Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun

Breaking News


Harmon inspectors blame breakdowns in communications for problems

The company responsible for ensuring that construction work on CityCenter's Harmon Tower has blamed communications breakdowns between different groups for problems at the project.

Representatives of Converse Consultants Southwest said Tuesday the company, which was a quality assurance agency on CityCenter, is working to improve its practices and is assisting Clark County's efforts to improve its construction inspection process.


Most Popular Stories
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • Three suspects arrested in shooting death of police officer
  • Corrections officer dies in collision on U.S. 95
  • Station Casinos posts $455 million third-quarter loss
  • Two of three suspects in slaying of officer could face death penalty
  • Man sentenced to 15 years for federal tax crimes
  • Las Vegas police shoot at man fleeing after traffic stop
  • Las Vegas police shoot at man fleeing after traffic stop
  • Escalator accident at Caesars Palace still under investigation
  • Las Vegas man denied pardon in killing of abusive father
  • Man pleads guilty in death of girlfriend's child
  • Visitors authority urges officials to call off mock nuclear blast




  • "We learned no program has no weaknesses," Converse attorney Greg Gilbert said at a hearing Tuesday to determine whether Converse's status as a quality assurance agency with the county should be revoked or changed.

    "Direct actions have been taken. I think it's safe to say consultants that have looked at this project have come to the conclusion that best practices are in place," but that something was missed.

    A hearing officer Tuesday heard testimony from county building officials and Converse officials on the company's status and how reinforced steel was placed improperly in the Harmon Tower at MGM Mirage's CityCenter project.

    The hearing officer, Charles Thomas, was appointed by Ron Lynn, director of the Clark County Deverlopment Services Department. Thomas said he expected to have a recommendation on Converse's status by next week, although the county will not be required to accept his decision.

    Thomas, who went through four binders and hundreds of pages of material before the hearing, said the case focuses on 62 daily reports filed by Converse inspectors. In them, the inspectors stated that all reinforcement work was completed properly and matched the construction plans filed with the county.

    "Obviously, that was not accurate," Thomas said.

    Clark County Deputy District Attorney Cliff Jeffers, who represented the county at the hearing, said county inspectors review daily reports from the construction site, but they never received any reports indicating there were any problems with floors six through 20 on the tower.

    MGM Mirage announced in January that the Harmon Tower's top 15 floors were being eliminated after officials determined it would be too expensive to replace reinforcing steel that was improperly installed by Pacific Coast Steel, a subcontractor on the CityCenter project.

    Inspectors from Converse, which holds several third-party inspection contracts at CityCenter, failed to document the errors.

    Gilbert said Converse is not able to fully explain where the communication breakdown occurred, because the firm has limited access to documents held by CityCenter owner MGM Mirage, general contractor Perini Building Corp., and others on the project.

    There were numerous representatives, from the contractors, subcontractors, the county, Converse, the engineer on records and others, on the CityCenter site during construction, Gilbert said.

    "While I can't necessarily answer some of the questions because I don't have all the materials, it is safe to say there was a shortfall in communication that at some point impacted the way in which the project was built," Gilbert said.

    Thomas questioned whether changes in the way the firm worked during the contstruction process could have contributed to Converse inspectors not spotting the faulty work.

    "It's disturbing to me that when you modify your plan, your quality assurance plan, you have to make sure it's going to work," Thomas said. "I don't see the evidence that it was effective."

    According to a Jan. 9 complaint filed by Lynn, reinforcing bar hooks and an unapproved tie system being used in the reinforcing steel was discovered around July 15. Additional problems were noticed by July 18.

    Gilbert said Converse notified the county after the problem was discovered by project engineer Halcrow Yolles.

    An Oct. 18 meeting between county and Converse officials and the two inspectors on the Harmon Tower, Scott Edberg and Joseph Glenn Laurente, determined the faulty work was not properly inspected and that the "documentation of special inspections are materially incorrect and that a substantial lack of required supervision occurred on the site."

    Gilbert said Tuesday that Laurente still is employed by Converse but is not doing concrete inspections. Edberg is no longer with the firm.

    Gilbert assured the hearing officer the firm has visually re-inspected all areas of the project.

    He said his company also has implemented the practice of rotating inspectors on projects to ensure compliance.

    "It's a way of getting a fresh look, a new set of eyes," Gilbert said.

     

    Contact reporter Arnold M. Knightly at aknightly @reviewjournal.com or 702-477-3893.

     

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 11 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    AP wrote on July 01, 2009 03:08 AM: Have a government agency inspect...like the did with the endoscopy clinics or like they do when enforcing the smoking bans?


    tonyss wrote on July 01, 2009 12:05 AM:

    zack wrote on June 30, 2009 07:42 PM:
    sometimes the Quality Control Program is to closely tied to the contractor. The best way to ensure quality is to have the actual government agency inspect and test the work, they can focus solely on quality and not worry about the contractors bottom line. Anytime the contractor has control of the QC firm you are not going to get the same focus on quality, that is just the way it is. Not to mention it is cheaper for the taxpayer to have the county, city or states inspectors/testers perform these functions most of the time these consultants cost over $100 a hour to the taxpayer while actual gov employees come at much lower rate

    Zach...

    one of these days you are going to want to be one of those consultants...

    love ya man..


    Veritas wrote on June 30, 2009 08:53 PM: Monkey See Monkey Do-
    Converse has everything to do with this. They are bound by Clark Co. administrative code. It's no secret their special inspection wing is bogus.


    Breakdown wrote on June 30, 2009 08:52 PM: Another recent instance of breakdowns (sic) in communications:

    http://gizmodo.com/5304233/entire-new-13+story-building-tips-over-in-shanghai/gallery/


    Don Best wrote on June 30, 2009 08:07 PM: Wait a minute. Were the cut sheets wrong? Or did the Ironworkers simply screw up the size and placement of the rebar? Were any of them fired? Before blaming inspectors, you have to assure that you have competent field personnel on the job. As usual, the Union loafers get away with murder. But in about 6 months, they'll need to do it in another state. Good riddance.

    "improperly installed by Pacific Coast Steel, a subcontractor on the CityCenter project". 'Nuff said.


    zack wrote on June 30, 2009 07:42 PM: sometimes the Quality Control Program is to closely tied to the contractor. The best way to ensure quality is to have the actual government agency inspect and test the work, they can focus solely on quality and not worry about the contractors bottom line. Anytime the contractor has control of the QC firm you are not going to get the same focus on quality, that is just the way it is. Not to mention it is cheaper for the taxpayer to have the county, city or states inspectors/testers perform these functions most of the time these consultants cost over $100 a hour to the taxpayer while actual gov employees come at much lower rate.


    Vania wrote on June 30, 2009 07:06 PM: Money See - Money Do said "As long as the Clark County Commissioners continue to allow Ron Lynn to embarrass them, nothing will ever change. Same old song and dance.

    When you have absolutely NO OVERSIGHT by the County, why would anyone comply with building code? It's been ignored for DECADES. Whenever someone points out a flaw, 2 things happen. RON LYNN blames someone else. That someone is FIRED.:

    MAYBE THIS PROBLEM SHOULD BECOME A CAMPAIGN ISSUE FOR WHOEVER RUNS AGAINST RORY REID FOR GOVERNOR.

    RORY, WHAT DOES RON LYNN AND THE INSPECTORS HAVE ON YOU OR YOUR DAD THAT YOU, PERSONALLY, AS CHAIRMAN OF THE COUNTY COMMISSION, CONSISTENTLY FAIL TO FIX THIS MONUMENTAL PROBLEM?


    Vania wrote on June 30, 2009 07:02 PM: "...the inspectors stated that all reinforcement work was completed properly and matched the construction plans filed with the county"

    "An Oct. 18 meeting between county and Converse officials...determined the faulty work was not properly inspected and that the "documentation of special inspections are materially incorrect and that a substantial lack of required supervision occurred on the site."

    Let's go back to the MGM Grand fire. Afterwards, our building codes were updated to make the buildings firesafe. The codes also are supposed to make the buildings earthquake safe. The purpose of these up-to-date building codes, requiring best construction practices, is to keep tourists safe. Tourists are the lifeblood of Las Vegas' economy.

    It's time for the District Attorney to start prosecuting individual inspectors and their employer for criminal fraud in this case. If that doesn't occur, no tourist, and no investor in casino stock, will ever be safe from concern that these highrise hotel towers are NOT safe.

    The District Attorney needs to make an example of these inspectors and their employer, to whom the County Commissioners, County Manager and Ron Lynn delegated the County's duty of due diligence to protect the public.

    And if the District Attorney can make a case against the subcontractor and general contractor, on some theory of fraud or violation of the building codes, it's equally important that they be prosecuted too.

    If the District Attorney doesn't act, these sloppy practices will continue, Lady Luck will insure that one day there will be another hotel disaster and the Las Vegas communities' gross negligence in construction practices will be exposed, destroying public confidence in the county's high rise hotels and in tourist safety.

    There's an old adage "Don't bite the hand which feeds you" and in this case the tourist's hands are feeding most of Las Vegas.


    Monkey See - Monkey Do. wrote on June 30, 2009 06:04 PM: How can Converse be thrown under the bus for following STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE in Clark County?

    Ron Lynn and his gang of incompetents have been busted TIME AND TIME AGAIN for violating the same set of standards. Do you really think that anything has changed?

    As long as the Clark County Commissioners continue to allow Ron Lynn to embarrass them, nothing will ever change. Same old song and dance.

    When you have absolutely NO OVERSIGHT by the County, why would anyone comply with building code? It's been ignored for DECADES. Whenever someone points out a flaw, 2 things happen. RON LYNN blames someone else. That someone is FIRED.

    GOOGLE - Former inspector says new audit repeats old issues.

    Absolutely incredible to see TEFLON RON still blaming others for his MONUMENTAL MISTAKES.

    More incredible for the Clark County Commissioners to be IGNORING THE FACT that the Building Department, under Ron Lynn, has ALWAYS been on the take.

    Read the Kessler Report. It's all in there. Converse has NOTHING to do with this issue.

    GOOGLE - Watchers were not watched.

    Why on earth would RORY REID and the Commission continually give this guy Lynn a FOOLS PASS when it comes to PUBLIC SAFETY. What are they waiting for? Another collapse?




    VegasSmitty wrote on June 30, 2009 05:52 PM: The inspection process ultimately falls on the county building inspectors, but its almost impossible to pry them out of air conditioned offices and do the job they were hired for.


    Read All Comments