Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon

sponsored by
News


JANE ANN MORRISON: Anti-government waste commission proved the skeptics wrong

When the SAGE Commission started its work a year ago, Chairman Bruce James was optimistic, Carole Vilardo was hopeful, and David Goldwater was skeptical.

But midway through their two-year assignment on Gov. Jim Gibbons' Spending and Government Efficiency Commission, all three believe their time wasn't wasted.


Most Popular Stories
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • FATAL SHOOTING: Police again mourn comrade
  • NORM: Biden finds rank has its privileges
  • Corrections officer dies in collision on U.S. 95
  • Two suspects in officer's slaying could face death penalty
  • Two of three suspects in slaying of officer could face death penalty
  • DEADLY HOME INVASION: Police suspect link to family
  • NORM: Walton: Coach deserved a punch
  • Station Casinos posts $455 million third-quarter loss
  • ANOTHER SOMBER DAY: Fourth officer in short span dies




  • Out of the 24 SAGE recommendations, nine were implemented, eight were rejected, four are under consideration by the governor, and three received no action.

    The biggest victory was that the Legislature agreed to reduce costs at the Public Employees Retirement System and the Public Employees Benefits Program, at least for newcomers to the state system. Lawmakers didn't go as far as the commission urged, but for the first time, some progress was made in reining in escalating costs.

    Former Democratic Assemblyman Goldwater evaluated the commission. "If the objective was to find millions of dollars immediately to fill the budget hole, it was not successful. And that was the governor's original intent, to find waste in state government."

    The 14 commissioners didn't find $600 hammers or $900 toilet seats in the state government, for example. But the commission succeeded, Goldwater said, by disproving state government is bloated. "From that perspective, the SAGE Commission was successful," Goldwater said. "At the end of the day, from my definition of success, we disarmed that stupid argument that goofy paper of yours uses."

    James put it more diplomatically. "As long as the programs exist that exist today and we structure it the way we do, there isn't a lot of fat. That doesn't mean that things cannot be organized and streamlined," James said. "Without question, we have several redundancies in government; there are 170 entities in the executive branch, and many are overlapping."

    Both Goldwater and Vilardo, president of the Nevada Taxpayers Association, praised James for his leadership. (My blog tells you about his political future.) "I give Bruce credit. He sought unanimity on things. Almost everything was unanimous except for some of the reductions in pension and health benefits," Goldwater said.

    "SAGE helped elevate the conversation," Vilardo said, referring to the retirement and health benefit reductions for new hires after Tuesday. She gave credit to the Las Vegas Chamber of Commerce for actively lobbying for those cost-cutting ideas that public employee unions killed in prior sessions. With a floundering economy, this turned out to be the right idea at the right time.

    In 1999, when times were better, Gov. Kenny Guinn appointed a cost-cutting committee. Just before the 2001 Legislature, the Fundamental Review of State Government submitted 65 suggestions to save $50 million by improving state efficiency. In the end, lawmakers approved ideas calculated to save $30 million.

    James had no dollar estimate of how much money will be saved with the nine proposals approved and tweaked by the Legislature.

    After the session, SAGE members agreed that they should have more actively lobbied legislators about the proposals. Instead, the commission made a conscious decision to leave the lobbying to Gibbons. But with the tension between lawmakers and the GOP governor, in retrospect, that was a mistake.

    With another year to go, James said the next phase will focus on health care costs, ideas Gibbons can implement without legislative approval and four to six more solid suggestions for the 2011 session.

    The other commissioners are Don Ahern, Barbara Smith Campbell, Bob Feldman, Bob Forbuss, Randy Garcia, Steve Greathouse, Steve Hill, Jan Jones, Howard Putnam, Jerome Snyder and James Thornton. They're a pretty impressive group who don't have time to waste and showed up at almost every monthly meeting, paying their own expenses and receiving no pay. There are three full-time, paid staff members.

    At their June 24 meeting, James asked commissioners whether they thought the time they had spent on the commission had been worthwhile, whether they thought progress had been made and whether they were pleased with the results.

    Yes, yes and yes, they all answered.

    A year earlier, all agreed they were happy to give their time and pay their expenses, but they wanted to accomplish something.

    Even if lawmakers didn't go as far as SAGE commissioners wanted, the commissioners have made progress in saving you money, and they're only half finished.

    If Goldwater and Vilardo agree the SAGE Commission is worth their time that tells me the governor's commission is worthwhile. And like Goldwater, I started as a skeptic.

    Jane Ann Morrison's column appears Monday, Thursday and Saturday. E-mail her at Jane@reviewjournal.com or call (702) 383-0275. She also blogs at lvrj.com/blogs/morrison/.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 11 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Dixon wrote on July 10, 2009 08:56 PM: The Chamber of Commerce is worried about retirements, salaries, and benefits of past and future govermnental employees while they support businesses who break the law by hiring illegal emigrants which is against the law. Gaming and business do not want anything but cheap labor and no tax raises especially in gaming. Casino execs making millions a year are on tv excited about a workers retirement package.


    Cronies wrote on July 05, 2009 09:57 AM: You have three government cronies looking for waste and they can't find any. FRANKLY I am shocked. NOT!

    It is as shocking as when the Coroner Inquest or Metro's Internal Affairs finds Cop didn't do anything wrong.

    Yes sir. The Fox has discovered that no chickens were missing from the Hen House. LOL

    Hold the presses!

    Thanks for the laugh Jane.


    Gregory Brown wrote on July 03, 2009 08:06 PM: There are several factual errors in this account, most significantly that the new regime for pensions and retiree health benefits does not take effect until 1 July 2010.

    Secondly, every single SAGE recommendation concerning PEBP was rejected by the legislature. This may have been because the proposals regarding health insurance were opposed by nearly half (5 of 13) of the Commissioners. The proposals were based
    written by a man whose expertise is in auto insurance and had little evidence to back them up.

    The cost savings for the state from PEBP result from recommendations made by the PEBP board itself, not the SAGE Commission.

    Lastly and most interestingly, JAM doesn't discuss the disastrous SAGE Commission meeting in Las Vegas in early May, when the Governor gave a rambling speech and could not answer a question about why out of state retailers pay almost no taxes -- and then he rejected out of hand Chairman James's recommendation that the state invest in preparing for the 2010 census by making funding available to the universities to help ensure the Census Bureau gets a full account of all Nevadans. The Census Bureau estimates that the state lost $1.5b over the last decade due to Nevadans it missed in 2000, and by rejecting this recommendation, the Governor cost the state at least that amount in the coming decade.


    re-link wrote on July 02, 2009 09:26 AM: .


















    .


    tom1 wrote on July 02, 2009 09:03 AM: Jane please get a clue or quit your job and save us the tripe. If you decide not to get with the program, you are bound to be left in the dust along with the rest of the socialists come 2010 and 2012............LOL....


    wow,once again the most worthless suck @$$ columnist on the planet post useless articles wrote on July 02, 2009 09:03 AM:
    gibbons wasted nothing but tax payer money trying to rape mazzeo and lied about it
    costing investigation dollars we have not even begun to spend yet.

    wake up lady.

    allowscriptaccess="never"
    src="http://oddhammer.com/tutorials/debt_clock/US_debt_clock_dynamic.swf" quality="high" pluginspage="http://www.macromedia.com/shockwave/download/index.cgi?P1_Prod_Version=ShockwaveFlash" type="application/x-shockwave-flash"
    width="340" flashVars="topString=Hello&bottomString=World"
    height="155">



    .


    LVMPD wrote on July 02, 2009 08:20 AM: David Goldwater? It's good to see you...
    Sober.

    http://www.kvbc.com/Global/story.asp?S=2331620


    zack wrote on July 02, 2009 07:45 AM: The SAGE Commission is a joke - they did not do anything but screw over the employees while leaving all the needless programs in place. I see the state is still heavily funding enviromental projects, NDOW is wasting tons of money studying wildlife they should already know about, many state agencies are paying private consultants more money than they are paying their own employees (state workers on furlough and cannot work O.T. while private consultants are working O.T. to cover state workers duties) and the list goes on. Helen Weils you are so far off base when evaluating government waste, you totally focus on employee salaries and don't see that most of the waste is hidden from the public in the way each agency operates. The agencies would save money if they would quit hiring private consultants for up $120 an hour and let their own workers do the work, or let their own workers do projects instead of bidding them to private contractor. The State could change the some of their enviormental laws and save a billion dollars easy, example go ask NDOT how much money they spend getting an EIS for each project. Why do they need that document to reconstruct I-15 in the middle of the city, I will tell you why because of the enviromental laws and the sue happy enviromentalists, change these laws and an agency like NDOT will save millions of dollars every year.


    HELEN WEILS wrote on July 02, 2009 07:17 AM: NO BLOATED GOVERNMENT??? LET'S START WITH COP AND FIREFIGHTER PAY AND BENEFITS.


    normoes wrote on July 02, 2009 07:14 AM: I'm sorry - I'm still one of those mean skeptics. I think it's a joke to tell us that our state government isn't wasting money. Within this commission's own report they said:

    "Without question, we have several redundancies in government; there are 170 entities in the executive branch, and many are overlapping."

    What was that? "170 entities" in the executive branch alone! - many of which "are overlapping"? How many other "redundancies are there in all the layers of our state government that "overlap"?

    Kenny Guinn spent 40 million about four years ago to start a "teacher's college". It's not like there aren't several ways to get a teacher's certification here in southern Nevada - UNLV, Nova, Pheonix University, among others. Guinn spent the 40 million to "start-up" this new school. It's going to cost millions more each year to keep it going. I call this an unnecessary waste of taxpayer money. We didn't need this college then and we don't need it now. And, this is just one example I know of - how many other state government "pork" programs are out there under the radar?

    So, no, I don't buy this commission's message that our state government is doing all it can to be cost-effective.


    Read All Comments