Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun

Opinion


EDITORIAL: No deaths, this time

But procedures that make it hard to identify police at the door should be reviewed

Las Vegas police officers served a search warrant at the Seven Hills home of Emmanuel Dozier on Panorama Ridge Drive in Henderson at about 9:30 last Sunday evening.

The officers say they announced themselves, got no response, and opened fire to break the lock off the metal front door.


Most Popular Stories
  • THOMAS MITCHELL: Sacrificing free speech won't appease fanatics
  • EDITORIAL: Stood her ground
  • Smart meters not all they're cracked up to be
  • EDITORIAL: Numbers stink?
  • VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Some things are worth fighting for
  • EDITORIAL: Going to extremes
  • LETTERS: Nursery did the right thing with laborers
  • LETTERS: Teachers not most important learning variable
  • SHERMAN FREDERICK: Here's a scary thought
  • LETTERS: Agassi remains a good citizen




  • At that point, the suspect, a 32-year-old sheet-metal worker, also opened fire. Three police officers were wounded.

    Mr. Dozier, who was suspected of cocaine trafficking and is now held in lieu of $3 million bail, says he thought it was a home invasion.

    "I want you to know something in your heart. I did not mean to shoot any cops," police report that he told them.

    An attorney for his girlfriend, Belinda Saavedra, says her client dialed 9-1-1 from the home during the police raid, believing it to be a (non-police) home invasion.

    No cocaine was found in the home, and it initially appeared the charges filed against Mr. Dozier -- attempted murder and possession of a controlled substance, to wit marijuana -- did not include the alleged cocaine trafficking that supposedly prompted the raid.

    So the raid itself instigated a crime more serious than that cited on the arrest warrant.

    Ms. Saavedra's children -- including an older child not at home at the time -- were taken away by authorities. Because she was not named on the warrant and was not arrested, and since there seems to have been no prima facie evidence she was incapable of caring for her kids, that would seem to resemble a punishment for innocent family members -- just as her attorney alleges.

    "If anyone put these kids in danger, it was the police," contends Ms. Saavedra's lawyer, Vicki Greco.

    The first piece of good news here -- though anyone who thinks it's a laughing matter to receive "just a flesh wound" by gunshot is welcome to step forward and volunteer -- is that none of the three police officers involved suffered a life-threatening injury, though one did require surgery.

    The second piece of good news is that the suspect surrendered -- he did so as soon as he realized the men at the door were police, if he is to be believed -- and was taken into custody without being shot.

    Some neighbors allege he was treated roughly during arrest; his arraignment photos show a man with a bruised and swollen eye. Indeed, assertions that a surrendering suspect "resisted arrest" seem odd.

    But others may hold out for some arrest protocol out of a children's tea party, if they like. Considering the kind of emotions that flow when one is under gunfire -- especially when three officers have been hit -- it would be more appropriate to honor the courage and restraint it took for officers to hold their fire and take a suspect into custody, substantially uninjured.

    Some measured, pre-emptive force during arrest of a known felon who has been firing on police is not necessarily out of line.

    But none of this should prevent a review of the "standard" procedures which appear to have contributed to the violence, here.

    Does a raid timed for 9:30 Sunday evening -- more than four hours after nightfall, at this time of year -- make it more likely residents will understand the men at the door are police? Police say the raid was staged by SWAT officers: Does that mean they did not display standard, easily recognizable uniforms and chest badges? Were they, in fact, dressed in black to make them less visible?

    Pardon us if we doubt the officers waited even two or three minutes for residents to pull on clothes (if necessary), come to the door, ascertain who was there and ask to read the officers' warrant.

    For that matter, wouldn't the chance of violence have been reduced -- in a home where police should have known young children were present -- if someone had simply telephoned the home, explaining police were approaching the door with a warrant ... preferably during daylight hours?

    Some will say such a procedure would be naive -- drug dealers could use the time to flush their product down the toilet.

    But no cocaine was found -- and a dealer who can eliminate all his product in one toilet flush isn't really very big-time, is he?

    If Mr. Dozier is prosecuted on drug-trafficking charges it will be based on the testimony of the undercover officers who say they bought from him in the past.

    The drug war has taught us to accept as "normal" police procedures -- even in the case of a man alleged to have dealt quantities of drugs worth only a few hundred dollars -- which increase the risk of violence and death in our neighborhoods.

    Just as in cases where some jurisdictions have found overall fatalities could be reduced by having ambulances obey stoplights, it is those "standard" procedures that are in need of a serious new review.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 28 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    Report abuse

    Scott wrote on January 12, 2009 11:49 PM: Any girlfriend of Herb should have her tubes tied right away. Upon doing that, she should automatically receive the Nobel Peace Prize. We don't need that moronic type of intelligence level in this country. It is bad enough that we have one Herb in this country.


    Report abuse

    Scott wrote on January 12, 2009 07:49 PM: Fact #1: Never get your facts from Thomas A. Carpenter. He does not even know how to define the word "fact."
    Fact #2 See Fact number one because Tomas A. Carpenter will tell any lie to argue his nonsense. For example: "SWAT does not serve low-risk warrants." Thomas, a swat team recently broke into the home of a mayor in the early evening! That's not a low risk warrant? Give yourself a break.
    Fact #3: Solid article by Review Journal. Thank you.


    Report abuse

    Jon wrote on January 05, 2009 04:15 PM: Thomas A. Carpenter,
    You big fat idiotic dumb stupid scum,

    Of course the SWAT serve low risk warrants. They do it all the time you dumb fat POS.

    They do it for practice.

    And who cares WHO serves the warrant: why is Metro so interested in a low level punk selling a few crack rocks?

    why not go after the suppliers, not some idiot like you who sells enough to supply his own habit.

    Metro is one of the most corrupt departments in the USA. Second and third are occupied by Henderson and NLV.


    Report abuse

    Little Birdie wrote on January 05, 2009 03:03 PM: The war on drugs is idiotic and always has been. Perhaps if more cops are shot in such circumstances, they will lose interest in drugs and go back to doing their job of protecting the public.


    Report abuse

    Thomas A. Carpenter wrote on January 04, 2009 10:12 PM: Rule #1- Never get your facts from the Review Journal.
    Rule #2- Never get your facts from the T.V. news.
    Rule #3- Never violate rules 1 and 2.

    Scumbag #1 is being held on 3 million dollars bail for a good reason. SWAT does not serve low-risk warrants. And if you have a reenforced steel door on the front of your house in Seven Hills..your probably in fear of the Police and your fellow crooks for good reason, because one or the other is going to take you out of the game.


    Report abuse

    patrick wrote on January 04, 2009 06:08 PM: Not a single life should be lost, nor a single dollar of the taxpayers money be spent, imposing government violence on innocent people EVEN IF, they are selling drugs.

    The drug war is the BIGGEST single waste of government spending in this country's history, barring only possibly bush's Iraq war.

    Hmm, war on terror war on drugs, what have they accomplished;

    Millions of people dead, trillions of dollars spent, FOR NOTHING.

    I am glad the officers lived and that the innocent man was not killed.


    Report abuse

    chill wrote on January 04, 2009 05:45 PM: It saddens me to read some of the mean and uncaring things that are written in these posts. I realize that much of this is written to get a response, but it doesn't excuse the fact that the people that are written about are real and as a society why do some feel the need to constantly tear down.
    Agree or disagree, but is it too much to ask that we remain decent in our comments.


    Report abuse

    Herb wrote on January 04, 2009 04:59 PM: I wish they would have taken away the children of the girlfriend away. Women are attracted to drug dealers. This is becoming such a serious problem that even a Mexican beauty queen was recently caught with a drug lord. hopefully her crown will be taken away.

    One of the motivations drug dealers have is that beautiful women are attracted to them. We need to do something to make women fear having a relationship with a drug seller. One of the few things that would work is the government taking away the woman's children. Mothers love their children and wouldn't want to lose them. They will then avoid drug sellers. If not they will cry and cry as their children are taken away. The woman deserves to cry and be depressed for the rest of her life because she is the wind beneath the wings of evil drug dealers. For women who don't have children yet, the punishment for being caught with a drug seller should be forcing her to get her tubes tied.


    Report abuse

    Virga wrote on January 04, 2009 03:46 PM: Dozier 3 metro 0.

    We are not unarmed German Jews.


    Report abuse

    SamT wrote on January 04, 2009 03:05 PM: One issue, yet to be addressed: Why, despite having a live 911 operator on the line (twice), this situation escalated to a shooting?

    Metro--again--fails to pass the smell test.






    Read All Comments