Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

sponsored by
News


IN DEPTH: EDUCATION FOR ALL

Impact of illegal immigrants on Clark County schools vast but untracked










When Leticia Ochoa started the fourth grade, she had just arrived from Mexico and didn't speak English.

With extra attention from her teacher, Ochoa said, she started speaking English within a month or so, and was fluent after a year. Now the 13-year-old teaches English to her mother, an illegal immigrant.


Most Popular Stories
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • FATAL SHOOTING: Police again mourn comrade
  • NORM: Biden finds rank has its privileges
  • Corrections officer dies in collision on U.S. 95
  • Two suspects in officer's slaying could face death penalty
  • Two of three suspects in slaying of officer could face death penalty
  • NORM: Walton: Coach deserved a punch
  • DEADLY HOME INVASION: Police suspect link to family
  • Station Casinos posts $455 million third-quarter loss
  • NORM: 'Girls Gone Wild' creator feels heat




  • "I had a deal with my teacher," she said. "She spoke to me only in English and I helped her learn Spanish. For me, I think it was real good. Some students take a lot longer to learn" English.

    Samantha Guerrero, who was 11 when she came to Las Vegas from Southern California, got lost in the shuffle of new students. School administrators, at first glance, presumed she knew little English even though she is bilingual, said her mother, Angie Guerrero.

    The oversight was soon corrected and Samantha was moved to a more challenging class, where she assists students not fluent in English.

    "Her teacher, who only speaks English, has Samantha sit with the Spanish-speaking students and translate for them," said Angie Guerrero, 35.

    The two girls are just drops in the wave of Spanish-speaking students that has hit the Clark County School District over the past 10 years, as more immigrants come to Las Vegas for jobs in the service industry, construction or other pursuits.

    The number of Clark County School District students has grown 49 percent since 1998, but enrollment in the English Language Learner (ELL) program for non-English-speaking students has skyrocketed 136 percent.

    Over the same period, the budget for ELL has jumped 196 percent, but the per pupil expenditures have inched up only 6 percent because of the growth in enrollment, according to district budget and enrollment figures. For the 2006-07 school year, $18.4 million for the program came from state funds and $8.3 million came from federal funding.

    The program's students are 94 percent Spanish speakers. Two percent speak languages from the Philippines, less than 2 percent speak Chinese and the remainder speak a variety of languages.

    During the 2006-2007 school year, more than half of the Hispanic students -- 59,874 of 117,496 -- were in the ELL program, enrollment data from the district shows.

    Meanwhile, for the first time last year, Hispanic students in the district outnumbered the Caucasian students, meaning the district is now considered a "majority-minority" district.

    School administrators say 75 percent of students in the ELL program were born in the United States.

    "In registering, they provide a birth certificate and that is how we know if they were born in the U.S. or not," said Nancy Alamo, director of the ELL program.

    But the school district has no way of knowing how many are children of illegal immigrants. Parents are not required to prove citizenship or legal resident status.

    NOBODY COUNTS

    Tom Rodriguez, executive manager of the school district's Diversity and Affirmative Action Programs, said no school in the country tracks students who are illegal immigrants or who are the children of illegal immigrants, and said there is no "common sense" reason to do so.

    "You might find some people on the far right who would want to do that, but I can't think of any educators that would want to do that. Why would an educator not want to provide educational services?" said Rodriguez, whose parents came to the United States as illegal immigrants nearly 90 years ago when they were small children.

    "If someone is living in your community in large numbers," he continued, "wouldn't you want them educated so that they can better feed and clothe themselves, take care of their well-being and try to contribute to the community? ... Of course, you will get an argument on that from the fiscal end."

    A 1982 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the case of Plyler v. Doe dictates that all children residing in the United States have the same right as citizens to a public education under the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment.

    The case challenged a 1975 Texas law withholding from schools state funds for children who were not admitted legally into the United States. The state was challenged by children of Mexican immigrants attending schools in Smith County, Texas.

    According to a synopsis of the court ruling by the Cornell University Law School, "The undocumented status of these children does not establish a sufficient rational basis for denying them benefits that the state affords other residents ... no national policy is perceived that might justify the State in denying these children an elementary education."

    However, Gustavo Regalado, 55, a naturalized U.S. citizen from Mexico with two children in Clark County public schools, sees things differently. It's unfair, he said, that his tax money goes to teaching English while other school programs are being cut from the budget.

    "I'm American," he said. "I learned English and my two children knew English when they started school. It's not fair because now there's money coming out of my pocket to teach children who don't learn or who just immigrated and don't know English."

    LEARNING THE LANGUAGE

    The schools in Southern Nevada with the highest number of ELL program students are Bell Elementary, southwest of Interstate 15 and Sahara Avenue near Palace Station; Monaco Middle, near East Lake Mead and North Nellis boulevards; and Rancho High, near Bruce Street and East Owens Avenue, according to the school district.

    The schools with the lowest Hispanic enrollment are outside the urban area and include Harry Reid Elementary in Searchlight, Garret Middle School in Boulder City and Indian Springs High School north of the Las Vegas Valley.

    The ELL program provides training for teachers, learning materials, books and other resources, Alamo said.

    There are 157 ELL specialists, who travel the district working with teachers. And, for the coming school year, there are 2,200 teachers equipped with training in English as a Second Language curriculum or who are considered by the state to be "bilingual endorsed" teachers, which means they have training in teaching non-English speaking students, Alamo said.

    Specialists provide professional development for teachers, serve as mentors for teachers and provide student instruction in classrooms and smaller group settings, Alamo said.

    ELL teachers and specialists do not receive any stipend, extra time off or any other benefits for their additional qualifications. They are paid the same as other teachers, who average $46,429 a year, including salary and benefits.

    Some children will require much more time to learn the new language than others do, Alamo said. With previous classroom experience of some sort, students typically require two to three years to learn English. Without a prior education, it typically takes five to seven years, she said.

    There are seven dual-language elementary schools in the district, said Kelly Sturdy, principal at Herron Elementary School, near the intersection of East Carey Avenue and North Pecos Road in North Las Vegas.

    "Our major goal is to get kids 100 percent proficient in English so they are scoring the same as their English-speaking peers by the fifth grade," Sturdy said. "And our other goal is to get the English speakers proficient in Spanish to increase their opportunities for jobs. ... Being bilingual is a great gift for children to have."

    At dual-language schools, students whose primary language is English and students who speak Spanish are taught in both languages. The program has added a grade every year as the first class of dual-language students moves up.

    Although the program is relatively new, the preliminary results have been positive, and national data indicates students in dual-language schools exhibit higher cognitive skills and a higher-level vocabulary than students at traditional schools.

    "For Spanish-speaking kids, they have no choice. They have to learn to speak English and get on track," Sturdy said. "I have no doubt all of them will be English proficient."

    Libardo Gonzalez, 18, a Cuban immigrant who was granted asylum when he and his parents arrived in the United States eight months ago, said he would love to attend the University of Nevada, Las Vegas when he completes the "easy" night class he is taking to get his general education diploma.

    However, with the high cost of tuition for even a Nevada resident, he plans to get his nursing degree before pursuing his dream of becoming a doctor, he said outside the English class that he attends mornings at the Stupak Community Center, west of the Stratosphere.

    "It's important to speak English," he said. "We are in America and the official language is English, and (immigrants) have to learn English to do anything here."

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 21 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    P.Mont wrote on September 09, 2007 09:45 AM: anyone who thinks it's easier to educate an illegal alien must be crazy.Why can't Mexico educate them.These people are invading our schools, hospitals, jobs, having baby after baby, who will be future voters. 8 out of 10 babies born at UMC are from an illegal alien, the bill is passed on to the tax payers. (Mary) said it's cheaper to educate them than incarcerate them". Thats not true, they have even invaded our prison system, more American citizes are killed at the hand of an illegal alien each week then soldiers killed to middle east in a month. this is an invasion, and Mexico have declared it, some Americans want believe it until it's too late for them.


    Mary wrote on August 31, 2007 02:09 PM: It's cheaper to educate them than incarcerate them.


    George wrote on August 27, 2007 01:32 PM: I'm ashamed of every American who supports dual language schools. I didn't serve my country, and help preserve our American way of life, to see it given away!! American schools are taught in English!! Period!! There's always someone, or group, who thinks they know what's best for America. The bottom line is, if you don't want to assimilate to our country, and language, get the hell out, and take your kids with you!! How dare the CCSD force American students to learn Spanish. Where is this crap going to end?? Our country is being turned into a 3rd world nation before our very eyes, and the people who are giving it away, are our elected officials! We've all heard "When in Rome, do as the Roman's do". What's wrong with "When in AMERICA, do as AMERICAN'S do??


    STEVE KALDI wrote on July 23, 2007 12:33 PM: Tom Rodriguez says " There is no common sense reason to track illegals in school "

    THEN LET HIM PAY FOR THEM, NOT THE TAX PAYERS !


    shell wrote on July 20, 2007 08:58 PM: Yeah Lynn, you got a cheap wiring job and stucco job while some American Contractors are now laying off American Citizens because they do not have enough jobs. And the Hispanics that are doing the cheap work are sending the money they made off of you to Mexico so that their families can live nicely. Why don't they take their skills back to their homelands and make it better?
    And Ryan, with all of the Illeagals sucking up all of the school monies and grants the American children cannot afford to go to school. They have to get jobs so that they can afford insurance because the hospitols or government is not going to give them a break. They would not qualify for medicare just because of the color of their skin. Talk about discrimination!!!


    Shell wrote on July 20, 2007 08:46 PM: So, our American Children get 6% increase while Hispanic children of Illegals get 196% increase in the school budget. Next time the school budget is debated I know where I will side. I am tired of paying and paying while Illegals make their money and send it home to Mexico. Then want us to pay for their Healthcare, education and housing. And 6 or 7 children that they cannot afford to raise. 75% of these children are born in the United States and yet do not speak English? They get special classes. Talk about Racism in schools. Maybe Educators would want to count because they are tired of the 196% of the budget going into teaching kids that should know English and be able to learn the same as any American Citizen Child. They get a lousy 2% pay raise while these special classes get 196% raise????


    Lynne Personius wrote on July 16, 2007 04:37 PM: I don't see the fair and balanced reports to accompany these articles that describes how much the same group contributes to our economy. At my home, most of the actual building, wiring, stucco work, roofing, flooring, landsacaping, etc etc was done by workers listening to the local Spanish language radio station. What a great help this was! Is anyone counting that effort, and comparing it to the costs documented in this segment? Unfortuantley the people who benefit from the work done by this group may not be the workers themselves, which is sad.


    Ryan wrote on July 16, 2007 01:08 PM: Nationalism is an infantile disease. It is the measles of mankind. - Albert Einstein

    But the best thing about capitalism is that I get to make my money regardless of illegal immigrants or poor Americans. From the looks of it, it's lower-class to lower-Middle class conservative Americans worrying about this issue more than anybody else. You know what? Get a skill set. Heck, go to ITT. We import a ton of nurses from other countries, go be one of them. Corporate America is going to make sure new laws never get passed, so you'd make changes for own betterment and nobody else's.


    it's time wrote on July 15, 2007 05:45 PM: how long are the citizens going to put up with the illegals?


    Joe C wrote on July 15, 2007 05:18 PM: Joe,
    I have read some of the things you have posted. While this is the first post you have written without it being full of hate for whites, blacks; I don’t believe you have concern for the illegal alien you say work for you.
    In fact I doubt you have anyone working for you and most likely you don’t have a job.
    Just some disgruntle mentally disabled guy his parents gave a computer to so he wouldn’t feel so lonely.
    Plus ditch diggers deserve a fair wage also.
    It’s good this keeps you occupied, this way you’re not in the public much and keeps you from acting out like the guy at VT.


    Read All Comments