Home subscribe manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon

Opinion


VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: 'To train school children in ... loyalty to the state'

Don't you love it when a member of the ruling class slips up and admits to the peasants what they're really up to?

For years, I've called for the complete shutdown of America's massive archipelago of mandatory government youth propaganda camps. The defenders of this Largest Jobs Program in History shriek and bellow that I must be "against education," which is sort of like charging those who opposed slave galleys with being against ocean navigation.

Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

Most Popular Stories
  • ERIN NEFF: Sarah Palin: It's just wrong
  • LETTERS: One angry man speaks for millions
  • EDITORIAL: Risky loans
  • EDITORIAL: A failure of leadership
  • EDITORIAL: Public records assault
  • VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: The biggest armed robbery in history
  • LETTERS: To fix crisis, vote incumbents out
  • LETTERS: Bill must hold CEOs accountable
  • LETTERS: Crushing freedom for the 'greater good'
  • EDITORIAL: VP debate unlikely to change minds



  • Read de Tocqueville for his amazement at the high level of literacy -- including an ability to discuss complex political issues -- found among American workingmen of the 1830s -- 20 years before Dewey and Mann launched today's government-run youth camps on the Prussian model in Massachusetts in 1852.

    The New York Times reported Feb. 27 that fewer than half of American teenagers know when the Civil War was fought, and one in four believe Columbus sailed to the New World some time after 1750. About a quarter of the teenagers were unable to correctly identify Hitler as Germany's chancellor in World War II, instead identifying him in a multiple-choice test as a munitions maker or premier of Austria.

    Why is anyone surprised? The academic curriculum is the "cover," the "front." The real goal is not to ensure, but rather to ensure against successive generations developing a cohesive philosophy of self-sufficiency, a code of ethics appropriate to a free people living under a government of limited powers. The goal is to make sure successive generations are powerless to muster the historical and economic context, logic and critical thinking skills necessary to see through the latest scheme to seize yet more of our wealth and use the loot to hire more bureaucrats to regulate yet another portion of our lives, our industry, our commerce.

    California's 2nd District Court of Appeal on Feb. 28 declared the parents of most of that state's 166,000 home-schooled children to be outlaws, ruling the law requires parents to send their children to full-time state-certified public or private schools or else have them taught at home by "credentialed" tutors -- which most home-school parents, presumably, aren't.

    "California courts have held that ... parents do not have a constitutional right to homeschool their children," Justice H. Walter Croskey said in the 3-0 ruling, which makes it clear those parents can be criminally prosecuted for failing to comply.

    And did Judge Croskey and his black-robed ruling-class pals say this was because the home-schoolers weren't doing as well at teaching reading, writing and 'rithmetic?

    Of course not. They couldn't say that, because tests consistently shows home-school kids, taught by parents without state "certificates" or licenses, score 30 to 37 percentile points higher than their public school peers across all subjects.

    So why ban home-schooling, if the academic results are far better?

    Judge Croskey obligingly explained: "A primary purpose of the educational system is to train school children in good citizenship, patriotism and loyalty to the state and the nation as a means of protecting the public welfare."

    Imagine that. "Loyalty to the state." Almost as if what they're running are, I don't know ... mandatory government youth propaganda camps, or something.

    -- -- --

    K.G. writes in: "Dear Mr Suprynowicz, I wasn't always a homeschooler. I stumbled upon J.T. Gatto while researching school reform after dealing with my local school district and getting nowhere but Delphi'd and a SLAPP letter.

    "I read 'Underground History' -- in fact, I was unable to put it down. It explained HOW IT HAS BEEN DONE, how Americans have been turned into stupid, apathetic, self-absorbed, toadying sheep. ... At this stage of the game the social engineers no longer even pretend to educate. They 'socialize', they 'mold minds', they decide who will go to college and 'lead' and who will dig ditches for the local business-government or the national corporate state.

    "After finishing that book I had to get my kids out, pronto. I regret that they spent their most formative years in the govschool gulag learning to take orders and stand in line, raising their hands to go to the toilet. In fact, when I told my youngest daughter, starting '3rd grade', that we would be homeschooling, she asked me if she would be allowed to go to the toilet whenever she wanted. I almost cried. ..."

    -- -- --

    A local attorney writes in: "Mr. Suprynowicz -- Government schools are liberal indoctrination camps, nothing more. My son was shown 'An Inconvenient Truth' during 4th grade and now berates my wife for using plastic bags. He is a GATE student (gifted) but curiously received a 'C' after he disagreed with his teacher that global warming was caused by human activity. He said no humans were around when the last ice age melted and for that he was punished.

    "His teacher went on to teach the class that President Bush used cocaine and that the moon landing was staged. She had white students apologize to black students for slavery and (said) that taxpayers should pay reparations because slavery destroyed the black family. He was also taught that a perfect electric car was made many years ago but the oil companies killed those responsible. ...

    "My cousin home schools his children. His son who is 15 ... is taking college level classes through independent study. He is showing an affinity for geometry and physics. ... He is reading books about maritime history ... non-stop even though his reading 'level' is below what some standardized test says it should be.

    "When he attended a public school in Belmont, Calif., he was put in special classes for learning disabled children. No doubt his teachers had high hopes he would become a dishwasher. ..."

    -- -- --

    J.B. writes in from upstate New York that John Taylor Gatto's "book, 'Dumbing Us Down' was instrumental in helping me make my decision to homeschool my two children, and we are in our fourth year of doing so. ...

    "Anyway, just wanted to take a moment to thank you for helping to get the word out on the largest crime ever perpetrated on the human race: the locking away and dumbing down of our beautiful, vibrant, smart, loving children.

    "I dream of a day when the parents rise up, en masse, and scream for their release!"

     

    Vin Suprynowicz is assistant editorial page editor of the Review-Journal and author of the novel "The Black Arrow." See www.vinsuprynowicz.com/.



    Leave Your Comment 43 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Lord Vader wrote on March 28, 2008 12:25 PM: At this rate, what's next? Soon they'll really be teaching that blacks were the first Egyptians and could fly until the evil white man stole their powers and enslaved them. They might as well, everything else they teach is BS.

    Believe it or not, desegregation of schools has much to do with it. Next came affirmitive action "teachers" who constantly tried to tell me what an evil cracker I was.


    William wrote on March 27, 2008 11:38 AM: Do you expect this problem to be solved by the presidential village idiot who can't put a sentence together even when he's reading it?

    "Is our children learning?"


    billy chav wrote on March 23, 2008 11:23 PM: John Dewey was born in 1859, so he probably wasn't launching any youth camps--government-run or otherwise-- in 1852. But how could you know that, if you yourself were educated in one of those youth camps Dewey launched in 1852? Now I'm getting vertigo.


    Paolo wrote on March 22, 2008 04:38 PM: Jeremy says:

    "If all these people are so dumbed down because of bad schools, how are they going to teach their kids any better by homeschooling?"

    That subject has been discussed many times on these pages. First of all, per Montessori, children are not so much "taught" as they "learn." A "teacher" can set up activities for a child, and occasionally explain something the child may not understand. But the child does the work of "learning" largely on his own. Parents in general, and especially parents of home schooled kids, quickly learn that children are made to learn; it takes a government-run bureaucracy to squeeze the love of learning out of them.

    Next comment: "By the way, loyalty to the state can also be construed as patriotism, isn't that what cons complain isn't being taught?" [sic on the punctuation].

    That is a particularly shallow view of patriotism, don't you think? More often than not, patriotism requires opposing state. German schools in the 1930's were particularly adept at teaching "loyalty to the state." Were the young Nazi party members who graduated "patriots"?

    I congratulate Jeremy on a grain of truth, however: most "cons" DO want "patriotism" to be "taught." That is the worst aspect of today's "conservatives"--especially the Neocons.

    Most people cannot think deeply enough to understand there is a difference between "love of country" and "love of state." Usually, one precludes the other.


    Bill Smith wrote on March 22, 2008 10:08 AM: Only fascists support government schools Jeremy.

    What is this "real education" you speak of?

    Let's see your "evidence" also Jeremy since you dismiss what Vin has written.


    Jeremy wrote on March 21, 2008 07:57 PM: Wow, what paranoid fascist imagery you employ, but it's a cover for the shoddiness of your argument. If all these people are so dumbed down because of bad schools, how are they going to teach their kids any better by homeschooling? Let's try to fix what we have, so can your juvenile cliches and do something to fix the problem. By the way, loyalty to the state can also be construed as patriotism, isn't that what cons complain isn't being taught? You use anecdotes and some stats then proclaim some great truth but your reasoning is shoddy and illogical, maybe you need to get some real education too?


    NlGGERMANIAC wrote on March 21, 2008 12:26 PM: When will humans say ENOUGH ! to this constant NlGGER Loving Bull$$$$!!!?

    NlGGERMANIA dot COM


    Jerry Taylor, WV wrote on March 21, 2008 10:15 AM: I graduated high school (HS) in 1965. The "town" kids were expected to excell in life, and us "country" kids were not expected to do as well. We were expected to become the ditch diggers, but only by the younger teachers. Those teachers, nearing the ends of their careers, were truely dedicated to each and every student. Looking back, we were in the transitional generation(s). Ironically, a higher % of country kids graduated college (me in 1970), than did the town kids. We were all fortunate to have had enough of the "right" teachers in our lives.

    However, when my kids went to HS (1990s) the difference was most noticable regarding those who drove a Lexus or BMW vs those who, like my kids, rode the bus. The "bus" kids were treated like 2nd class citizens, and, their grades showed it - regardless of their intelligence and potential. It was a true and obvious Self Fulfilling Prophecy, placed upon them by their teachers, as well as by their fellow students - those with the cars, etc.

    My oldest held her own and did OK. I had to pull the youngest and put her in a private HS. She did tremendously well in THAT environment.


    Bill SMith wrote on March 21, 2008 04:39 AM: A nice start would be to allow only net taxpayers to vote. People who receive any kind of government assistance (including having children in public schools, socialistic security) or work for any level of government (police, teachers, military, fireman, elected officials, various bureaucrats, etc) would not be able to vote. If you get paid with tax dollars, it is impossible that you pay taxes. It only appears so on paper.


    Paolo wrote on March 20, 2008 07:59 PM: Most parents now do not realize the power they have to cause real change in society. If more and more parents kept their kids away from the propaganda camps, those camps would get less and less money, while (simultaneously) more and more children would become independent-thinking adults.

    If only more parents understood the power they have. For those of you who read this, I say: RESCUE YOUR CHILDREN TODAY! DON'T WAIT ANOTHER DAY. TAKE THEM AWAY FROM THE SPIRIT-CRUSHING PROPAGANDA CAMPS! You can teach them better than any bottom-third certificated education "professional." Just take the first step, parents! You will be amazed at the power you have to change the direction of this country.


    Read All Comments