brown gold! Yee Ha!


    ET wrote on March 06, 2008 06:02 PM: Hang em . they are killing your children.


    p wrote on March 06, 2008 05:56 PM: Dr. carrol should have taken all the precautions to preven infection from spreading to rest of the patients.
    Shame on you dr. carrol. dr. desai.

    Lets not assume all the doctors and nurses are bad as awhole and take needy action on bad apples.


    Jose wrote on March 06, 2008 04:49 PM: We need to find out who this man is and have him arrested. We must stop him before he infects more citizens!


    MLW wrote on March 06, 2008 04:27 PM: These greedy sob's are affiliated with 6 clinics here in Nevada; are they associated with clinics in other states? If they insisted on these unsafe practices here you can bet these same practices would have been endorsed in other places also. To the man and his family this article was about - don't blame yourself - you did not do anything wrong - just hollow words but I do mean them.


    Read All Comments