Las Vegas News, Sports, Business, Entertainment and Classifieds

Las Vegas Review-Journal - News

Saturday
Mar 20, 2010
Clear
Clear 60° Weather Forecast

RECENT EDITIONS
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

sponsored by
News


Parents ask court to cancel two Henderson school's play productions

Some parents are asking the courts to evict the plays, "Rent" and "The Laramie Project," from the theater of Green Valley High School in Henderson.

The parents are seeking a preliminary injunction in district court that would cancel the performances of two plays with homosexual characters and the theme of social tolerance. They argue that since they object to the adult content, their own kids are essentially excluded from participation in the school's theater program.


Most Popular Stories
  1. Rare, exotic birds killed in fire
  2. Ex-NFL linebacker Livingston dies
  3. Woman tells how suspect killed husband, shot her
  4. Titus, Berkley say they will vote for House bill; 'public is demanding this,' says Titus
  5. Court: Anna Nicole Smith gets none of oil fortune
  6. Northern Iowa guard's 25-foot 3-pointer KOs Rebels
  7. Northern Iowa guard's 25-foot 3-pointer KOs Rebels
  8. Student arrested for bringing gun to school
  9. Republicans subpoenaed in Ensign probe
  10. Madness trip turns into memorial

  • Goodman says wage talks mired in 'gridlock'



  • The controversy has divided the suburban campus as other parents and students protest a perceived threat of censorship.

    The school's theater season's theme is "Controversy, Compassion, Courage" as "The Laramie Project" deals with the brutal slaying of a gay college student in Wyoming and "Rent" is about starving artists coping with drug addiction and AIDS.

    Cory Hilton, the lawyer for the parents objecting to the plays, acknowledged he has not seen the script for either school production but said he is more concerned about process than the content.

    He is afraid of the "slippery slope" that might come if school officials do not follow Clark County School District procedures for presenting controversial subject matter to students.

    He said school district regulations do not allow "R" rated material to be presented to students and parents have a right to weigh in with their opinion if the content is PG-rated.

    Michael Rodriguez, a District spokesman, said Hilton was confusing the district's policy of showing movies in school with school plays. Movies, unlike theater performances, can be compulsory viewing as part of the curriculum. Participation in the plays is voluntary and requires parental permission.

    Sarah Balogh, 17, a senior who plays the lesbian character Maureen in "Rent," a musical, appreciates that her school can be gutsy.

    "We were the first high school to start drug testing (of students)," she said. "We deal with problems head on."

    "The Laramie Project" was presented on Oct. 12 on the 11th anniversary of the murder of Matthew Shepard, the subject of the play. It's scheduled to be presented again Nov. 12-14.

    "Rent" is scheduled for performances in late January and early February.

    The actors say the school has been accused of trying to push a political agenda.

    "That's definitely not what we're doing," said Samantha Ma, 15, an actor in "Rent."

    School officials and students also note that both plays have been toned down for younger audiences.

    "This is what people don't get. It's the high school edition," said Joshua Lovell, 16, who plays the principal character, Mark Cohen, in "Rent."

    There is no illicit drug use and very limited "public displays of affection," Lovell said. "Some hugging, but no kissing," Lovell said.

    Hilton, the lawyer, said he has the support of at least 100 parents from different backgrounds, religious and non-religious.

    Hilton and Rick Magness, a parent of recent graduates, said families feel excluded because they find the content of the plays objectionable.

    Neither Green Valley Principal Jeff Horn nor theater teacher Jennifer Hemme were available for comment Friday. Drama students said Horn selected the school plays.

    In a letter to Hilton, Horn responded that the school has performed many plays in the past with controversial content. "Romeo and Juliet," for instance" dealt with teen suicide and betrayal of parents and "As You Like It" had some cross-dressing.

    Balogh said "Rent" hardly glamorizes drug use or sexuality and the play instead shows the hardships the characters go through.

    "Ultimately, it's about compassion and being there for someone," she said.

    Contact reporter James Haug at jhaug@reviewjournal.com or 702-374-7917.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 181 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    School wrote on November 09, 2009 04:48 PM: CLARK COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT POLICY 6130 (…II. Profanity, inappropriate dress, or any action promoting the acceptability of alcohol, drugs, immoral conduct, or any language that might be interpreted as degrading shall be prohibited).


    Report abuse

    Chrissy wrote on November 06, 2009 06:12 PM: I am an unaffiliated law student who is a former student of GVHS, but this matter has really bothered me.

    If you are a parent or child adversely affected by this lawsuit, you should contact a civil rights organization or attorney soon (such as the ACLU of Nevada, First Amendment Coalition, Human and Civil Rights Organizations of America, etc) to support your rights. I'd write an amicus brief if I could, but unfortunately, it wouldn't be considered by the judge :(

    If the motion wins on November 10, the show will be stopped. That would truly be unfortunate.


    Report abuse

    Chrissy wrote on November 06, 2009 05:48 PM: The district policy that the entire lawsuit is based on 6150(13)is applicable only to electronic media. A play is never electronic media. The policy states:

    "any portion of electronic media in any format that is rated "R" or "PG-13" shall not be shown to students ant any grade level within the school district under any circumstances."

    Simply highlighting the term "in any format" does not transmute a live play into electronic media.

    The lawsuit is baseless and frivolous. Hilton is a practicing attorney and should know better. No policy has been violated.

    On 11/10/09 the judge will hear plaintiff's motion for a preliminary injunction to stop the Laramie Project. Let us pray the judge has the common sense to comprehend the plain meaning of the policy.

    I loved Green Valley when I went there and my heart goes out to current students of GVHS theater.

    If you don't like the plays, don't go. There are many other plays that are showing this season that you can view and your children can participate in.

    Don't try to hide behind a district policy that doesn't exist. It is insulting.


    Report abuse

    ANS wrote on October 29, 2009 11:45 PM: "the how are still google on" was supposed to say "the shows are still going on"


    Report abuse

    ANS wrote on October 29, 2009 11:42 PM: One, your efforts to sue the district is pointless. Even if,by some psychotic happenings, you're side is to win the suit, the how are still google on, just not on school campus. We have tremendous support from the community, and other venues are offerring to host the show. Two, did you know that the president just signed to pass theatthew Sheppard Act? And the House Of Representatives made a proclamation acknowledging those who participate in the Larimie Project: Ten Years Later which, Third, we've already performed. We are not excluding anyone by putting on these productions, you are excluding yourselves. I know the daughters of those during and I have not treated them differently at all, however, if this feud cotinues, all you will be doing is distancig relationships and starting controversy in the school. There has been no buzz of any of this at school. You are making a big deal out of nothing. We are not advertising these productions at all. Guess what? You are. We've had more ticket sales since you started this. So thank you! :) Anyways, I think you all should take the time tht you are wasting on this and spend it with your family. One of your defenses is that you don't want your children exposed to them, you are the ones exposing it. Think about that and stop crushing dreams. This is my first and last lead role at Green Valley, since I won't be in town for the spring show. Why are you trying to take that away from me?
    me?


    Report abuse

    Abolish_public_education wrote on October 29, 2009 03:38 PM: If you have to change the content, then you are censoring it.

    The only time this sort of "editing" is evil is when you have to change an expression for fear of government sanctions.


    Report abuse

    Mike Roderick wrote on October 28, 2009 09:19 PM: It's interesting that the advocates for the plays say that the opposition group is trying to censor them, but then say that they are going to perform and "toned down" "high school version" of the plays. That is the actual definition of censorship. If you have to change the content, then you are censoring it.


    Report abuse

    against wrote on October 28, 2009 04:52 PM: As a Jehovah's Witness, it is against my beliefs to celebrate holidays. Should we ban "It's a Charlie Brown Christmas" or "Miracle on 42nd Street" because I can't participate? Ditto for singing the National Anthem before every event at school. I can't participate, but I am respectful because it is what is required in a civilized society.


    Report abuse

    Abolish_public_education wrote on October 28, 2009 04:48 PM: Nevada spends about 8500 per student

    Your accounting is WAY OFF. You neglect costs such as debt (which NPRI reports as $11,776 per kid) and teacher pensions. The real number is > $10,000 per student! Of course, even a penny per kid would be too much.

    The reason people come here for K-12 daycare is because we subsidize the service, which turns it into a welfare magnet. If we didn't, Nevada parents who value education would find private alternatives. Freeloaders would move to CA.


    Report abuse

    M.G. wrote on October 28, 2009 02:37 PM: GV Student....

    An excellent and articulate response. Further proof that our public education system is working despite cries to the contrary.

    Unfortunately... in this case, you are incorrect. The Laramie Project is not, nor was it ever intended as a Satire. It is "actual interviews" recreated from the interviews this project did in visiting Laramie Wyoming. They believe what they are stating is an true representation. Their depiction of Christian religion is despicable. Please read the projects website and then reread the script in the light they intend it. It is highly offensive.


    Read All Comments