Comments (5) | Add a comment
EDITORIAL
Court skeptical of BLM's roundup secrecy
Tools
A Minden photographer and wild horse advocate who has been blocked from watching roundups in Nevada scored a First Amendment victory in the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday.
A three-judge panel in San Francisco overturned a lower court ruling and sent the case back to a federal judge in Reno to determine whether the Bureau of Land Management's restrictions on media access to roundups are constitutional -- while strongly indicating they're not.
"When the government announces it is excluding the press for reasons such as administrative convenience, preservation of evidence, or protection of reporters' safety, its real motive may be to prevent the gathering of information about government abuses or incompetence," wrote Judge Milan Smith Jr.
Laura Leigh, a photojournalist and writer for Horseback magazine, filed a lawsuit in the summer of 2010 seeking to halt the roundup of about 500 wild horses in Lincoln County, near the Utah state line. She said the BLM's closure of 27,000 acres of public lands, where the Silver King roundup was taking place, amounted to a violation of the First Amendment and prevented her from observing in a watchdog role.
BLM lawyers argued Ms. Leigh had been granted no less access than anyone else and that the restrictions were necessary for the safety of the horses and the observers.
"A court cannot rubber-stamp an access restriction simply because the government says it is necessary," Judge Smith wrote. "When wrongdoing is under way, officials have great incentive to blindfold the watchful eyes of the Fourth Estate. ... The relevant question is not whether the BLM prohibited Leigh from observing the horse gather altogether. The issue here is whether the viewing restrictions were unconstitutional. On that question, the district court failed to conduct the proper First Amendment analysis."
The 9th Circuit has sometimes been known to forget that all 10 planks of the Bill of Rights outweigh the convenience of government agents -- that citizens with nearly unlimited rights are the agents who delegate to the bureaucrats their limited powers, not the other way around.
A few minimal safety rules to keep bystanders out from under horses' hooves might make sense. But closing off 27,000 acres at a time? That sounds like an agency with something to hide.
The court got this one right.
Comments
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Review-Journal does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please use the Report Abuse button.
Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 24 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
OF COURSE the BLM has something to hide; It's an agency entrusted to PROTECT these creatures, and instead it uses our tax dollars to torment, maim, torture, and ultimately SLAUGHTER the very sub-species it's contracted to preserve. These "gathers" are carried out by barbaric, low-flying, helicopter-piloting yahoos with whips and cattle prods (and some shady connections to slaughterhouses no longer necessarily in Mexico).
mrs ed, a little delusinal today? Heh? Where were you when hollweird made movies about killing George Bush? And you people have the gall to talk about the civil discourse in politics today. Like you never said anything stupid. Get a life ed.
Sounds like the Secret Sevice needs to check to see who Scary Harry is??
mrs ed....if people used the hide and meat from Obama, the way they do gators, would we have more incompetent politicians?
The Mina lobster round-up was done in broad daylight. Loo at all the gators they have in the South. If people used the hides and meat from horses, the way they do gators, there would be more horses.