Home subscribe manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue

Opinion


ERIN NEFF: Ten minutes with John McCain

After taking a shot at Sen. Barack Obama for "having no plan" during an interview last week, Sen. John McCain clearly showed he should have pointed the criticism inward.

McCain was in town to raise money this past Wednesday, but he included an energy speech at UNLV and a quick chat with supporters at his new office in Henderson.

Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

Most Popular Stories
  • LETTERS: No school administrator left behind
  • LETTERS: Professor needs to get with the program
  • LETTERS: Washington loves rewarding failure
  • FROM OUR READERS: We can't do worse than country's current leadership
  • VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Shall we save the economy ... or the government?
  • EDITORIAL: The governor's e-mail
  • EDITORIAL: Tuition hikes
  • LETTERS: Don't expect district to cut waste
  • EDITORIAL: Sending the right message
  • EDITORIAL: 'A cautionary tale'



  • In a 10-minute interview dominated by discussion of the Yucca Mountain Project, the presumptive Republican nominee showed he's learned a lot in all those years as a nuclear dump proponent.

    The problem: He's incapable of evolving on the subject. His environmental plan, if you want to call it that, calls for new coal, gas and nuclear plants and -- apparently -- paying the Russians to reprocess the radioactive waste.

    "We're going to build power plants in America, they're going to be coal-fired or natural gas or nuclear," McCain said. "Right now clean coal is not where we want it to be," he added. "To say that I'm not going to do nuclear power because we can't solve the waste problem when the French are doing it is a mistake."

    But McCain doesn't really solve the nuclear waste problem. He boasts about his call to spend more money on scientific research into alternative energies, yet doesn't want to stray from the tried-and-true "dump it in Nevada" policy.

    He supports reprocessing, but he isn't keen on doing that at Yucca Mountain, 100 miles northwest of Las Vegas.

    "My understanding is that the first priority for Yucca Mountain, if it ever opened -- and it's not clear whether it will ever meet the environmental requirements that it's going through both in and out of court -- that it would be the defense nuclear fuel that would have the first priority," McCain said. "So what do you do with all the spent nuclear fuel that's sitting at nuclear power plants all over America? Wait 15, 20 years?" he asked.

    Under a McCain administration, assuming the Department of Energy won its licensing fight and court battles with Nevada, Yucca Mountain would be the default plan.

    If you believe McCain's assumption about the piles of civilian waste around the country, it wouldn't be sufficient. But McCain had no additional information about the reprocessing plan he calls central to both global warming and nuclear proliferation.

    The Russians would have to work with the French, and then McCain said he'd have to negotiate with Vladimir Putin, the former Russian president who floated the idea to him, to figure out how much we're going to pay to export our garbage.

    What a win-win.

    "Nuclear power plants are a vital part of eliminating greenhouse gas emissions," he said. "(To) people who are against nuclear power, what about what can give our children a damaged planet? That is greenhouse gas emissions. You've got to have nuclear power if you're going to address greenhouse gas emissions."

    So his entire plan involves a handshake with Putin and then hands off.

    I asked McCain about sports betting and Internet gaming, and whether any Nevada Republicans or gaming industry representatives had approached him about those issues.

    "The issue of college betting is not going anywhere. ... The sports betting thing, that was over years ago," he added. "I've faced reality. It's just like with immigration reform. Americans want a secure border."

    On Internet gaming, McCain was just off his game. First he tried to back away from his position because he hasn't been involved in it lately. Then he said it was really fellow Arizona Sen. Jon Kyl's deal.

    Then he tried to find a Nevada-friendly stance. "The economy is what's hurting the gaming industry in Las Vegas today," McCain said. "It isn't sports betting or Internet gaming."

    Yes, but if the gaming industry could make money online, it could help the bottom line when tourists balk at spending thousands to fly here or hundreds to drive here.

    "Let me get back to you on it," he said. "I haven't thought about the issue."

    He did say he had concerns about Internet gaming originating in foreign countries. Of course, this happens because of U.S. policy and restrictions, but never mind.

    McCain also spoke about oversight and making sure the kiddies don't have access.

    "I'll call you back," he added.

    Could the position be evolving like so many of his others? We'll have to wait and see just how much Nevada is in play, as the election grows nearer.

    We know McCain will be back. Maybe he'll have an Internet gaming proposal by then. For the sake of the gaming industry, we'd better hope it's not as deeply thought out as his energy plan.

    Then again, maybe the gamers wouldn't mind if offshore meant the Caspian Sea.

    As for him calling back, I'll be waiting.

    Contact Erin Neff at (702) 387-2906, or by e-mail at eneff@reviewjournal.com.



    Leave Your Comment 20 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    douglas wrote on July 03, 2008 07:18 PM: with an immediate expansion of nuclear and coal energy production, there *may* be downward pressure on demand for imported crude and natural gas. since the "progressives" have fought against development and harvesting of u.s. resources for years, american consumers are saddled with continuing, skyrocketing energy costs.

    meanwhile, the empty suit suggests pass through taxes on the roughnecks, the corner gas stations, and all others who transport, refine, or distribute petroleum products. that's beneath stupid. and of course, under the empty suit plan, consumers have to teach their bambinos how to shiver.

    coolest will be when the chinese and cuban consortium drill into crude oil bearing strata within 80 miles of the u.s. land. if they are studious, they should be able to find a continuous crude bearing strata that extends close to or even beneath, the u.s. landmass. it'd be like sticking a straw into the oil pool and sucking it dry. and i wager that the cubans won't count before and after, the sea slugs, minnows, and endangered crabs.

    thank you "progressives".


    Steve wrote on July 03, 2008 05:18 PM: The problem with McCain is that he is a RINO. He doesn't even have enough courage to admit that he's a liberal Democrat.


    hss wrote on July 03, 2008 03:29 PM: The problem with McCain isn't what he says now, the problem is the comparison with what he says today vs what he said last year and the year before, etc. He's flip flopped on so many issues, he makes Kerry look decisive. The McCain who ran against Bush in 2000 would have been okay but not the McCain pandering to the Bush crowd. And what happens if he gets elected and appoints another Scalia, we'll have no civil right in no time.

    While there is some merit to Erin's conerns about McCain's inability to understand some issues that are important to Nevada, there are bigger problems nationally than Nuclear power. If the energy companies get their way, fuel costs will go up and up and up (even if we drill in Alaska).


    MJ wrote on July 03, 2008 02:09 PM: Stop asking McCain specific questions, it only confuses him. He will fix the economic condition of the country, his plan is for his wife to write a check for the national debt. He will solve the environmental problems by planting corn in the antartic. He can solve the war problem, by declaring we won and then post troops there for the next 50 years, just like in Korea. Unfortunately the solutions of McCain are better than the solutions of OBama, he just wants to meet with everybody and have everyone walk away holdiong hands and singing.


    0u812 wrote on July 03, 2008 01:20 PM: All elected demon crats are LIARS, BACKSTABBING Thieves. Not one dem has done a thing for the USA but put MONEY into their pockects and of shore accounts. Kennedy is the most ruthless LIAR and Backstabber with 500 million in offshore accounts to protect from taxes. All dems need to be spit upon because they are helping terroist succeed.


    Steve wrote on July 03, 2008 11:19 AM: Rob L,

    "When you have a chronically uneducated populace, that is what happens. They are completely unable to form a opinion that wasnt fed to them by either CNN or Fox."

    Therein lies the problem. That's the reason why we have politicians in office for 20, 30, 40 years even though they lie with every breath and do things that are destroying this country (and I mean both "major" parties). Just look at Ted Kennedy... murdered a girl, got an extremely minor slap on the wrist, and has never had to worry about not being returned to the Senate. Absolutely amazing.


    Steve wrote on July 03, 2008 11:18 AM: Rob L,

    "When you have a chronically uneducated populace, that is what happens. They are completely unable to form a opinion that wasnt fed to them by either CNN or Fox."

    Therein lies the problem. That's the reason why we have politicians in office for 20, 30, 40 years even though they lie with every breath and do things that are destroying this country (and I mean both "major" parties). Just look at Ted Kennedy... murdered a girl, got an extremely minor slap on the wrist, and has never had to worry about not being returned to the Senate. Absolutely amazing.


    Rob L. wrote on July 03, 2008 10:55 AM: "You are the only writer there with a clear, open mind."

    Shouldnt you just restate that as...
    " You are the only writer there with a clear, open mind that I agree with!"

    As a matter of job description, its impossible for an editoral writer to have an "open mind." Do you really believe there was any chance she would have walked out of that interview saying "Wow, he has some really good ideas?" That about as likely as her ever questioning Obama's economic plans!


    Rob L wrote on July 03, 2008 10:52 AM: Hey McD,

    I never defended any Republicans, I just refuted the idea that only Repubs are corrupt. If you ever read any of my posts, I am of the firm belif that there is very little difference between the 2 and both are corrupt and immoral.

    I just hate partisans whose political beliefs prevent them from seeing their own hypocrisy. I just chuckle when people like Ms. Neff and "Judy" attack the right while the people they support do the very same things. When you have a chronically uneducated populace, that is what happens. They are completely unable to form a opinion that wasnt fed to them by either CNN or Fox.


    Brian wrote on July 03, 2008 10:17 AM: Erin,

    You are a breath of fresh air. Thanks to the RJ for hiring you and keeping you. You are the only writer there with a clear, open mind.


    Read All Comments