Comments (19) | Add a comment
EDITORIAL
Facing the music
Tools
The saga of the offended high school music teacher continues up in Northern Nevada.
Kathy Archey, a teacher at Churchill County High School in the small town of Fallon, about 50 miles east of Reno, has now sued virtually everybody in sight over an article she didn't like that was published in the school's student newspaper.
At first, Ms. Archey tried to sic her teachers union on the school paper to try to block publication of an article that claimed she had withheld student audition tapes for a state musical competition.
The union's effort failed, however, as the school principal sided with the First Amendment and allowed the story to be printed.
Now, Ms. Archey has lawyered up and has sued the school district superintendent, the principal, the school journalism adviser and even the editor of the local paper, who apparently helped vet the student's article.
Ms. Archey wants at least $10,000 in damages. She claims the story defamed her and effectively scuttled plans she had with her husband to open a local restaurant.
"Based on the conduct of these individuals, Kathleen's reputation as a teacher has been damaged," the suit says. "She has suffered ridicule and has been rebuked by people who have been influenced by these defamatory and malicious allegations concerning her integrity as a teacher."
Interestingly, Ms. Archey didn't name the student journalist, Lauren Mac Lean.
Ms. Archey, an eight-year veteran at the school, denies the charges in the story, claiming she submitted all the voice tapes of the students who qualified. But one could still make the argument that Ms. Archey's reputation has been harmed more by her effort to kill the story and then extract revenge from those involved rather than by the content of the article itself.
At least one of the defendants was unrepentant.
"I think that we followed everything we needed to and there was no defamation of character on our behalf," said school principal Kevin Lords. "We took all precautions to make sure her rights were not violated. ... "
Let's hope a judge agrees.
Comments
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Review-Journal does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please use the Report Abuse button.
Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 24 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
This is the type of frivolous tort that needs to be addressed. A laywer will file a very small cliam, in this case $10K - small in the litigation scheme of things, and it will invariably be settled as filed since will cost more to fight than what it costs to pay. The scheister gets his percentage, and the plaintiff gets the rest.
Money for nuthin! No amount of money can put the ketchup back in the bottle.
Incredible.
"Based on the conduct of these individuals, Kathleen's reputation as a teacher has been damaged," the suit says. "She has suffered ridicule and has been rebuked by people who have been influenced by these defamatory and malicious allegations concerning her integrity as a teacher."
In a small community such as Fallon they're going to have some difficulty coming up with people who'll testify that her opportunity to open a restaurant was damaged by this incident. Come on folks. A restaurant? I mean what if the food just sucks and they can't make it. Show me the plans and money you spent for it. A government employee (other than a firefighter owning a construction company) actually owning a private business. What a crock.