Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue

sponsored by
News


Letter: Doctor quits insurer

E-mail notice follows allegations of conflicts in health clinic crisis




Members of the Nevada Board of Medical Examiners received notice Thursday that fellow board member Dr. Daniel McBride was stepping down as chairman of a malpractice insurance company, a position that some suggested posed a conflict of interest with his board post.

An e-mail from McBride to board members contained an attached letter of resignation to Andrew M. O'Brien, president of Nevada Mutual Insurance Co.


Most Popular Stories
  • Traffic accident claims life of longtime, successful lawyer
  • TRAFFIC STOP: Shooting accounts conflict
  • One motorcyclist killed, another critically injured in accident
  • THE FACES OF JOBLESSNESS: Family had to get help for first time
  • NORM: Buchanan called 'larger than life'
  • NORM: Marie Osmond, manager battling
  • Nurseries fence out day laborers
  • Second person dies after being restrained by police
  • REFUSING THEIR OWN MEDICINE: Vaccination policy spurs legal action
  • NORM: Agassi reveals bad vibes with Shields




  • The letter was sent the same day a Review-Journal story detailed how McBride served on the committee of the board that investigates malpractice complaints brought by patients while also serving as chairman of the medical malpractice company that fights paying out medical claims.

    Gov. Jim Gibbons is pressuring McBride to step down from his position on the board while an investigation continues into practices at the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada, which officials have linked to six cases of hepatitis C.

    Gibbons cited conflicts with the clinic's majority owner, Dr. Dipak Desai, as the reason McBride needed to step down. But lawmakers and others questioned whether McBride had additional conflicts.

    "You can't be working for Nevadans on medical malpractice questions and for a medical malpractice insurance company at the same time," Assemblywoman Sheila Leslie, D-Reno, said.

    The e-mail was sent to board members early Thursday. McBride's letter of resignation was dated Wednesday, the day the Review-Journal contacted him for comment on the story.

    McBride had told the newspaper Wednesday: "Put me down for a no comment. I don't want to get into that right now."

    McBride did not return repeated calls Thursday. Chip Wallace, marketing director for Nevada Mutual, said Thursday that he wasn't certain whether McBride's letter meant he was resigning.

    "I'll try to get back to you," Wallace said Thursday afternoon. "That was a letter he (McBride) shared (with the board)."

    Wallace never got back to the Review-Journal.

    McBride's letter to O'Brien reads: "Please accept my resignation as chairman and director of Nevada Mutual Insurance Company effective immediately. I will remain as a one of the over 1500 members of the finest physician owned insurance companies in the State of Nevada."

    McBride says on the company's Web site that Nevada Mutual "was formed by doctors to provide stable, long term professional liability coverage.

    "As a Nevada mutual insurer, we insure only Nevada doctors and our owners are our policyholders."

    Gibbons believes McBride's ties to Desai have helped undermine public confidence in the board.

    The governor also has asked for the resignations of Dr. Javaid Anwar and Dr. Sohail Anjum.

    McBride has acknowledged that Desai, majority owner of the Shadow Lane clinic, referred a large number of cases to him and that they have a long-standing friendship.

    Although he recused himself last week from any board work concerning Desai, McBride did not distance himself enough to keep Gibbons from repeating his call for a resignation.

    Thursday's developments did not impress the governor's office.

    "There is no change in the governor's position," said Ben Kieckhefer, spokesman for Gibbons.

    Board member Donald Baepler, a former president of the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, said Thursday that he did not believe McBride should have resigned as chairman of the insurance company.

    "He was just trying to help doctors get insurance," Baepler said.

    And board member Jean Stoess said McBride should be able to stay on the board.

    "I don't know if he has any more conflicts (of interest)," she said. "But he certainly seems to be trying to do the right thing."

    Contact reporter Paul Harasim at pharasim@reviewjournal.com or (702) 387-2908.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 36 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Sculler wrote on March 25, 2008 09:25 AM: I will first of all admit that I do know Dr. McBride personally, and that I will be accuse do being biased. I will accept that, however I would like to point out that he does not have a conflict of interest, nor ever did. His main focus always has, and always will be the patients of Nevada. He created the insurance company in order to ensure that the citizens of Nevada would still have health care. When insurance premiums rose to such insane amounts, good doctors were choosing no longer to practice because it was not worth the trouble to be constantly sued or the fear of being sued, and it was the Nevadans who suffered the most not the doctors. Dr. McBride could have moved to a different state where he would not face the same pressures, but instead he wanted to make sure that his community would continue to have quality health care. This is the same reason why he is on the BME, he wants to ensure that Nevadans are being treated by qualified doctors. He has never tried to hide the information that he was on both the NMIC and the BME, he fully disclosed this information. It is sad to see that these doctors are being made scapegoats. Is it really a surprise that we have these medical issues when we treat the doctors the way we do in this state?


    Report abuse

    susanekg wrote on March 22, 2008 10:40 AM: McBride's dual service on both the Nevada Mutual Board and the Medical Board was unconscionable. While he was supposed to be dealing with malpractice cases on behalf of injured patients who had complained to the med board, he was busy promoting tort reform based on distorted statistics and, as the Nevada Mutual web site says, inventing "innovative defense claims techniques" in his role as chairman of its board. We also need to know more about Anwar's company's "evaluation" of Desai's clinic last year. How does Anwar's company, which he runs with former med board member and Gibbons advisor Ikram Khan, get its clients and what exactly does it do for them? Make them look good when they shouldn't? Ward off law suits? McBride and Anwar both need to come clean since neither seems to understand what "conflict of interest" means.


    Report abuse

    Amen Doctor Quits Insurer wrote on March 21, 2008 09:42 PM: Great point. Anyone wonder why he decided to resign from the NMIC instead of the BME? Obviously, I'm restating the obvious........, he's covered by the NMIC.


    Report abuse

    Doctor Quits insurer wrote on March 21, 2008 08:51 PM: But he is still is an owner/stockholder isn't he? So, he stays on the BME and still oversees and gets paid. Not a bad gig.

    This is nothing. Wait till you get to meet the fine folks at the Regional Justice Center. Desai might have screwed you but they will tatoo you.


    Report abuse

    bear wrote on March 21, 2008 07:15 PM: David Johann,
    That means you do nothing.Then there is no way, there can be an appearance of conflict of interest.


    Report abuse

    Press Release: Southern Nevada Health District (Parody) wrote on March 21, 2008 06:51 PM: Press Release (Parody)
    Southern Nevada Health District
    For Immediate Release
    March 21, 2008

    Officials with the Southern Nevada Health District announced today that a serious misunderstanding is behind its recent botched investigation of 7 cases of acute viral hepatitis in the Las Vegas area.

    Acting Interim Director, Joe Smith, explained the misunderstanding:

    "Several years ago, the State Senate asked us to hire a 'Senior Epidemiologist' to complement services provided by the Southern Nevada Health District. That request was relayed by telephone to our offices by Nevada State Senator Dina Titus."

    Smith went on to explain, "Unfortunately, Sen. Titus sounds like she lives in a trailer park in Bear Wallow, Kentucky. We understood her to request that we hire an 'epididymologist'."

    Smith explained further, "An epidemiologist is an expert in public health and disease transmission, whereas an epididymologist is an expert in scrotal studies; in other words, an expert in testicular science."

    Smith took no questions but indicated that a Senior Epididymologist's investigatigation of the hepatitis crisis may have led to several unreliable conclusions and misguided actions taken by the District.

    Contacted at her office late this afternoon, Senator Dina Titus commented, "Oh it's all the same ta me, epididymologist or epidemiologist, whatEVER. It jus it'n an isha!"


    Report abuse

    David Johann wrote on March 21, 2008 06:48 PM: In the Hippocratic Oath physician's pledge to "first, do no harm."

    They should subsequently pledge: "second, do not even give the APPEARANCE of even POSSIBLY having a conflict of interest."

    When I worked for the Department of Veterans Affairs Healthcare (VA), we were certainly taught my proposed secondary oath, at least in principle.

    The first is part of the Hippocratic oath. The second, I will call the non-hypocritical oath, again: do not give the APPEARANCE of even POSSIBLY having a conflict of interest.

    If McBride or Greatdoctor can't see the wisdom in that, I have to wonder about their clinical judgment, regardless of the level of their technical knowledge.


    Report abuse

    Concern for angryReader wrote on March 21, 2008 04:31 PM: Do you also remember how we DID lose a few of our OBGYN's, or that some of the OBGYN's that stayed dropped the OB and practiced only GYN because of a huge jump in insurance premiums? Many of the other specialists were suddenly saved by some miracle. Any idea who formed the consortium, or who is reaping huge benifits from it?

    It is my belief that this thing is bigger than anyone knows and, in the near future, there will be a wide net spread on this huge mess.

    The public interest is in finding a forest through the trees solution.


    Report abuse

    Mayberry's Senior Epididymologist wrote on March 21, 2008 03:14 PM: How many Senior Epididymologists can we have in Mayberry? I thought that big wig Brian Liability was Mayberry's only Senior Epididymologist?

    You are the expert Barney Fife but do you think we could be getting too many cooks in the kitchen?


    Report abuse

    Shazam! wrote on March 21, 2008 02:58 PM: They put Barney Fife in charge of health care for the whole state? That would explain a lot.

    Is it true they made Gomer Pile a Senior Epididymologist? Shazam!

    I heard Gomer already figured out what caused the hepatitis and it wasn't that doctor from Indiana. It was them dam filthy nurses. Surprise, surprise, surprise!

    Is Gomer Pyle looking for more state inspectors. Maybe Dr. McFly could do that now that he has some extra free time.

    Could Dr. Venger go to work as an inspector after all those trials are over? Did somebody say he had to give up brain surgery because it makes a mess of his acrylic nails?


    Read All Comments