VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Helping students become 'responsible citizens'? - Opinion

PRINT THIS Popular

Jul. 15, 2007
Copyright © Las Vegas Review-Journal

VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Helping students become 'responsible citizens'?

VIN SUPRYNOWICZ
MORE COLUMNS

John Taylor Gatto, honored on several occasions as New York City and New York state teacher of the year, has made it the second part of his life's work to determine why our government schools are so ineffective -- why he always had to fight the bureaucracy above him in order to empower his young charges (many of them minority kids, given to him as "punishment" because the administrators thought them "hopeless") to spread their wings and learn.

What Gatto discovered is enough to cause a massive paradigm shift for anyone who reads his books, whether you start with the slim "Dumbing Us Down" or his weightier master work, "The Underground History of American Education."

Most Popular Stories

EDITORIAL: A pre-9/11 approach to terror

LETTERS: Public-sector workers are still doing well

LETTERS: Harry Reid: Working hard for all Americans

EDITORIAL: 'That's the ticket!'

VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Barefooted, gun-toting hayseeds?

LETTERS: A giant octopus threatens rural Nevada

LETTERS: America should try terrorists in open court

EDITORIAL: Religious freedom

LETTERS: Senator just trying to kiss up to Harry Reid

GEOFF SCHUMACHER: UNLV needs new stadium

America's schools aren't failing, Gatto discovered. They're doing precisely what they were re-designed to do between the 1850s and the early 1900s, when America embarked on our current imperial/mercantilist adventure -- that is, to churn out little soldiers and factory workers with mindless obedience drilled in and with the higher critical faculties burned out of them through the process of feeding them learning in small unrelated bits like pre-digested gruel, till they neither know how nor feel any inclination to discern higher patterns, which might lead them to challenge the "party line."

Who dreamed up such a system?

John Dewey and Horace Mann brought this form of "compulsion schooling" home from Prussia, Gatto learned.

(I've actually had readers write to ask me why I don't blame these men for borrowing the French school system, instead of the German. I could do that. I could also report that, in 1492, Columbus boldly crossed the Mediterranean and discovered Africa.)

Thus, if we want to see what our "reverse-engineered" copy of the German school system has in mind for us, it might pay to simply take a look at what's happening with government-run schooling ... in Germany.

You won't find much reporting on the case of 16-year-old Melissa Busekros in our "Mainstream Media." Instead, you'll have to visit Web sites such as WorldNetDaily, or that of the Home School Legal Defense Association.

What you'll find is the tale of a bright and spunky 15-year-old girl who'd fallen behind in math and Latin, and was thus being tutored at home.

Problem is, home-schooling was outlawed in Germany by some guy who was in charge there in the 1930s, Herr Hitler insisting it was vital to his plans for the state to "inoculate our youth with the spirit of this community of the people at a very early age."

When German officials -- in 2007, not 1937 -- discovered young Melissa was being tutored outside of state control, she was expelled from her school in Erlangen, Bavaria.

Then, in February, Melissa was seized from her family home by 15 police officers in a dramatic raid. She was sent to a psychiatric hospital for two weeks of evaluation to determine whether, after two-and-a-half years of home tutoring, she was suffering from a form of mental illness which the Germans called "school phobia." At that point she was moved to a foster home, the location of which was kept secret from her parents and siblings, though she was allowed one weekly visit with her parents.

Apparently confusing the Busekros family with Islamic terrorists training their kids to don suicide belts, Wolfgang Drautz, consul general of the Federal Republic of Germany, said that the government "has a legitimate interest in countering the rise of parallel societies that are based on religion or motivated by different world views and in integrating minorities into the population as a whole. ...

"Homeschool may be equally effective in terms of test scores," Drautz wrote. "It is important to keep in mind, however, that school teaches not only knowledge but also social conduct, encourages dialogue among people of different beliefs and cultures, and helps students to become responsible citizens."

Of the Reich.

We hear this argument in America, too. So what if our state-run schools fail in the academic arena -- having virtually given up any attempt to teach even a single foreign language, to teach Latin or Greek, to teach physics or European history, to teach spelling or grammar or syntax or mathematics above the level of algebra? So what? It's all made up by the great job they're doing in "socialization"! Which is why they have to ban the wearing of colored hats or kerchiefs, lest homicidal gang warfare break out before lunchtime.

Joel Thornton, president of the International Human Rights Group, told WorldNetDaily the problem is that Melissa's original psychiatric evaluation was so vague it could be used to justify treatment for anyone.

"There is an increased fear among homeschoolers about whether their children are next."

The good news? At midnight on April 23, the minute Melissa gained considerable more legal rights by turning 16, she left a note for her foster parents and headed out the door, surprising her family by arriving home at 3 a.m. And there the courts have so far ruled she may remain, since they find her to be (for some reason) no longer "in danger."

A follow-up state psychology evaluation conducted in May found Melissa Busekros a "stable person" who does not suffer from "school phobia."

Mr. Thornton of the IHRG says Melissa now wants to finish her education by an accredited correspondence school, which is permitted by law at 16.

German homeschoolers -- some of whom have fled the country -- have taken their battle for the right to teach their children at home to the Human Rights Court for the European Union, asking for affirmation of the statement in the European Convention on Human Rights that: "In the exercise of any functions which it assumes in relation to education and to teaching, the State shall respect the right of parents to ensure such education and teaching is in conformity with their own religious and philosophical convictions."

But that court last year upheld a German court which ruled the parental "wish" to have their children grow up free of statist propaganda "could not take priority over compulsory school attendance."

After all, the international court ruled, government schools represent society and it's "in the children's interest to become part of that society."

There are an estimated 2 million homeschooled children in America -- almost 4 percent of our school-age population. Homeschooling is growing between 7 and 15 percent per year. But you probably knew that. After all, you're part of a shrinking minority in America. You can read something more complicated than the TV guide. Something a lot of us learned to do ... at home.

Vin Suprynowicz is assistant editorial page editor of the Review-Journal and author of the novel "The Black Arrow." See www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?vci=51238921.

Share & Save

Leave Your Comment	14 Reader Comments
Terms & Conditions The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor. Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Please enter your name Name: Please enter your email Email: Please enter a comment COMMENTS : (word count limit is 300) You have reached the maximum number of words allowed Current Word Count: Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background. MIke wrote on August 22, 2007 07:16 PM: Hey Anon, did you ever learn to balance a checkbook, plan a family budget, comparison shop with coupons, grow your own food, and learn to cook in government schools? I sure didn't. I learned them from the first teachers I ever had--my parents. My own mother got banned from a grocery store because they were stupid enough to do a BOGO sale with triple coupons. We left with $250 of groceries and $10 cash back in two carts, and went home and tag-teamed cooking dinner. Now that's an education. Most people today have no clue about that stuff, and it shows! Melinda Secor wrote on July 22, 2007 12:58 PM: My children are homeschooled, and I am no radical fundamentalist. The simple fact is that the school system is not teaching real thought. Joining the PTA is useless in a system that is so flawed that it cannot be fixed. No wonder the previous comment was signed anon...I would surely refuse to attach my name to such an ignorant statement as well. Studies show that homeschooled children score better in academics, fare better in life, and are now being courted by the Ivy League colleges due to their superior education and skills. The public schools are turning out graduates who need remedial help to function in basic community college courses. Homeschooled children are America's ONLY hope of competing in the world marketplace. Check your facts Mr. Anon!! Anon wrote on July 19, 2007 08:58 PM: Look we all know that the homeschooling in America is being driven by the radical fundamentalist Christians who want to teach that the earth is 4,000 years old, that dinosaurs were wiped out by Noah's flood (or the bones put there to "test the faithful"), that without the public schools Americans would be unable to compete in any industry that requires fact-based reasoning instead of looking it up in one version of the Bible or another. If you want to make things better, then join the PTA. Bob_Robertson wrote on July 19, 2007 08:49 PM: Ah, the "socialization" myth. What disgusts me is how pervasive that myth is. Even when every academic point is conseeded to being educated at home, the impression is that without being bullied, taunted, teased, bored and drugged, somehow kids won't know how to make friends. Dave D wrote on July 16, 2007 08:58 PM: A friend said that he sends his kids to government schools because of the social setting. But the social setting at school is nothing like the social experience of real life. In real life, we socialize after work. We may have friends at work, but the majority of our time is spent working on projects. It is possible for children to go to a private school and then socialize with friends after school. For this reason, home schooling makes more sense than government schooling because it is more like real life: one studies at home and then socializes with friends; the two are not connected. Then when a child leaves the home, the child will work during the day and socialize after work. Mutineer wrote on July 16, 2007 01:13 PM: Welcome to school "socialization" 101! My friend, his 14 y/o son got hooked on meth in his "socialization". My daughter, is taunted for doing well in her studies and is urged to drop out and be "cool" like the rest as part of her "socialization". My son is harassed by preteen gang members to join as part of his "socialization". I'm wanting "socialization" too...I'm planning to quit work and go on welfare living with the rest of the trailer trash watching Oprah everyday on television. Bill Smith wrote on July 16, 2007 12:53 PM: It is so refreshing to have a man like Vin write the truth. I’m still surprised the LVRJ lets Vin continue to write the truth in a major newspaper. Keep up the good work!! Ken wrote on July 16, 2007 12:46 PM: Have any of our schools changed the format by which they teach kids nowdays? My point being, kids these days need to be entertained alot more than my generation did. Their minds go a million miles an hour. I dont watch network news anymore due to the fact that they bore the living bejesus out of me. Both FOX and CNN have great formats where the producers went out and hired a great looking man and women to tell you the news while having a great sense of humor. They added entertainment to it. There by almost putting the network news out of buisness. If my son had my first period history teacher, he'd be asleep in two minutes. I made it through my classes thinking of all the things I would do after school - Ride my bike, and then watch 2 hours of TV, one of the three channels available. Our kids on the other hand have far more things to think about. Ipods, cell phones, Game cubes, My space, Computers, 700 TV channels, etc. An unlimited amount of entertainment. So now we have an enourmous amount of children diagnosed with ADD and fed ridlin in order to make them sit still long enough to take a test. Maybe its not the kids, maybe its how they are being taught. Ps144 wrote on July 16, 2007 09:51 AM: Just wondering, is watching the TV Guide CHANNEL the same as reading a TV Guide? I have read Gatto's book, and it pushed me over the edge. Now my kids are Home Schoolers too. Thanks, Vin! Triple Eight wrote on July 15, 2007 02:35 PM: bingo, Vin! thanks for saying it. Read All Comments