Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun

sponsored by
News


Demise of Yucca project predicted

Reid sees Obama blocking nuke waste dump




WASHINGTON -- President-elect Barack Obama and Sen. Harry Reid have had several discussions about the Yucca Mountain Project since the election, with Reid saying this week the nuclear waste burial plan will "bleed real hard" before being halted.

Reid said the most recent conversation, covering the waste repository program and other issues, took place Tuesday.


Most Popular Stories
  • TRAFFIC STOP: Shooting accounts conflict
  • Man shot by police identified as local attorney
  • NORM: At time, drug use wasn't suspected
  • One motorcyclist killed, another critically injured in accident
  • Nurseries fence out day laborers
  • NORM: Marie Osmond, manager battling
  • Second person dies after being restrained by police
  • Boy struck, killed by car pulling out of driveway
  • Three children fall from vehicle; mothers arrested
  • Traffic accident claims life of longtime, successful lawyer




  • He declined to give details, but hinted that the plan to bury 77,000 tons of highly radioactive material in Nevada could die a slow and painful death.

    "Yucca Mountain is history, OK?" Reid said in an interview Wednesday. "Just watch, we'll see what happens real soon, just watch. You will see it bleed real hard in the next year."

    Supporters and critics of the proposed Nevada nuclear waste repository have been waiting for signals as to how Obama might proceed on nuclear waste issues.

    One of the tea leaves is Reid, the Senate majority leader and the leading congressional opponent of the Yucca project that is unpopular among many Nevadans and most of the state's elected leaders.

    Other signals, observers say, will be who Obama selects to run the Department of Energy and carry out his policies, and how much money he proposes to spend on the project in the coming year.

    The Nuclear Regulatory Commission started in September to review an 8,600-page DOE application for a repository construction license.

    It has not been made clear what the ramifications might be if that process is stopped in its tracks, for instance whether legislation might be needed to set a new course, and what would become of more than $20 billion set aside so far for construction.

    During the presidential campaign that included a key early caucus in Nevada, Obama declared the selection of Yucca Mountain for long-term waste storage "has failed." He said nuclear waste should continue to be kept at reactor sites while policy-makers come up with a Plan B.

    Critics say the geology of the mountain ridge 100 miles northwest of Las Vegas is unsuitable for safe storage of nuclear waste for periods that would stretch beyond tens of thousands of years.

    Further, they say shipping the radioactive material to Nevada would invite accidents and possible attacks.

    But others contend the Department of Energy strategy to place waste in corrosion-resistant containers within Yucca Mountain tunnels will meet federal safety standards for up to 1 million years.

    As for transportation, DOE and nuclear industry officials point to a safety record for nuclear shipments going back 30 years.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 21 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Joseppi wrote on November 26, 2008 04:11 AM: Reid is a politically motivated fool. Obama is politically motivated too, but he's the man in charge now and he would be best served by letting the scientists and engineers complete the project at Yucca.

    Look... throughout most of the 1900's a black man still couldn't even vote in many states in the US because of political ignorance and political arrogance, even though the 15th ammendment was enacted in 1870. But 65 years ago scientists and engineers who were free from biased thought had developed the technical wherewithall to harnass the atom once and for all.

    The ideals of political racial equality had begun to make real gains by the 1960s but the science of nuclear power, and of making nuclear weaponry had been growing by leaps and bounds, made safer and more reliable for several decades.

    So now the politicians have finally caught up to the racial realities in this nation, and we seemingly agree as a population of this nation and elect a black man as president. Perhaps it is time for those same politicians to admit that the nuclear scientists and engineers, the statisticians and the safety experts, and everyone in between were right all along, had a much better handle on the real issues therein, and have great solutions to the growing nuclear waste problem. Perhaps it is time to fully endorse the Yucca plan and get on with developing the cleanest energy source we know today.

    Can we really afford a one hundred thirty eight year learning curve on safe nuclear waste management? I think not.


    Report abuse

    John Griggs wrote on November 25, 2008 05:24 PM: Killing Yucca Mountain would be insane. We've known since the 1950s what to do with spent fuel and high level waste: bury it in deep geologic storage. This in a sense returns the radioactive material to its original condition: it was initially buried uranium ore. But politically we have been avoiding the geologic burial because of NIMBY concerns.
    Now we have in place a licensing process that will review all of the contested technical issues regarding whether the site is safe and the burial plan is appropriate and workable. And Se. Reid proposes to pull the plug before getting any of those answers? DO NOT KILL THIS PROJECT! It is irresponsible to continue putting off a solution to high level radioactive waste.


    Report abuse

    To Russ: wrote on November 21, 2008 09:01 PM: The Democrats caused it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_MGT_cSi7Rs&eurl=http://sweetness-light.com/archive/watch-dems-defend-the-fanniefreddie-scam

    http://pundits.thehill.com/2008/09/17/fannie-freddie-mel-and-barney/


    Report abuse

    davelv wrote on November 21, 2008 08:32 PM: So what are Washington, Idaho and South Carolina going to do with all of the weapons waste and the legal agreements to remove this waste from these states? In particular, Idaho can stop the Navy and DOE from shipping any more waste to Idaho if Obama pays off Reid by stopping Yucca Mountain - which will have severe and significant impacts on the nation's defense.

    Obama appears ill-advised as to the ramifications of not having Yucca Mountain proceed through the legal process. If YMP is not suitable, let the NRC decide.


    Report abuse

    WHAT ABOUT THE TOXIC DUMP IN RORY"S DISTRICT? wrote on November 21, 2008 12:55 PM: Yipee! Harry closed a Dump with nothing in it.

    What's Rory's excuse for letting Pardee Homes build 919 homes at the Sunrise Highlands? They are in the toxic plume right next door to the Sunrise Landfill.

    That is an Unlined Landfill and it's leaking Toxic Waste directly in to the Las Vegas Wash and contaminating our drinking water supply. That would be that pond we call Lake Mead.

    Republic Services just paid a MILLION DOLLAR FINE for violating the Clean Water Act. The EPA finally stepped in.

    What are we thinking? Yucca Mtn. doesn't threaten us at all. Sunrise Landfill is polluting us DAILY. How could they possibly build homes right next to it? Rory and Pinky pushed it through. WHY? DON'T DRINK THE WATER.


    Report abuse

    Don't Kill the Messenger: wrote on November 21, 2008 12:28 PM: Go to the artice and sign up....we will see where this boy was born once and for all. No, I am not going to let it go.

    OBAMA WATCH CENTRAL
    Petition to see the birth certificate
    Online effort launched to answer presidential eligibility question

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Posted: November 21, 2008
    1:00 am Eastern

    © 2008 WorldNetDaily

    WASHINGTON – WND today announces the launching of an online petition designed to enlist the public's help in demanding evidence of Barack Obama's constitutional eligibility for the office of the presidency.

    The electronic petition calls on all controlling legal authorities to take seriously the matter of where and when and to whom Obama was born and whether he qualifies as a "natural-born American citizen," according to Article 2, Section 1 of the Constitution. Go to www.worldnetdaily.com
    and sign up.....







    Report abuse

    pamm wrote on November 21, 2008 10:04 AM: Harry tries so hard to portray himself as the superhero fighting the big bad Department of Energy that's imposing it's will on Nevada - - nevermind that it was Congress (of which Reid is a member) that passed legislation that was signed into law, directing DOE to investigate building a repository at Yucca Mountain, and it was Congress that subsequently approved the Yucca Mountain site and recommended it to the President for his approval as well, in 2002. DOE is only doing what Harry's congressional colleagues have directed it to do. His fits of drama and his anger are somewhat misplaced; I guess it makes a better storyline for him to pretend its he is fighting some big rogue government agency, rather than his Congressional colleagues.
    By the way, how does Harry plan to help the hundreds of Nevadans that will be unemployed if the Yucca Mountain project is derailed?


    Report abuse

    pamm wrote on November 21, 2008 10:01 AM: Harry tries so hard to portray himself as the superhero fighting the big bad Department of Energy that's imposing it's will on Nevada - - nevermind that it was Congress (of which Reid is a member) that passed legislation that was signed into law, directing DOE to investigate building a repository at Yucca Mountain, and it was Congress that subsequently approved the Yucca Mountain site and recommended it to the President for his approval as well, in 2002. DOE is only doing what Harry's congressional colleagues have directed it to do. His fits of drama and his anger are somewhat misplaced; I guess it makes a better storyline for him to pretend its he is fighting some big rogue government agency, rather than his Congressional colleagues.

    By the way, how does Harry plan to help the hundreds of Nevadans that will be unemployed if the Yucca Mountain project is derailed?


    Report abuse

    Skeptical Nevadan wrote on November 21, 2008 09:29 AM: Roger:

    That's why they're geologists and you were merely "on the tour."

    A "significant seismic event" means something different to a geologist or a seismologist, whose task on the Yucca Mountain Project is to evaluate the record and calcualte probabilities for future events.

    Those probabilities are factored into the engineering design bases for the surface and subsurface facilities. The probability of a "significant seismic event" (high or low) is in no way a "deal breaker" or a serious safety concern, as you imply. It just means that the repository has to be designed to withstand such events, which it is. This makes it no different than the many buildings, roads, bridges, and overpasses that you happily use day in and day out. In fact, because the nuclear industry is renowned for its safety standards, you would likely be a lot safer in a repository building than in a typical Strip hotel during a "significant seismic event."

    As for the economic scare tactics, do you really expect us to believe that tourists or prospective residents will be deterred by a repository located adjacent to the Nevada Test Site, where for decades they conducted aboveground and belowground detonations of nuclear bombs? Where was the nuclear panic and deterrence effect during those decades, when Nevada saw consistent growth rather than decline, while mushroom clouds lit the horizon and A-bomb-induced seismic shocks rattled the valley?


    Report abuse

    Skeptical Nevadan wrote on November 21, 2008 09:06 AM: Concerned Las Vegas Citizen:

    You might also be interested to know that there are potential direct benefits in the offing for Nevada, apart from the indirect benefits that result from the Yucca Mountain Project in the form of jobs and related local spending.

    Sen. Inhofe and others have proposed the following amendment to the Leiberman-Warner climate change bill (S. 3036):

    (1) Under the amendment, Nevada would receive $100 million annually in direct federal compensation while the repository license application is under review by the NRC (three to four years, for a potential total of $400 million).

    (2) If the license application is approved by the NRC, and a construction authorization is granted, the state would receive $250 million annually for the duration of the construction phase (expected to last around eight years, which would equate to around $2 billion in federal compensation).

    (3) After the repository is built and begins receiving spent nuclear fuel, the state would receive $500 million annually, potentially for the duration of repository operation and beyond (perhaps up to 130 years).

    Now, who's going to make sure that this amendment gets cut from the Leiberman-Warner climate change bill? You can bet that Harry Reid will be leading the charge, with the Nevada congressional delegation in tow.

    And to my knowlege, no one in the local media has reported this story, even though it's clearly there for all to see in the Congressional Record for June 5, 2008.

    Now, why do you think our politicians and local media would downplay this story during a time of state fiscal crisis?


    Read All Comments