Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon

sponsored by
News


BUILDING AND FIRE SAFETY: Audit blasts inspectors

Favoritism toward commercial property owners revealed




Clark County building and fire inspectors have been "derelict" in their duty to keep commercial buildings safe, according to a scathing outside audit released by the county Wednesday.

Falsified reports, inadequate record-keeping and favoritism toward commercial property owners were found by New York-based consultant Michael Kessler. His 97-page report is posted as "Kessler Report" on the county's Web site at www.accessclarkcounty.com.


Most Popular Stories
  • Traffic accident claims life of longtime, successful lawyer
  • TRAFFIC STOP: Shooting accounts conflict
  • One motorcyclist killed, another critically injured in accident
  • THE FACES OF JOBLESSNESS: Family had to get help for first time
  • Nurseries fence out day laborers
  • NORM: Marie Osmond, manager battling
  • Second person dies after being restrained by police
  • NORM: Buchanan called 'larger than life'
  • REFUSING THEIR OWN MEDICINE: Vaccination policy spurs legal action
  • NORM: Agassi reveals bad vibes with Shields




  • Inspectors' "general lack of concern and sense of urgency regarding complaints" demand a "significant change to ... current practices," Kessler wrote.

    "A vast injustice" is his description of a discrepancy between how homeowners were treated, compared with owners of multifamily housing or commercial properties. The county regularly charged penalties and investigative fees to homeowners for violations that went through building inspectors, while it let commercial owners duck the fees. "Kessler recommends that penalties be assessed uniformly and consistently to all property owners who are guilty of violations," the report reads. Claims that some elected county leaders and inspectors have kowtowed to large property owners in ways that eroded building safety are also included.

    "The failings need to be disclosed, and addressed," Ron Lynn said Wednesday afternoon about the audit, which the county received in its final form Tuesday night. Lynn supervises county building inspectors in his role as director of development services.

    "These are going to result in personnel actions," is how County Manager Virginia Valentine described the step that county administrators will next take, which is to investigate the problems and possible problem employees pinpointed by Kessler. It is premature to say whether firings will result, she said.

    Kessler recommended bringing law enforcement into the investigation. Valentine said the county shared the report Wednesday morning with representatives of Las Vegas police, the Clark County district attorney's office, the Nevada attorney general and the U.S. attorney's office.

    The report is based, in part, on Kessler's analysis of complaints lodged during three months in 2006. He looked at the length of time from when a complaint was opened to when the targeted building was inspected, to when the complaint was closed.

    Some complaints were not logged appropriately, according to Kessler. Statements by the individuals complaining were not always recorded accurately. "Resolutions were falsified," he wrote. In several instances, records gave dates claiming that cases were assigned and inspected before the dates complaints were received.

    "And, proper and complete documentation" was not always kept, the consultant added, which means that documentation essential for determining liability, should a safety matter later land in court, went missing.

    The Kessler report covered only how the county handles safety complaints about commercial buildings, not the process by which the Clark County Public Response Office -- CC PRO, for short -- handles most safety complaints about private dwellings.

    Some commissioners "exerted undue influence" on fire department managers, according to an allegation Kessler received from lower fire department personnel, whom he interviewed but did not identify by name.

    "Staff complained that on more than one occasion they were directed by (fire department) management not to write violations concerning life safety issues," the report said. Kessler did not delve into the behavior of commissioners because the scope of his contract was to examine handling of safety complaints.

    As to inspectors, Kessler wrote he repeatedly was told that inspectors who check out safety complaints at hotels were reluctant to create a hostile relationship because the hotels gave them comps including "meals, show tickets, stays at other properties and branded clothing."

    The county responded to Kessler's report by unveiling proposals it has been working on since autumn to revamp its building division and fire departments, which it will submit to county commissioners Tuesday.

    Ethics training and classes in report writing and investigation techniques are recommended for some personnel by Kessler, steps that county administrators agree with.

    "If they can't see that bright line (delineating ethical behavior from corrupt), they need to know where it is and what happens when they cross it," Valentine said. The Kessler report recommends the training; it is included in the staff proposal that commissioners will get Tuesday.

    The county released Kessler's report in a form that identified employees only by job title and numeral, such as Building Inspector 9 or Supervising Inspector 2. But the Review-Journal pressed Wednesday for the identities, resulting in a decision by the district attorney's office to release names with a disclaimer that the county "does not take responsibility for the veracity" of Kessler's statements, whose accuracy the county could not yet verify by late Wednesday afternoon.

    Supervisor Inspector 2 turned out to be Rick Maddox, the former county employee who handled the August 2006 complaint into remodeling without permits or inspections at the Rio. That matter triggered a Review-Journal exposé published in early October and led county commissioners in November to hire Kessler.

    According to the audit, data from a global positioning device in Maddox's county vehicle showed it was parked at the Rio for 38 minutes on the day that Maddox claimed to have checked 37 guest rooms.

    Maddox told Kessler that Rio staff changed the floor number appearing on the elevator's display to make it appear he was visiting the 19th floor, when in fact the elevator had stopped at the 18th floor.

    "These people aren't completely honest," Maddox told Kessler, according to the audit.

    County investigation eventually proved the newspaper's contention that regular rooms, on the 19th floor only, had been converted during remodeling to larger, fewer suites.

    In a September incident at the Wonderful Massage Spa -- in a suite at 3880 Arville St., Kessler reported that James Braddock, called Inspector 9 in the report, had approved work done that did not match the building plans submitted.

    The same inspector also, according to Kessler, worked out of his assigned geographic area, sometimes approving work that the assigned inspectors had rejected. GPS documentation indicated that Braddock approved some work without visiting the work sites, Kessler wrote. Kessler did not respond to telephone requests from the Review-Journal for an interview.

    Harrah's Entertainment declined to comment on the report.

    Its "chief litigation officer," later identified as Michael Kostrinsky, declined to let Kessler interview employees because "the county caused him problems with the (state) contractor's board, and thus he did not want to have to defend any other claims," the consultant wrote in his report.

    District Attorney David Roger and Assistant Sheriff Mike McClary each said he planned to read the report before commenting on action his agency might take.

    The report threatens to further undermine public trust in the commission, Commissioner Chris Giunchigliani said. "There never should be any undue influence from commissioners or by management over an employee (responsible for) life-safety issues."

    If warranted by the evidence, county employees should be terminated and prosecuted, Commissioner Bruce Woodbury said.

    Rory Reid, who leads the commission, said he knew "the audit would focus on things that we don't do well, but (examining the system) is healthy."

    Contact reporter Joan Whitely at jwhitely@reviewjournal.com or (702) 383-0268.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 49 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Jim Sempek wrote on March 14, 2008 05:54 PM: Refering to the audit of the building department. This makes me absolutely sick. I was a building official for over 28 years in Colorado and Washington State. My inspectors were always briefed on doing the job they were hired to do. Make full fleged inspections and maintain the best reports possible because the odds of ending up in court are pretty high considering this sue crazy society we live in.
    I led a very healthy and proud career doing the job that was expected of me by my managers and City fathers. In court, I won all of my cases and in the field my contractors respected the decisions of my inspectors and myself.
    Too bad Clark County. You got caught with your hands in the "Don't Go There" cookie jar.


    Report abuse

    ROD wrote on March 14, 2008 08:58 AM: Has anybody gotten a copy of any of the 'COM LOGS' from any of the casinos - Probably not - they would implicate TOO many of our Government officials - at every level - State, Federal, and local - Any body that thinks there is a 100% clean person in the Nevada Government supervisory staff is naive. They have all gone out to lunch, dinner or spmething with some Casino employee and therefore owe someone a favor. It is just how big of favor they owe.


    Report abuse

    Nv for Nv wrote on March 14, 2008 01:00 AM: So well put Clark County always seem to think they are better then the rest of the State and the Nation when it comes to these issue. Doesn't really matter if you have "some of the most stringent codes" when you can't inforce then. What a shame....


    Report abuse

    Cynical Observer wrote on March 14, 2008 12:11 AM: The MGM Grand fire killed 85, and injured 650, including guests, employees and 14 firefighters. Most of the deaths and injuries were by smoke inhalation.

    Just after 7:00AM on the morning of November 21, 1980, the fire broke out in the Deli. Over 5,000 people were in the casino and its 2,000 rooms.

    While the fire primarily damaged the lobby, casino and restaurants, most of the deaths were caused by smoke inhalation on the upper floors of the hotel. Openings in vertical shafts (elevators and stairwells) and seismic joints allowed toxic smoke to spread to the top floors.

    The fire was caused by an electrical ground fault inside a wall soffit. The wiring inside the wall was used to power a refrigeration unit for a food display cabinet in the deli. The vibration of the machine caused the wires to rub against each other. The friction damaged wires arced and developed into a fire, which was not detected until several hours later.

    The fire spread by feeding on wallpaper, PVC piping, glue, and plastic mirrors. The burning material created toxic fumes and smoke, which caused the majority of the deaths.

    The casino and restaurants were not protected by a fire sprinkler system because THEY WERE EXEMPTED BY THE CLARK COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT from rules requiring fire sprinklers in areas occupied 24/7. Building department managers had granted the exemption -- despite the opposition of the fire marshal -- guessing that a fire would be quickly noticed by occupants and contained with portable fire extinguishers.

    Clark County employees guessed wrong, and 85 died.

    Imagine casino hotel fire deaths in today's intense cable news environment.
    Graphic reporting and editorializing 24/7 would focus on public employee corruption. Tourists would be afraid to stay in Vegas hotels, and tourism dollars would dry up, destroying our economy.


    Report abuse

    Rotten wrote on March 13, 2008 08:29 PM: I'm not sure exactly what his name is, but his Dad's knick-name rhymes with "STINKY." I think he's a Senator.

    Don't ask me how I know that.

    It happened at a place that rhymes with HAHARA.

    Want more? Just ask. I'm easy.


    Report abuse

    Ghost wrote on March 13, 2008 07:01 PM: Has anyone wandered what happened to the Night Inspector that was reassigned after he tryed to do his job. Which County Commissioner got involved in that.


    Report abuse

    hypocritemsG wrote on March 13, 2008 06:15 PM: I am surprise at Chris G’s comment “The report threatens to further undermine public trust in the commission, Commissioner Chris Giunchigliani said.”There never should be any undue influence from commissioners or by management over an employee (responsible for) life-safety issues." This is the same person who as a hearing officer for the fire department and ruled on behalf of the union and a fireman who was charged with wrong doing at the fire department. Ms. G is a hypocrite and is in the pockets of the union she can care less about safety in our community. She was bias and did all she could to aid the unions.



    Report abuse

    Transplanted New Yorker wrote on March 13, 2008 05:54 PM: It took a New Yorker to bring ethics to Las Vegas. Thank You Mr. Kessler.


    Report abuse

    For the Record wrote on March 13, 2008 05:43 PM: It was Ron Lynn who approved the Firestops Floor Penetrations in the Floors at the MGM Grand,He made an exception for them and tested the floor panels out in the desert with scrap fire wood,started a fire in the open and did not follow any UL or ICBO regulations for testing,I wonder why?He also is the same person who was suspended for abuse of County Vehicles and County Employees from the Structural Division for using them for Moving him out of his personnel Residence..they Promote Him ! Can you Believe it


    Report abuse

    giveusabreak wrote on March 13, 2008 05:33 PM: This is an election year and we need a new group of commissioners and a county manager, we need to clean house. There is a trail of corrupt officials who were paid something, so which commissioner made the call to the county manager and other staff to ok building inspections to avoid delays for grand opening, special parties and other special events. Special treatment doesn’t just occur from the bottom they start at the top. So as Ms Valentine rush to turn information over to the police, and DA, let us hope she is included in the investigation, along with our great commissioners.


    Read All Comments