Comments (42) | Add a comment
Sherman Frederick
Let's get back to capitalism
May America find renewed faith in capitalism in 2011.
Here's hoping we shake off the big-spending Congress of last year and replace it with one willing to start us on a path of fiscal responsibility. Out with the old members who sat in judgment of a perverted capitalist economy in which politicians, not the marketplace, picked winners and losers, and in with a return to sanity in the housing and mortgage sectors, the auto industry, the financial industry and, if it's not too late, the health care industry.
In other words, let's get back to the economic system that made us the greatest nation on Earth: unfiltered, poverty-erasing, job-creating capitalism.
To get those righteous juices flowing, may I recommend two books for your mind and your soul: "After the Meltdown," by Marc De Vos, director of the Itinera Institute, a Brussels think tank; and "Money, Greed, and God" by Princeton theologian Jay W. Richards.
Both books provide an excellent starting point for a national discussion on why, as Richards' subtitles his book, "capitalism is the solution and not the problem."
Both authors explode many of the myths articulated by liberal intellectuals who have lost faith in capitalism. Here are two worthy of immediate debunking:
First, the concept of "state capitalism." When the free market doesn't respond, government can prime the market. Truth is, as argued by De Vos, government-led development never substitutes for market-led development.
When a nation's government becomes the principal agent of the economy, the pool of innovative players shrinks and, in the long run, the economy devolves into political cronyism. No better up-to-the-minute case than America's green energy economy.
Consider the company A-Power Energy Generation Systems. This is a Chinese supplier of wind turbines, partnered with a Dallas investment firm with strong ties to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and other Democratic Party insiders.
A-Power seeks to "compete" for $450 million in taxpayer stimulus money to construct a wind farm in Texas. The assembly plant, oddly enough, would be located in Henderson -- Reid's home state.
A-Power's decision helped Reid in a tough re-election campaign. Aside from Reid receiving donations from the wind farm's backers, posing for pictures and being able to tell voters his "power" brings jobs to Nevada, A-Power's partner in Henderson, American Nevada, is also one of Reid's biggest financial supporters and an employer of one of Reid's sons.
So, let's review: A communist Chinese company seeks $450 million in American taxpayer money to build a wind farm in Texas with parts assembled in Nevada. This is "state capitalism" in full bloom: Political back-scratching and cronyism with no chance of translating into a sustainable market in the long term. True capitalism is never born out of a Senate re-election bid. Capitalism requires innovation, not government intervention and political patronage.
The second concept to debunk: capitalism equals greed. Haters of capitalism perpetuate the stereotype of successful entrepreneurs as greedy misers stepping on the poor as they seek to fleece consumers to accumulate wealth.
"Unlike the self-absorbed," Richards argues in his book, entrepreneurs "anticipate the needs of others, even needs that no one else may have imagined. Unlike the impetuous, they make disciplined choices. Unlike the automaton, they freely discover new ways of creating and combining resources to meet the needs of others. This cluster of virtues, not the vice of greed, is the essence of ... the 'entrepreneurial vocation.' "
In 2011, let's make it a point to debate the merits of capitalism, especially with the "intellectual" left who say America needs more government intervention, not less. The only excess to capitalism and multinational free trade is widespread prosperity, freeing people to become less dependent upon government entitlements.
It's tempting to tell liberals brave enough to publicly differ to begin their argument by explaining those examples of recent leftist governments that thought they could control free markets and instead caused death and misery in their attempts to "share the wealth:" Josef Stalin's Russia, Mao Zedong's China and the Khmer Rouge's Cambodia.
But let's focus on the here and now.
Is there anyone out there who thinks that, if by some miracle A-Power doesn't get that $450 million return favor from Sen. Reid, that Chinese company will proceed to build an assembly plant in Nevada for a wind farm in Texas?
Anyone?
Sherman Frederick (sfrederick@reviewjournal.com), former publisher of the Las Vegas Review-Journal, writes a weekly column for Stephens Media.
Trending topics:
Comments
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Review-Journal does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please use the Report Abuse button.
Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 24 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
Ah the old "capitalism has never existed so therefore it cannot be the cause of any problems" defense. Well, since capitalism has not existed David can it be the "cause" of any good?
True capitalism is the solution not the cause. The perverted thing many in the US call "capitalism" but in reality is just merchantilism is the cause and not the solution. I'd love to see true capitalism here in the states for the first time. Sorry, we can't "go back" to it as it has never existed here.
So "DIAPER OF SNOOPY" (all CAPS) represents maturity and intelligence? ;-) That is amusing.
Tin foil hat? Is that suppose to be funny? It is trite, silly, and amuses no on.
Nothing escapes the single-digit IQ of Not-So-Deep Thoughts. Native Las Vegas, you ignoramus, means this person was born in Nevada and is not "the Alabama type breed".
You are too stupid to discern this.... ;-)
Wow, you both sound very tolerant and intelligant. So, DIAPER OF SNOOPY, is that tin foil hat fitted or one size fits all? Native, I really have no problem with you, you are smart, dyed jeans of snapple is a very special breed. Probably the Alabama type breed.
There is more than one of you? God help us! That is the problem with this country, Single Thought; there are too many dunderheads such as you. ;-)
I do admire you, Thick Thoughts. You know what your beliefs are by God and can fit them on a bumper sticker! ;-)
You don't just "get" respect, you have to earn it. Coming on here to make snide comments about the timing of my posts rather than engage me in a thoughtful discussion isn't respectful or intelligent, and is not the way a "good debator" would act. It is, however, the way a D.B. would act.
Hmmm, just a little kid with a keyboard. Wow you are so smart and great, you use the LVRJ to try to be a big boy. Tell you what, grow up, get a life, and have something worth saying and people might take you serious. Until then, keep acting like some tough guy if it makes you feel all warm and fuzzy. The rest of us see you as creepy and juvenile.
'Seriusly'? I am not familiar with that word, Simple-minded Thoughts. Is English your second language (pig Latin first)?
You are correct. Rational people like myself and Native Las Vegan have a low tolerance for ignorance and stupidity.
Raze us? You are an amusing twerp, aren't you? The only things you raze are the English language, intelligent thought, logic and reason.
The evil fox news brainwashing waves are getting to me, quick, get me a tin foil hat! I think I will go take a Native and wipe my Diogenes. Seriusly guys, if you weren't haters you might actually put me on the fence with your ideas, but instead you thrash people and never consider anyones thoughts but your own. This is why I raze you. I am usually a good debator when you show respect.
@ Diogenes - I see you've met "Thoughts". Don't let him get to you. I don't. He is a mindless drone who does nothing but come on this website to regurgitate whatever misinformation Hannity and Limbaugh fed him the night before and call anyone who doesn't agree with him names. The fact that he puts the word "Deep" in front of his username only proves that he's delusional as well. I think its funny he's attempting to insult me for making comments on this older article, when he himself is obviuosly still checking in on it...presumably to see if anyone was able to "out-wit" his witless comments. He can just look at what he dropped in the toilet this morning if he wants to see something capable of outwitting him.