Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat

Opinion


On the road to health care hell

Blame government, not free markets for this mess

Currently, Southern Nevada news is full of reports of assembly-line colonoscopies, hepatitis C infections, clinics ignoring the most basic safety protocols, criminal medical investigations and a collapse of public confidence.

Welcome to the future of American health care.


Most Popular Stories
  • VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: What stops mass murderers? A gun
  • SHERMAN FREDERICK: Call evil by its rightful name
  • EDITORIAL: Terrorism on trial
  • EDITORIAL: A pre-9/11 approach to terror
  • LETTERS: Public-sector workers are still doing well
  • LETTERS: Harry Reid: Working hard for all Americans
  • EDITORIAL: 'That's the ticket!'
  • Our politicians are the greatest, all right
  • EDITORIAL: I believe in free speech, but ...
  • LETTERS: A giant octopus threatens rural Nevada




  • For the past two generations, the U.S. system of federally dominated, third-party "managed care" medicine has been on a direct trajectory toward this ignominious point.

    While an embarrassed Silver State now finds itself in the national spotlight, the main engines driving degradation of health-care quality are actually national. Moreover, they have been in place, gathering increasing momentum, for a very long time.

    First, a rarely publicized truth: The hidden bone fields of American medicine are already remarkably large. Consider the year-2000 study, To Err Is Human, published by the Institute of Medicine of the National Academies. Its authors reviewed U.S. hospital medical records and found that as many as 98,000 people die every year from medical errors.

    Even those numbers, however, may be a substantial under-estimate: the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) says 2 million patients contract hospital-acquired infections each year, with 90,000 of them dying as a result. In addition, there is the entire subject of medication errors. Last year the Institute of Medicine estimated, based on multiple studies, "that about one medication error occurs per patient per day in hospital care."

    In that report, Preventing Medication Errors, the Institute of Medicine also returned to the subject of its earlier, groundbreaking work.

    "The key messages of To Err Is Human," said the Institute, "were that there are serious problems with the quality of health care delivery; that these problems stem primarily from poor health care delivery systems, not incompetent individuals; and that solving these problems will require fundamental changes in the way care is delivered."

    That American health care's problems are systemic is an argument we often hear from advocates of socialized medicine. But the rarely admitted reality is that we already have socialized medicine. And it is that system that is increasingly devolving into -- and subjecting us to -- bureaucratically indifferent, incompetent and callous Soviet-style medicine.

    Michael F. Cannon, director of health-policy studies at the Cato Institute, made this point emphatically last October:

    "We've already got socialized medicine. Government already pays for half of Americans' medical care. Government controls production and consumption by determining the number of physicians; what services medical professionals can offer and under what terms; where they can practice; who can open a hospital or purchase a new MRI; who can market a drug or medical device; and what kind of health insurance consumers may purchase. Government even sets the prices for half of our health-care sector directly, and indirectly sets prices for the other half."

    Yes, said Cannon, "Much of the U.S. health-care sector is private. But private markets are not necessarily free markets. What matters is who controls how the resources are used. More often than not, that 'who' is government."

    Consider, as an example, how federal rules operate to reduce the quality of care for certain patients. Because Medicare's price-fixing system pays only predetermined fixed sums for treatment of numerous categories of illness, the actual cost to physicians and hospitals of delivering medical care can vary enormously, depending on the patient.

    The result is to effectively ration care for the poor, the old and the sick. Because the government, not the patient, controls the treatment price, the system offers big economic incentives for assembly-line medicine that ignores the actual individual needs of such patients.

    Precisely such a case was recently reported in Las Vegas -- 78-year-old Duke Breuer, sent home from the Endoscopy Center of Southern Nevada, an IV needle still sticking in his arm.

    The impact of the federal government's bureaucratic one-size-fits-all system goes far beyond elderly Medicare patients. Because government-paid medicine so dominates U.S. health care, most large third-party payers have, for economic reasons, also adopted its approach. Nevada and many other states, for example, use the same system in their Medicaid programs for low-income patients. Ditto for numerous private insurers' programs.

    Another major way government is driving America down the road toward health-care hell is by its repeated and politically motivated exemption of the health-care industry -- medical professionals, insurers, pharmaceutical companies and hospitals -- from the competitive and accountability-producing dynamics of free markets.

    Today, as special-interest rent seekers, left-wing ideologues and mentally challenged politicians agitate for a full-blown, coercive, police-state health-care socialism, it's worthwhile to stop and reflect just a moment:

    If you like the growing problems America has now, you'll love the mess we'll have later.

     

    Steven Miller is vice president for policy at the Nevada Policy Research Institute.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 4 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    ralph wrote on March 16, 2008 05:59 PM: EdR- where whas your all knowing all serving government when it came to regulating these places? Whether these centers were private or public, they still would have had the same rotten administration and the same inept inspections. Personally, I would love to give Walmart a shot at managing our health care. I seriously doubt Walmart could be worse than the government.


    dont pass the buck wrote on March 16, 2008 03:07 PM: Nevada has mega issues in every direction. The bottom of the barrel. A cesspool.

    I totally agree with the direction things are going nationwide as for the state healthcare.

    But the responsibilty for Nevada's problems...ALL OF THEM...rests on taxpayer paid elected officials here in Nevada.

    Our back yard sucks...lets deal with what we can do something about and deal with Nevada's elected officials.

    Before we get over reeling over one issue we get hit with another...international news!!!

    I dont know of any state that is perfect...but I also dont know of any with so many out of control issues.


    Ed. R. wrote on March 16, 2008 11:30 AM: Ah, the Nevada Policy Research Institute, the community college of the region's wanna-be intellectuals, wracked its brain and discovered that infecting patients with reused needles isn't about criminal negligence and greed, but about Evil Socialism(TM)! If you don't want some quack poking you with a dirty needle because he's an angry victim of government regulation, then look to "the competitive and accountability-producing dynamics of free markets" to get superior Walmart-style, Chinese-manufactured quality medical care!


    Dr F Coles wrote on March 16, 2008 09:13 AM: The government caused the entire problem with health care in America by over socializing (with unfunded mandates) medicine to the extent it is not completive. The government allows a monopolistic pharmaceutical environment, and the FDA a federal agency failing American citizens and needs be eliminated or completely re-organized; and is causing a major impact on the cost of healthcare in America, and we want to exacerbate the problem? http://www.InteliOrg.com/