Comments (15) | Add a comment
Steve Sebelius
Only real conservatives make the grade in this report card
How many true conservatives would you say there are in the Nevada Legislature? According to conservative activist group Citizen Outreach, it's fewer than you think.
A report card to be released to the public today rates Nevada lawmakers based upon how they voted on 62 specific bills debated during the 2011 Legislature. And even using the standard once attributed to then-Gov. Ronald Reagan -- somebody who's with you 80 percent of the time is an ally, not a 20 percent traitor -- there are slim pickings.
In the 42-member Assembly, only Ed Goedhart (93.5 percent), Richard McArthur (82 percent) and John Ellison (78 percent) make the grade.
(It should be noted that Citizen Outreach President Chuck Muth has done consulting work for Goedhart, and report-card researcher Dan Burdish worked out of Goedhart's office during the 2011 session, but was paid by Citizen Outreach.)
In the 21-member Senate, Don Gustavson (95 percent), Elizabeth Halseth (95 percent), Michael Roberson (93.3 percent), Greg Brower (90 percent), Barbara Cegavske (90 percent) and James Settelmeyer (80 percent) are in the club.
Even the lowest-ranking Republicans -- Assemblyman Lynn Stewart (30 percent) and Sen. Joe Hardy (48.3 percent) -- rate higher than every single Democrat, however. Eight Democrats in the Assembly, including 2011 Speaker John Oceguera and would-be 2013 Speaker William Horne, got zeros, which means Citizen Outreach thinks they voted the wrong way on every bill! Two senators, Shirley Breeden and Valerie Wiener, got close to zero with scores of 1.7 percent.
That probably isn't surprising, because the group says it based its ratings on criteria developed by the conservative House Republican Study Committee, including opposition to new taxes and fees, government regulations and restrictions on "individual freedoms" and personal responsibility.
That's why lawmakers got points for favoring smoking in adult-only bars, but not if they favored a ban on handheld cellphones while driving.
Opposition to taxes and fees earned lawmakers points. In fact, they got one point of extra credit if they signed the Americans for Tax Reform anti-tax pledge. Chief among the bills ranked was a vote on an extension of $600 million in taxes that were supposed to expire. (Citizen Outreach insists on erroneously calling this a tax "increase," although nobody actually paid any more in taxes.)
But the list of bills wasn't just about taxes. Lawmakers got credit for voting against regulations (and, sometimes, fees) on industries as varied as dietitians, fire performers, moped drivers, music therapists, hair braiders and hair stylists, and auto shops (which could have been required to check your tire pressure under a bill that died in the Assembly).
Showing its libertarian streak, the group gave lawmakers points for voting against a bill that would have allowed governments to collect DNA samples from people merely arrested for crimes, not just those convicted of them.
And while Citizen Outreach opposed Gov. Brian Sandoval's education budget, Burdish says Sandoval vetoed about half the bills the group opposed. Perhaps they should sign Sandoval up for a half-price membership?
To some extent, all report cards are subjective, depending on which bills are selected and why. And their ultimate use is generally rhetorical, for fundraising or to bash someone seen as insufficiently conservative or perhaps too much so.
Citizen Outreach says its goal was to measure rhetoric and reality: "Our ratings help conservatives differentiate between what a candidate says on the campaign trail and how they actually vote once in office."
So a candidate who made no promise to vote against taxes and then did has as much integrity as a candidate who promised to oppose them and did? That's how it should work.
Review-Journal political columnist Steve Sebelius blogs at SlashPolitics.com. Follow him on Twitter at www.Twitter.com/SteveSebelius or reach him at (702) 387-5276 or ssebelius@reviewjournal.com.
Trending topics:
Comments
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Review-Journal does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please use the Report Abuse button.
Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 24 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.
RSS
Twitter
Facebook
Here we go again, Steve "lefty" Sebelius showing how much of a partisan hack he is. Nine out of ten columns he writes are PRO-demo. Him and that face to face guy are glaring examples of how much bias there is in a "political columnist" How about you retell us how you back and support Berkley and her using taxpayer money to fund her own husbands business?? Ethics, integrity, true journalism?? not with lefty Steve.
An extension of $600 million in taxes that were going to expire means that people will pay more in taxes, so that makes it an increase in taxes that will be paid, but Steve Sebelius is so liberal he is too dumb to comprehend.
and we would have gotten away with it too, if it hadn't been for those darned conservatives and their Constitution. Hey liarjacks.heads, why do liberals hate the Constitution? Because it stands in the way of your 'progress'? You're kind of thinking, such as it is, is responsible for the mess our country is in. Time for you to sit down, shut up, and like it. You and your fellow socialist dolts have done enough. We see the results. We are living the results.
The amazing thing is that the very small minority of "true conservatives" -- the crazed baggers, neocons, and radical-individualist anarchist-libertarians -- simply stand in the way of progress whenever they can't get their way. Want more government paralysis? Vote bagger.
as i have stated, Nevada has no real conservatives, most are RINO a few even outright disloyal to their party, and platform. a big reason Nevada is in trouble is due to a lack of real opposition to the destructive democrats.
What is Steve's point? Yes, 20% is a traitor. Either they vote correctly every time or they do not. There is no middle ground.
Jack Bendover Webb, Barney Franks boy toy spouts his usual left wing drivel.
Why don't you libs worry about your own party? You've destroyed the country and now you think that you have anything to say about someone elses opinion? ROTFL
Liarjacks, how has that ball-playing worked out for you?
This is good. Really, people should be about policy instead of party or politician. For example, after bailouts and Obamacare, how can anyone support the treason of Reid or Pelosi? Where are they on GLASS STEAGALL? GLASS STEAGALL is really how you know who is a traitor or not.
This Sebelius column is good. All these personal attacks mean nothing. Only sound policy and the votes on the policy matter. Too many dupes and chumps have taken the bait and made it about personally attacking some shyster politician when that is exactly what they want, so that that becomes the issue instead of the actual issues that matter: policy and voting record.
Good job on this one.
Only real conservatives and super-geniuses like Hank Williams Jr. make the grade on that report card.
The rest of our elected officials know how, and are willing to, to play ball.
Are you ready to play some football? The radical right just wants to make a lot of noise and get in the way.