Quantcast
Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri

Opinion


GEOFF SCHUMACHER: We need to boost recycling, but not at expense of trash pickup

The "daily miracle" is an old industry phrase describing the newspaper tossed on your driveway every morning.

It's a daily miracle because, despite daunting time constraints, despite all the moving parts that must fall into place, despite the pitfalls that frequently bedevil the process, the newspaper manages to get made and delivered every day.


Most Popular Stories
  • LETTERS: With economists like these, who needs enemies?
  • LETTERS: Brace yourself for coming tax hikes
  • LETTERS: Nuclear power could be the answer for Nevada
  • EDITORIAL: Firemen's pensions past due for reform
  • EDITORIAL: Education 'consultants'
  • EDITORIAL: Internet sales taxes
  • FROM OUR READERS: In the dark about the new light bulbs
  • LETTERS: So now you're in favor of regulation, eh?
  • VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Letting the looters vote on who's for lunch
  • EDITORIAL: Water, water everywhere




  • And it gets printed and delivered seven days a week, 365 days per year, for years and years and years.

    And on top of all that, most of the words are spelled right and most of the pictures are in focus.

    Trust me, it's something very much like a miracle.

    The daily newspaper is one of those things that most people take for granted.

    There are other aspects of urban life that we take for granted, as well. For example, when we turn on the faucet, water comes out. Almost always, 99.99 percent of the time. And what's more, it may not taste very good in Las Vegas, but we're reasonably confident that we can drink it without falling ill.

    Also, when we flush the toilet or drain the sink, 99.99 percent of the time whatever is supposed to go away -- to leave our homes forever -- actually goes away.

    In my experience, this phenomenon is also true of trash pickup. I put the trash out on the sidewalk in the morning, and my garbage can is empty when I come home from work.

    And it doesn't matter what kind of material I drag out to the curb. Short of nuclear waste, the garbage men will take it away.

    We pay for all this, of course. Reasonable people can disagree on whether we are paying too little or too much for these services, but I would suggest that we are getting a pretty good deal on most of them.

    Perhaps the best deal of the bunch is trash collection. Republic Services picks up our garbage twice a week -- something of a luxury compared with many other cities. And then the company comes around every other week to gather our recyclables. In my 20 years in Las Vegas, they've always come on the scheduled day, and they've always carted away my garbage.

    Republic's bill for this service? About $12 per month.

    Not exactly a fortune by anyone's measure.

    But tinkerers lurk. Republic Services and the Clark County Commission recently agreed to experiment with this formula of twice-a-week garbage pickup and biweekly recycling collection. The goal of the pilot project is to figure out a method to encourage more people to recycle.

    Las Vegans are dismal recyclers, among the nation's worst. A ridiculously low number of us -- somewhere between 2 percent and 5 percent -- actually participates in the recycling program that we all pay for.

    One of Republic's proposed alternatives to the current system is highly controversial: It would cut back garbage pickup to once a week while collecting recyclables on a weekly basis.

    The first part of this plan has generated a firestorm of opposition. It's abundantly clear that Las Vegans really like twice-a-week garbage pickup.

    We have good reasons for this. First and foremost, the six or seven months of very hot weather in Las Vegas create a big problem. Leave your garbage out in the garage for six days and it starts to smell.

    This is not a small issue. Week-old trash left in the heat can be truly nauseating.

    Republic seems to favor this idea in part because it would be cheaper for the company to pick up trash once a week instead of twice. Even if recycling pickup increased to weekly, the company would come out ahead.

    Considering that homeowners pay a modest $12 per month for the current level of service, I'm not surprised that Republic is looking for ways to reduce its costs.

    If Republic is genuinely having trouble making a reasonable profit under its current contracts -- it's no secret that the cost of doing business is rising -- let's audit the numbers and see if an unscheduled fee increase is justified. Republic has the trash collection franchise in the valley, which means it has long-term contracts with local governments under which rates, services, etc., are regulated. If Republic opens its books and can convince local officials that the rates are too low to cover legitimate costs, then contract revisions might be in order. Or not.

    Bottom line: I'd rather pay a little more to maintain twice-a-week trash pickup than see my service reduced. Just as we won't stand for a degradation in our water service, sewer service or daily newspaper delivery, we can't see the logic in reducing trash-collection service.

    At the same time, we must be prepared to pay a fair price for this excellent service.

    Meanwhile, the jury is very much out on whether switching to weekly recycling pickup would result in higher participation. Cynicism about the local recycling program runs deep. If Republic Services and local governments want more residents to recycle, merely increasing the frequency of pickup isn't going to do the trick.

    Education and confidence would seem to be far more important components of a successful recycling program.

    Geoff Schumacher (gschumacher@reviewjournal.com) is Stephens Media's director of community publications. He is the author of "Sun, Sin & Suburbia: An Essential History of Modern Las Vegas" and, coming in February, "Howard Hughes: Power, Paranoia & Palace Intrigue." His column appears Sunday.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 6 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    kevin wrote on September 02, 2007 10:11 PM: To Bob and Sharon- do you realize that all this plastic, steal, glass, etc. will stay in the landfill for hundreds of years, and eventually we will run out of steal and plastics? It's not all about feeling pissed off about how we have to sort our trash for Republic. It's about how everyone needs to recycle more and try to save the enviroment and ourselves and kids' future.


    Whiskey Tango Foxtrot wrote on September 02, 2007 01:28 PM: Republic could offer to pick up recyclables every day of the week and that's NOT going to increase the amount Las Vegas recycles. If Republic wants to change the terms of its monopolistic contract, then let the current contract be dissolved and new negotiations started...with other interested companies adding THEIR proposals. No more "sweetheart" deals for Republic. If they're unhappy with the terms of their current contract, cancel it and let someone else bid on it.


    J wrote on September 02, 2007 01:06 PM: Everyone sees "good ol' boys" conspiracies everywhere. That gets tired real fast.

    This Las Vegas resident of 41 years (oh, wait ... maybe I'M a "good ol' boy"!) isn't interested in twice-weekly trash pickup. I recycle everything I can -- it doesn't take any extra effort -- and my single 35 gallon garbage can (with lid) never overflows with trash. Further, it stands OUTSIDE, right by my side entrance, and somehow I'm not overcome with stench. Amazing.


    Sharon wrote on September 02, 2007 10:19 AM: Republic Services has made a fortune with their monopoly. For those of you that lived here a few years ago, you know we already purchased the new fleet Republic bought when they got into recycling. We by the trucks they make the money. Republic got a sweetheart deal (contract) with the good ol boys downtown to pick up the trash Not to mention they get paid for trash they don't even pick up at every vacant house in town. The only business that gets paid when no service is provided. Thank the good ol boys downtown. Republic makes good money recycling. Do I do get a rebate for my time being a curb side sorter for them ? NO Under the current structure I will NEVER sort my trash for Republic Services. They make the money they can sort it. For health purposes the trash needs to be picked up twice a week. This is not a third world country yet.


    Bob wrote on September 02, 2007 07:52 AM: Recycling is a feel good concept that does not yeild any significant benefit. There are many exceptions to that statement, but they apply to specialized industries. The recycling of this article is correctly identified as an effort to increase the profit margin for Republic. Our contract with them was another MacDonald Folly. They have apparently found new officials to pay off.


    Thomas wrote on September 02, 2007 07:02 AM: Why don't any of the proposed plans to increase recycling include incentives for the homeowners? If it's so valuable & necessary, pay them for it. That will increase participation. If it's worthless or actually costs more to recycle than landfill, drop the whole issue. A number of major cities don't have any recycle pick-up. The world hasn't ended over it.

    Keeping twice a week trash pick-up is necessary around here.