Las Vegas News, Sports, Business, Entertainment and Classifieds

Las Vegas Review-Journal - News

Friday
Mar 19, 2010
Sunny
Sunny 71° Weather Forecast

RECENT EDITIONS
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri

sponsored by
News


LV importer 'totally stunned' by tainted pet food ingredient

The encounter was unusual even for a businessman accustomed to doing business in China.

But Steve Miller, 54, a Las Vegas-based importer, and a trading company official were still surprised after their flight from Shanghai to meet with the manufacturer of tainted wheat gluten that Miller had imported.


Most Popular Stories
  1. Rare, exotic birds killed in fire
  2. Rhodes rides again at Red Rock
  3. Ex-NFL linebacker Livingston dies
  4. Woman tells how suspect killed husband, shot her
  5. 'Phantom' made it to Final Four
  6. Northern Iowa guard's 25-foot 3-pointer KOs Rebels
  7. Northern Iowa guard's 25-foot 3-pointer KOs Rebels
  8. Student arrested for bringing gun to school
  9. Tea Party activists say candidate uninvited
  10. Republicans subpoenaed in Ensign probe

  • Testing scandal ensnarls Agassi principal



  • Lejun Mao, general manager of XuZhou Anying Biologic Technology Development Co. Ltd., met them at the airport during the late March trip, but there was no place to sit.

    "He put out newspapers on a parking lot. We just sat down on the newspapers to talk," Miller said.

    Miller spoke to Mao with the help of two translators while his wife, Sally, a native speaker of Chinese, participated by cell phone.

    Miller told Mao that the chemical melamine had been detected in wheat gluten that his company, ChemNutra, had purchased from XuZhou.

    "He said he didn't understand how that had happened, and he said he would look into it and get back to us," Miller recalled.

    The Chinese businessman seemed sorry about the problem, Miller said; in fact, Mao insisted on carrying Miller's luggage and backpack to the boarding agent after the meeting.

    However, Miller said, the manufacturer admitted no responsibility for the tainted wheat gluten.

    Miller has not been able to contact Mao since that meeting. Before Chinese officials could investigate the wheat gluten plant, bulldozers razed the structure.

    It was as if Miller -- the chief executive officer for ChemNutra, a three-person import firm -- had been a victim of the Chinese curse: "May you live in interesting times."

    Miller told the inside story of the tainted Chinese wheat gluten for the first time Friday in a restaurant in northwest Las Vegas.

    The importer earned a combination degree in law and a master's of business administration from Columbia University, and he worked as an investment banker before becoming an entrepreneur.

    He started an Internet company called Net Exchange in New York that provided a Web-based e-mail archive and database system for companies, but the company imploded and he lost all of his investment money after the dot-com bubble burst in 2000.

    Miller started ChemNutra in Pasadena, Calif., three years ago and moved to Las Vegas 18 months ago. He rents space in five warehouses around the country and provides a variety of pet food ingredients to manufacturers and pet food ingredient distributors.

    Miller, who discussed details about the story during an interview with the Review-Journal, said he first learned of the melamine problem while attending a trade show in Shanghai on March 29.

    The U.S. Food and Drug Administration contacted him at the trade show and told him that melamine was detected in wheat gluten he had imported from XuZhou, he said.

    "I was just totally stunned," Miller said. "It was out of left field. No one had ever heard of melamine," a chemical used in plastics and as a fire retardant.

    "I didn't even know what it was," he said.

    Like other pet food ingredient importers, Miller said he relied on the supplier to obtain a certificate of analysis from the manufacturer to ensure that the products were pure.

    Menu Foods, one of the pet food makers that ChemNutra supplied, learned on Feb. 20 that its pet food was contaminated, according to testimony in a Senate subcommittee hearing.

    Menu Foods told ChemNutra on March 6 to stop all shipments of wheat gluten, apparently because of a change in specifications, according to ChemNutra.

    ChemNutra issued a product recall on March 16 and spoke to an Associated Press reporter about the recall. It was the last interview Miller gave before Friday.

    Hours after the product recall, ChemNutra issued its first news release ever, advising the public about the tainted pet food.

    Television news crews from four stations swarmed outside the nondescript office building used by ChemNutra. A television station helicopter buzzed the area for an aerial view.

    When Miller's secretary went out to speak to the reporters, he and his wife "were able to sneak out, and they didn't see us leave even though there is only one door."

    Television crews still were staking out the office and shining a light on the dark building when Miller drove by at 11 p.m.

    Industry executives were surprised two weeks later to see Miller at the Pet Food Forum, a conference that brings 700 attendees to Chicago.

    "We had been a victim of fraud in this situation," Miller said. "I wanted to say: I'm still here. I'm still in business."

    But Miller's involvement in the pet food scare continued to grow.

    When he returned to his Las Vegas office from an errand on April 27, he found a vehicle parked in his office parking space.

    The people in the car promised to move.

    Miller did not know it, but he had just met FDA investigators waiting for a sealed search warrant to serve on ChemNutra's offices.

    "We had always given the FDA anything they asked for," he said.

    The FDA investigators wore badges and guns on their hips, but they were friendly, Miller said. "They were very jovial and pleasant people," he said.

    The FDA also served a search warrant on Menu Food's plant in Emporia, Kan., the same day.

    Miller said he believes he could be charged with a misdemeanor for importing tainted food, even though he had no knowledge that the wheat gluten was bad.

    The businessman believes the U.S. government will pursue more serious charges against others domestically.

    "I don't want to go into details, and I don't want to say who" may be charged with a crime, Miller said.

    Mao and another Chinese manufacturer of wheat gluten already are in jail, and Miller thinks they face long prison terms.

    "For China, this has embarrassed them so badly" that the government will want to punish wrongdoers, he said.

    ChemNutra is organizing the Pet Food Industry Safety Summit in Las Vegas on July 14 so that industry leaders can discuss ways to prevent problems like the tainted wheat gluten.

    Miller predicts the incident will spur the pet food import industry to start testing ingredients routinely.

    "We will definitely change our procedures to make sure nothing like this ever happens again," he said.

    He is also confident that ChemNutra will survive. Menu Foods is the only customer ChemNutra has lost, leaving 17 others.

    Miller believes ChemNutra has sufficient insurance to pay for any judgments stemming from lawsuits filed by pet owners and others.

    The FDA has said 16 cats and one dog were confirmed to have died after eating tainted pet food.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 10 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Saint Anthonys Fire wrote on July 14, 2007 07:45 PM: Rosiemeow says it all here:

    http://community.whptv.com/forums/thread/1483113.aspx

    Sad, indeed. Mr. Miller is not "an idiot or a liar". He is both.

    No one has ever heard of Melamine? Borden Chemicals right here in the good ole' US of A purchased a melamine company 6 years ago, and has another plant in guess where (drum roll) -
    China.

    He knew exactly what he was doing, as did Sally once removed Qing, as does Borden.


    Report abuse

    Elaine Vigneault wrote on May 20, 2007 05:54 PM: The FDA has reported that they've received over 17,000 complaints and at least 4000 possible pet deaths related to the recall.
    Source: http://www.fda.gov/bbs/transcripts/transcript050307.pdf
    Your article is misleading; there were obviously more than 17 pet deaths.


    Report abuse

    Gordon wrote on May 20, 2007 06:56 AM: 1. This shows the importance of knowing the character of who you choose to do business with. It is absolutely critical because you will lose if you are dealing with a crook. Bulldozing the plant so it could not be inspected smells of cover-up by someone who probably had done it before.

    2. Who are the 17 companies that don't care about my wellbeing? I need to know so I don't put their products in my grocery cart.


    Report abuse

    Shelley wrote on May 19, 2007 11:30 PM: "Miller believes ChemNutra has sufficient insurance to pay for any judgments stemming from lawsuits filed by pet owners and others."

    So does this mean, "I am sorry for poisoning your pets and tainting the human food supply?"


    Report abuse

    David wrote on May 19, 2007 11:25 PM: It's interesting that Chemnutra supposedly is minority and women-owned.


    Report abuse

    carol wrote on May 19, 2007 10:29 PM: http://www.fda.gov/ora/fiars/ora_import_ia9929.html

    fda reporting over 4000 pets!!!


    Report abuse

    Jim Richardon wrote on May 19, 2007 01:19 PM: This is what is wrong with America. A guy with a law degree and an MBA with no expertise in chemistry, biology or animal health can import ingredients from a 3rd world country that poisons the nation's pet food supply, and pork and chicken industry. Three people in a warehouse in Vegas can do this because the only thing American companies care about is cheapness. These people depended on the certification from the seller in China? Their web site talks about their expertise in obtaining ingredients from China. From the results, I'd say they aren't very good at this. They did no independent testing? What about all the consumers who thought they were buying top quality brands when the stuff is really made from industrial chemicals from China. I'll bet none of the labels said that...


    Report abuse

    Tim wrote on May 19, 2007 11:50 AM: The Chinese sell tainted baby formula to their own people, using cheap fillers instead of necessary vitamins and nutrients... now, why would you think or expect them to give a damn what they export to the U.S.

    Mr. Miller is either an idiot or a liar. If he knew more about his business or product, he would of had the knowledge to foresee such a problem. I do business in China/HK and have seen and heard of this fraud for years.


    Report abuse

    Debi Cole wrote on May 19, 2007 10:42 AM: "Like other pet food ingredient importers, Miller said he relied on the supplier to obtain a certificate of analysis from the manufacturer to ensure that the products were pure."

    Miller tries to paint himself as a victim here. Give me a break! Anyone importing foodstuffs from China, of all places, has a moral obligation to at least perform sample tests on any shipments received. This is yet another example of corporate greed, plain and simple.

    And just who are the OTHER 17 COMPANIES that ChemNutra has shipped their imported poison to???


    Report abuse

    Marcia Lozon wrote on May 19, 2007 10:05 AM: While I believe Steve Miller had no knowlege that the wheat gluten he imported was tainted, I'm having a hard time with him saying "no one" had ever heard of melamine. I'm 52 years old and no graduate of Columbia University but when I was sixteen or so I bought a set of summer dinnerware for my mom for her birthday. It was plastic, it said right on the box that is was "melamine dinnerware". It was great, virtually indestructable, we used it all summer long at barbeques. It didn't chip or break when dropped on concrete! When my father passed away in 2002 that dinnerware was sold at the estate sale (still in good shape)ugly daisy pattern and all! I don't believe Mr. Millers was born under a rock and since he's only 2 yrs. older than me, I can't believe he'd never heard of the stuff!