Comments (13) | Add a comment
Nurses targeted by police
-
DUANE PROKOP/LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
Two nurses at Sunrise Children's Hospital have been suspended while Las Vegas police investigate them in connection with "intentional patient harm," according to records from the Nevada State Board of Nursing. » Buy this photo
Tools
-
One newborn at Sunrise Children's Hospital was left in critical condition by a catheter disruption in a case that is being investigated by Las Vegas police. Another infant had to undergo an emergency procedure as a result of a catheter disruption, the hospital reported. DUANE PROKOP/LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL » Buy this photo
©2010 LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNAL
Updated: Jul. 20, 2010 | 1:28 p.m.
Two Sunrise Children's Hospital nurses whose licenses were suspended because of disrupted catheters -- which left one newborn in critical condition -- are targets of a Las Vegas police investigation into "intentional patient harm," State Board of Nursing records reveal.
Another infant had to undergo an emergency procedure as a result of a catheter disruption, the hospital reported.
Registered nurses Jessica May Rice and Sharon Ochoa-Reyes were suspended by nursing board President Doreen Begley "in the interest of public health, safety and/or welfare" after the regulatory agency received notice on June 10 from law enforcement officials that each nurse was a "person of interest" in an "ongoing criminal investigation," according to documents obtained Tuesday under the Nevada public records law.
Rice received her Nevada nursing license in 2006, Ochoa-Reyes in 1991.
The nursing board documents reveal that while Rice and Ochoa-Reyes were employed at Sunrise in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, "a patient suffered physical harm" and "other patients were exposed to the potential for physical harm."
No details were given as to what kind of harm the newborn received or whether the unplanned operation of the other newborn was necessary to save the child's life.
When the child was critically injured and what steps have been taken to keep the child alive have not been revealed.
Sunrise officials disclosed Friday in their only statement on the matter that they had asked police to investigate 14 incidents of disrupted catheters in its intensive care unit for newborns going back to February.
Attempts to reach Rice and Ochoa-Reyes were unsuccessful.
On her page on the MySpace social networking website, Rice wrote about her job as a nurse at Sunrise: "I am also a very hard working RN that loves her jobs dearly. The babies that I spend time with bring me joy and happiness."
Her site says she is 32, graduated from Clark High School in Las Vegas and previously worked at Cincinnati Children's Hospital.
Amber Lopez Lasater, chief of staff for Service Employees International Union Local 1107, the union representing the nurses, said Tuesday: "We will issue a public statement once the police investigation is finished."
Las Vegas police Capt. Patrick Neville said late Monday that the criminal investigation was ongoing and weeks away from any conclusion.
District Attorney David Roger said it was too early to decide whether criminal charges should be filed. "It is very troubling, if true," Roger said.
Sunrise officials have not disclosed when they asked police to investigate the catheter disruptions, only that they did so after an umbilical catheter, which has a low failure rate, was somehow disrupted.
Sunrise officials said they initially thought the problems with catheter tubings, which are used to draw blood and deliver medications and nutrition, were technical in nature.
The nursing board documents show that Rice was suspended June 10, the same day the board learned she was a figure in a criminal probe, and that Ochoa-Reyes was suspended July 9, the same day Sunrise officials notified the public that they had "identified an issue with disrupted catheters ... in February of this year."
Katherine Ramsland, a criminologist at DeSales University in Pennsylvania who has long studied health care workers who run afoul of the law, said Sunrise officials now must study incidents and deaths in the neonatal unit "over many months and perhaps years."
Sunrise officials would not say how many infants had what medical officials term "unexpected outcomes" when Rice or Ochoa-Reyes was on duty in the neonatal unit.
Ramsland said nurses who do harm to patients are very good at covering up what they do. "Often they're not caught for years," she said.
Nurses who harm patients are known as "Angels of Death" because after they are caught they say they were putting patients out of their misery.
Ramsland said nurses who engage in mercy killing generally do so with those who are the most defenseless, either infants or the elderly.
She said it also is not unusual for an "Angel of Death" nurse to force a patient into a medical crisis so the nurse can be seen as heroic in saving the patient's life.
Ramsland said a former pediatric nurse in Texas, Genene Anne Jones, is the most infamous "Angel of Death." In 1985, she was sentenced to 99 years in a Texas prison for killing 15-month-old Chelsea McClellan with succinylcholine.
Authorities believe Jones killed between 11 and 46 infants and children in her care, using injections of drugs to force them into a medical crisis with the intention of reviving them to receive praise. Many children could not be revived, however.
Ramsland cautioned against jumping to conclusions in cases of unusual deaths and injuries in hospitals. She noted that with so many medications and technologies, death can occur in mysterious ways.
"You don't want to convict an innocent nurse," she said.
In 1980, Sunrise nurse Jani Adams was accused of killing a patient by reducing the flow of oxygen to his respirator. But a judge dismissed the case, ruling that the evidence did not prove that a crime had been committed.
The recent Sunrise case has caused groups and professionals who deal with childbirth to remind expectant parents to always ask questions about a hospital.
Mandie Medford, who owns HypnoBirthing Las Vegas, a specialized natural childbirth training program, said it is incumbent upon Sunrise and all other hospitals to be as transparent as possible about incidents that occur.
"If parents don't get the answers they need to questions about what is going on in the hospital, then they should go to another hospital," Medford said. "If you can't trust the people to tell you the truth about what's gone on and what they've done about it, then parents should be responsible and go somewhere else. There is no way you can be comfortable there."
Rachel VanHorn, who used the HypnoBirthing technique to give birth to her son, now 11 months old, said she has closely followed media reports about the Sunrise catheter incidents. VanHorn said she and her husband plan on expanding their family soon.
"If I was going to have a baby there, I would definitely want to know what happened and what they did about it," she said. "If the information is not given freely, I'm not inclined to go there."
VanHorn, a biologist, said she reads every medical report she can get about a hospital's outcomes.
"I think I have a responsibility as a parent to get as much data as I can," she said.
Dr. Richard Chudacoff, an obstetrician-gynecologist, said he always tells his patients during pregnancy to take tours of hospitals and ask "enough questions to make you comfortable."
And, he said, expectant families should frequently talk to doctors about their experiences at hospitals.
Sherry Hopkins, who runs Well Rounded Mama, a resource center for expectant families, said she wishes hospitals and medical practitioners would give people more insight into what goes on in health care so that they can make intelligent choices.
"But everybody is afraid of malpractice," she said. "Everybody is afraid of getting sued, so we don't end up knowing very much. That's the biggest problem I see in health care."
Review-Journal reporter Brian Haynes contributed to this story. Contact Paul Harasim at pharasim@reviewjournal.com or 702-387-2908.
Comments
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Review-Journal does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please use the Report Abuse button.
Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 24 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
This article written by Paul Harasim was sensationalist and incendiary. Until the facts are known and the investigation is complete, I think it is irresponsible of Mr. Harasim to liken the "disrupted catheters" to murder and Angels of Death. I have known Sharon Reyes and her family for over 10 years and chose her to be my son's charge nurse 7 years ago when he was in the NICU at Sunrise Hospital. I know her to be a competent, caring and professional nurse and owe my son's life to her many times over. I hope that when the investigation is complete and her name is cleared that she will be able to get back to caring for those precious, fragile, little babies that need her.
Good job Sunrise for calling in a Police Investigation! I still believe Sunrise has the BEST NICU in our city! There are bad people in every profession, its not the hospitals or other nurses fault for a faulty employee. I will still be delivering my baby there!
Honestly, I don't know the whole story, and ofcourse, everyone is waiting to see what the truth is. it's a shame that because of these two nurses, this hospital is being bashed left and right. all you people are talking about are the negatives about this hospital. have you even heard of all the good things that this hospital has done? I have been a patient of this hospital since I was a child, and eventough there havebeen few rough times, I believe this hospital to be one of the best. I feel alot of you are being hypocritical, because you say this place is dirty, and that you would never bring your kids here, but, how about all the other hospitals? i'm sure they have made mistakes, and unfortuantely, these two nurses are not helping with what they did. I'm not trying to defend them, because I am just as angered about their stupid actions, but I am saying this. This I believe is one of the best hospitals I have been in, and though all of you want to try and make people believe that it's not, well, i believe you need to rethink it. Nobody is perfect, and everyone that works there works really hard to take care of every single patient, and whoever doesn't think so, well, to each their own. even the person who wrote this, "ask specific questions, and ask them this and that and exactly what they did." uh, hello! everyone was not standing there when this happened! so, naturally, all we can do is follow your stupid reports. so, then maybe, when someone asks your "specific questions", should they refer them to you then? because apparently, you know everything. seriously people. stop being so cut throat about this. every hospital makes mistakes, even your dear st. rose"s. seriously, think before you start bashing on something else.
Perhaps I misread the story, but it seems as though the nurses's licenses were suspended for being part of a criminal inquiry, but it doesn't say they were suspected of the same crime (harm to patients) It seems, as was stated below) highly unlikely that two "Angels of Death" were working together.
Maybe one of them is a killer and the other is just stealing meds, or some other more mundane crime?
Our son was in the N.I.C.U. at Sunrise for five months and was cared for mainly by Sharon. I can without a doubt say that she is one of the most qualified and kindest nurses at Sunrise. We owe our sons life to Sharon as she saved it many times!
The article makes many wild assertions; Sharon is as good as they come...
Something seems wierd here. Ok, I can understand that there may be An Angel of Death at a hospital, but two at the same time? Seems like somethig else may be going on at the hospital or equipment people are trying to hang the nurses out to dry.
Shame on the RJ for posting their names before the investigation is complete. One (if not both of these ladies) has done nothing but provide loving care to the most fragile of patients and will now forever been seen as a monster. When Metro completes their investigation the guilty will be dealt with. The innocent will never recover her reputation thanks to the RJ (you can't unring a bell). I know from first hand experience that the Sunrise NICU has an outstanding staff of RNs and LPNs who are dedicated to the best outcomes for their patients. My grandson passed through their hands and Sunrise is the only hospital in Las Vegas that our family trusts enough to care for our children
I cannot comment on what these nurses allegedly did, because I don't have the facts.
However, as a person who has spent a 3 1/2 month stretch in two separate hospitals, and then a 1 month stretch in another hospital, I do know a clean hospital when I see one.
I am the parent of a child who was a patient in Sunrise's Childrens Hospital for a week. During that week, her room was never cleaned. Everything in the room was grungy. In contrast, the childrens unit at UMC was sparkling and pristine when my child was a patient there.
I would NEVER allow my child or grandchild to be an inpatient at Sunrise Hospital under any circumstance.
@nbarendt The staph infection was probably caused by nurses who were wearing artificial nails. Artificial nails were found to be a source of many, many staph infections for neonates, as bacteria would get trapped in the crevices between the nails and the nail bed. NICU's(and JCAHO - the hospital accreditation board) banned nurses from wearing artificial nails around 2002.
My son was a patient in Sunrise's NICU in 1995. The nurses were excellent. They saved his life. What are the chances that there were two "angels of death" working in the same hospital and in the same department? Something just doesn't add up here. Hope the truth is discovered.
All I know is my nephew back in the 80's died from a staff infection while in Sunrise Intensive Care Neonatal he was 7 weeks old. His nurse who my sister trusted and really liked retired after 2 weeks of taking care of him was surprised that he passed he should have made it she found out what killed him and told my sister what he died from staff infection which means somthing was dirty the equipment or the nurses hands and that she should hold the hospital responsible. I would never recommend anyone to take their child to this hospital. Even though this was a long time ago it is apparent that this hospital does not take care of your babies. Don't they have a Intensive Care Neonatal at one of the St Rose hospitals?