Home subscribe manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed

News
Sep. 21, 2007
Copyright © Las Vegas Review-Journal

PANHANDLING: Homeless handouts add up

Survey finds local residents give millions

By LYNNETTE CURTIS
REVIEW-JOURNAL

Herbert Goodland, 45, panhandles Thursday at the southbound U.S. Highway 95 offramp to Charleston Boulevard. He said that on a good day he can make $15 or $20 in an hour panhandling.
Photo by Gary Thompson.



Click image for enlargement.

Kenneth Cofer had been on the job about half an hour Thursday morning and had earned just $1.46.

"It's the first time I've ever been out here," Cofer said while standing at the end of the southbound Interstate 15 offramp to Lake Mead Boulevard, clad in a St. Vincent shelter T-shirt and holding a sign that read: Vietnam vet need a little help thank you.

Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

Most Popular Stories
  • NORM: Phelps galpal gets exposure on Web
  • NORM: Robin Gibb in airport standoff
  • DOUG ELFMAN: Comedian says his arrest a joke
  • NORM: Web site shows life of Mazzeo
  • NORM: Knievel will try jump at Mirage
  • NORM: Wynn coveted cathedral's land
  • Las Vegas police use saturation strategy to cool 'hot spots' of crime
  • FATAL MAULING: Trigger for attack possibly food
  • Judge absolves juror who contacted killer
  • Mesquite casino to close temporarily



    • "I just want about $5 to buy a pack of cigarettes."

    Several miles away, at the southbound U.S. Highway 95 offramp to Charleston Boulevard, a rail-thin, shaggy-haired Herbert Goodland, who lives in a nearby homeless encampment, said he does OK panhandling now and then.

    "On a good day, I can make $15 or $20 in an hour," he said.

    It's difficult to come up with an accurate estimate of how much on average these and other roadside entrepreneurs make.

    But a survey of 107 local panhandlers conducted earlier this year found the monthly median income from panhandling was $192. The results were released Thursday by Applied Survey Research, a California-based nonprofit social research firm that also conducted two recent homeless counts in Clark County.

    The firm put together the 2007 "Southern Nevada Panhandling Study" for the Southern Nevada Regional Planning Coalition's Committee on Homelessness.

    In addition to surveying panhandlers, the firm conducted a random telephone survey of 1,000 Clark County residents to find out how much people were giving to panhandlers.

    Turns out that $1 or $2 every now and then can really add up.

    According to the survey, about 42 percent of locals donated to panhandlers in the past year. The median annual donation was $14. Collectively, they gave about $8.4 million to panhandlers during that time.

    That's more than enough to fund Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada's entire homeless services program for the next two years.

    The total amount of money people give to local panhandlers each year may in fact be higher, because the survey doesn't measure how much money is handed out by visitors to the valley, said Applied Survey Research Vice President Peter Connery.

    Some social service providers have long suggested that the public's money might be better spent on organizations that provide long-term help instead of handouts on the street.

    "Wouldn't it be better to push that money toward a homeless trust fund?" asked Shannon West, regional homeless coordinator for the homeless committee.

    The committee has set up such a fund to support outreach work, crisis services and other needs of the homeless population.

    West plans to use the results of the study in a public education campaign to persuade people to redirect their donations to established organizations.

    When survey respondents were asked whether they would be willing to participate in a program whose aim was to redirect donations from panhandlers to organizations, 58 percent of those who donated money to panhandlers said they would.

    Of those who didn't give to panhandlers, 63 percent said they would participate. But 62 percent of those who gave to panhandlers said such a program wouldn't affect their habit of donating directly to panhandlers.

    The panhandling study was part of a $325,000 contract with Applied Survey Research that included winter and summertime homeless censuses.

    The winter count, conducted in January, estimated that 11,369 people are homeless in Clark County on any given day.

    Results for the summertime count, conducted in July, also were released Thursday. That count found that in the summer about 11,681 homeless people live in Clark County, a difference Connery said was "not statistically significant."

    In a separate, February survey of 1,378 homeless people, about 19 percent said they panhandle.

    It's a myth that panhandlers do pretty well for themselves, Connery said.

    "The people who panhandle are homeless, are poor, have issues and they need help," he said.

    Eighty-one percent of the 107 panhandlers surveyed separately said they were homeless, and 70 percent said they had a disabling condition.

    Goodland, 45, said he is disabled and hasn't been able to find a job that pays enough to put a roof over his head.

    Goodland said if people stopped giving him handouts near the freeway, he still wouldn't spend much time in a homeless shelter.

    "You can only stay in them a certain amount of time," he said. "It's seven days here, three days there. I'd still be back on the street. I want a place to live, but I want to do it on my own."

    The New Jersey native said he has been homeless in Las Vegas for years and takes turns panhandling at the offramp with several other men, working an hour or two at a time.

    The most anyone has ever handed him is $20, he said.

    Cofer, 54, said he was new to panhandling, having been in town from Florida just 20 days and kicked out of a local shelter program for staying out too late a few days back.

    He came to town after hearing Las Vegas "is like paradise," he said, but can't work because of several health problems, including diabetes.

    Cofer recently applied for Social Security benefits, but in the meantime decided to try his luck at a freeway offramp.

    "Some friends told me I could make $75 to $80 a day."

    Cofer, who said he served in the U.S. Air Force during the Vietnam War, didn't seem on course to raise nearly that much.

    "It's OK," he said, rubbing his ample belly. "I won't go hungry."



    Leave Your Comment 15 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Helper wrote on July 21, 2008 12:10 AM: Please visit

    www.help-me-online.com

    Thank You, Helper


    Oliver wrote on October 02, 2007 10:20 AM: After winning $20K in a poker tournament at the Rio, I left and gave the guy on the Flamingo onramp a $100 bill. I thought he was going to have a heart attack. He just kept saying "Thank you, God Bless you, Thank you!!!"


    Michael Ray Thompson wrote on September 21, 2007 07:45 PM: What a life! Homelessness in Las Vegas is rampant. I just wished that the social service agencies in town would at least try to do a better job. The Salvation Army is a madhouse. They offer no security for their clients. There are those that make their living off preying on the homeless. They wait for the clients at the Salvation Army to be locked in for the night and then they rummage through the clients' luggage, which the clients are required to leave in a cage outside the facility. With all of the money that the United Way and other charitable organizations donate to these shelters you would think the homeless could count on some sort of security. Thank you for letting me share my oppinion.


    headscratcher wrote on September 21, 2007 04:19 PM: And the point of this article is....?
    AS MUCH AS $192 PER MONTH! OH MY GOD -- WE'RE BEING TOO KIND TO OTHERS AND ITS CAUSING ECONOMIC DISORDER AND CHAOS IN THE MARKETS! WHATEVER TO DO ABOUT ALL THESE PANHANDLERS!

    Give us a break, already... Did Oscar put you up to this, or just a slow news day with OJ out of town?


    CS wrote on September 21, 2007 03:10 PM: I got a begging letter one day for the hungry and a pic of a man on it saying help so i did, 4 daYS LATER I SAW THIS MAN AT MY FAV CASINO PLAYING 25CENT SLOTS.I WAS PISSED.2 WEEKS LATER A YOUNG LADY AND A LITTLE GIRL WAS SITING OUT SIDE VON'S STORE WITH A SIGN HELP HOMELESS AND HUNGEY SO I GAVE HER MONEY ONLY BECOUSE OF THE LITTLE GIRL. WELL GUESS WHAT THAT NIGHT WHEN I WENT TO MY FAV CASINO I SAW HER PLAYING POKER TALKING TO THE CHANGE GIRL SO I ASKED IF SHE KNEW HER SHE SAID YES SHES ALWAYS IN HERE..SO FROM NOW ON NO ONE GET'S A PENNY FROM ME ITS ALL A SCAM....


    Phil G wrote on September 21, 2007 09:15 AM: Hard to please some of the people here. Illegal Mexicans stand outside at Star Nursery begging for work but we don't want them to use up our social systems paid for by us tax payers and by coming here they are breaking the law. Got it.
    Street people don't appear to want to take those readily available jobs and it appears some would rather make a buck by standing on the corner for a money handout or social security or some type of welfare and i guess the welfare part, still funded by us tax payers is ok cause the street people are legal citizens. Some of us want laws dealing with street people and anybody that donates to them. Got it.
    I think.


    Gary G. wrote on September 21, 2007 09:06 AM: If we let all the productive street corners be available to the homeless, where are the hookers going to stand?


    J wrote on September 21, 2007 08:55 AM: DO NOT GIVE CASH TO PANHANDLERS. Donate to legitimate organizations whose mission it is to help people in these situations. Being homeless may not be a crime, but panhandling is an illegitimate business.


    W wrote on September 21, 2007 08:41 AM: The kids you see on the corner spinning the big arrow signs that point to new home sales offices make from $8 to $12 /hr . . . . . . . . Could the panhandlers handle a job like this? - it beats $192/mo . . . I read that an entrepreneur somewhere put together a business based on panhandlers adding advertising to the signs they already hold up, the problem with this is that human rights groups think this takes advantage of them. . . . They (the panhandlers) are essentially "independent contractors", it is their responsibility to record income for taxes but $2300 year is not enough to tax anyway . . .


    Jen wrote on September 21, 2007 08:17 AM: People who think homeless people should be put in to "camps" need to remember one important fact: Being homeless is not a crime. They may commit crimes, (so do the very wealthy.) They may be an annoyance, (so are the wealthy.) They may be lazy and rude and annoying, (so can... well you get the point.) Just because people find themselves in a horrible situation doesn't make them horrible people.


    Read All Comments