Home manage Las Vegas Review-Journal
  Jobs Cars Homes Shopping Travel Weddings Golf Best of Las Vegas Photo   Search:

RECENT EDITIONS
Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue

Sports


ED GRANEY: Cheesy NCAA rules need changing

They issued one of those excessive heat warnings Friday, advising of temperatures that could reach 110 degrees.

I might have paid attention, if the NCAA hadn't already caused me to reach the boiling point more than once this week.


Most Popular Stories
  • MATT YOUMANS: Sharp money avoids Saints
  • MATT YOUMANS: Underdog bettors profit as Manning takes fall
  • UFC 109: Couture rules by submission
  • BIGGEST GAME OF SEASON: Rebels concede little to BYU
  • ED GRANEY: NCAA proposes March mediocrity
  • Hauck's roster overhaul begins
  • STRESS-FREE NIGHT: UNLV avoids drama
  • 'SEVEN BIG GAMES LEFT': Rising Rebels stay grounded
  • RON KANTOWSKI: Kruger helps UNLV pack Mack again
  • Game, sports book tour live up to hype




  • I always thought if given the choice on who to come back as in another life, a PGA Tour player would be best. Not someone the magnitude of Tiger Woods, where unbelievable fame and fortune comes with a lifetime of no privacy, where you don't feel a need to spend $40 million to live behind walls and trees on an island to escape the incessant scrutiny.

    But rather someone like Jerry Kelly, where you annually rank among the top 30 to 50 players and pocket a few million dollars each year and exist without fear of walking outside and being mobbed. Where you live an awfully comfortable life playing golf, but fewer people recognize you than not.

    I've changed my mind.

    I want to come back as the cream cheese person.

    I want to be the one the NCAA assigns to sit at a desk and get paid for creating the dumbest, most absurd rules one can imagine.

    I want to be that guy.

    It seems as though the NCAA has grown at least one valve in its sinister heart and now will allow schools to provide its athletes things such as nuts and fruit and bagels. Snacks for everyone.

    But they can't offer any cream cheese or butter for the bagels, which George Mason basketball coach Jim Larranaga tweeted about this week. Give a kid some spread and you're dead.

    I'm trying to figure out where all of this lands under the notorious extra-benefits umbrella.

    Where in the world does the NCAA believe a little cream cheese could lead?

    Is it afraid mid-major programs might again find themselves at a competitive disadvantage because they can't offer the same level of Philadelphia Light as Ohio State?

    Does it fear Texas or Florida are evil enough to throw in some lox?

    I'm trying to get my hands around the idea that the preposterous 439-page NCAA infractions manual now reportedly includes a section about cream cheese and bagels but that John Calipari this week wasn't even mentioned in a report that again erased a Final Four appearance for a program that cheated under his watch.

    Memphis on Thursday was stripped of its 38 basketball wins and that national finals trip in 2007-08 for using an illegal player (Derrick Rose) who was accused of having someone else take his SAT exam.

    I suppose the first red flag was raised when Rose failed the ACT three times in his home city of Chicago and then passed the SAT ... in Detroit.

    Because, you know, I'm sure all those schools offering the SAT across Illinois that weekend were full.

    Memphis also was penalized for failing to monitor itself because a player's relative received $1,700 worth of free accommodations and travel. It seems the player (Rose) occasionally would substitute his carry-on bag with his brother (Reggie) on team charters.

    The good news: If there is a chance Reggie is lactose intolerant, more cheating probably didn't occur at breakfast.

    I understand the NCAA operates under an extremely limited scope in these matters, that it does not own subpoena power over someone such as Calipari (now at Kentucky) when investigating the Memphis situation.

    Think about it: How long has the NCAA attempted to nail its case against Reggie Bush? He'll be retired from the NFL before anyone from Indianapolis proves who paid for the San Diego-area home his parents lived in while Bush attended Southern California.

    I also know two programs (Massachusetts and Memphis) now have had Final Four trips erased from record books for violations while Calipari was coach, and the only punishment he has received is to continue landing better jobs for more and more millions.

    Calipari is a real-life chemist. Like steroids- and human growth hormone-afforded athletes, he's always one step ahead of those chasing him. Only the programs he coaches get nabbed.

    The NCAA needs to get serious about examining how it investigates these situations. It has to leave the cream cheese to Einstein's and as an organization discover ways in which those most culpable are disciplined.

    Cheating defines big-time business in college athletics as much as billion dollar television contracts. Presidents and athletic directors go to the wall when offering statements about having done their due diligence when hiring coaches with greasy pasts. They're just as liable when things spin out of control.

    The NCAA needs to go about its business in a different manner. Weeks like this, where kids apparently are going to be forced to eat dry bagels but Calipari continues to cash his fat checks and be treated like a savior in Kentucky, are beyond old.

    Find a way, NCAA. Hire smarter people, which shouldn't be difficult.

    Just don't bother the cream cheese guy.

    It takes serious time and thought to produce such idiocy.

    Las Vegas Review-Journal sports columnist Ed Graney can be reached at egraney@review-journal or 702-383-4618. He also can be heard weeknights from 11 p.m. to 1 a.m. on "The Sports Scribes" on KDWN-AM (720) and at www.infernosportsradio.com.

    Newsvine Digg Fark Technorati reddit StumbleUpon del.icio.us Slashdot Propeller Mixx Furl Twitter MySpace Facebook Google Bookmarks Yahoo! Bookmarks Windows Live Favorites Ask MyStuff myAOL Favorites

    Leave Your Comment 8 Reader Comments
    Terms & Conditions
    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The reviewjournal.com does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.

    Some comments may not display immediately due to an automatic filter. These comments will be reviewed within 48 hours. Please do not submit a comment more than once.
    Current Word Count:

    Note: Comments made by reporters and editors of the Las Vegas Review-Journal are presented with a yellow background.

    John wrote on August 23, 2009 12:51 AM: I am confused. I thought that once the NCAA clearinghouse cleared players then coaches were able to play them. So if I am correct, why the backlash against Calapari if the player was cleared by the NCAA clearinghouse? The coach has no control over when, where, how, of a high school student taking the SAT. Find something else to complain about in your next rant.


    JD wrote on August 22, 2009 11:31 AM: I agree ED, just ONE of thousands of ridiculous rules. Former NBA player and Utah Ute Keith Van Horn's father died, his mother called Ute Coach Rick Majerus trying to get in touch with her son to deliver the news, Rick goes and finds Keith to deliver the news and comforts him by taking him to a crappy greasy spoon food place for breakfast. Utes get put on NCAA sanctions and lose one scholarship for three years.


    Glenn Phillips wrote on August 22, 2009 10:37 AM: Never thought I'd read a critique of the absurdity of NCAA rules that would fit into one column, but you managed to do it (including the snippet re: the never-ending Reggie Bush investigation)! Great job. You correctly cited Mr. Calipari as the current example of coaches who emerge unscathed from scandal, but as a Sooner alum, I hold Kelvin Sampson up as the gold standard of gypsy coaches, having transgressed not once but twice!


    Homer the Loser wrote on August 22, 2009 10:25 AM: You're such a moron homer. It's the same old rhetoric every post. 'Tark cheated this and higher education is a joke that'. Everyone has had this absurd arguement with you over and over so there's no point......so....I'll just go right to war. Loser, freak, impotent minded, misguided fool.


    mike wrote on August 22, 2009 09:12 AM: whoa there Homer! Tark was the cheater??? why because he gave guys a chance that other schools wouldn't?? or was it because the NCAA tried to flip out over the team buying a 50 cent newspaper for his guys to read? you can't even compare Tark and that situation to this. To not allow cream cheese for a bagel is just retarded...... and the "illegal player", isn't that what the NCAA clearinghouse is for??? Don't they check these college athletes to make sure things are satisfactory before they start playing?


    homer wrote on August 22, 2009 08:32 AM: Ed grow up. The cheater who tried to gut the NCAA was Tark and thanks to him now an investigation into infractions is like death penality appeals, they go on forever and ever.
    Atleast Caipiiari's recruit graduated from high school and when he reported to school he did not go directly to a crack house where he was arrested. Lloyd Danniels ring a bell?


    martin bee wrote on August 22, 2009 07:45 AM: Same old NCAA! Out of touch once again. Bush was getting paid, usc brings in money so they look the other way. Higher education what a joke. They won't hold any championships in states where sports gambling is legal, thanks for saving me a few hundred bucks. I'll watch on my 65'HD tv instead.


    John wrote on August 22, 2009 02:24 AM: It is my understanding high school students setup and take the SAT. It is not the COLLEGE coach who sets up the date, makes sure they go to the test on time, etc.
    -------------------------
    Bring it on.

    Louisville's coach knocks up a skank in a restaurant and then covers the abortion.

    Roy williams is cited for knowing that Kansas players were receiving money from boosters. UNC hires him while Kansas goes on probation.

    Duke played an ineligible player for a year and didn't have to vacate a single game.

    IU and Sampson's problems are so deep I don't have time to start.


    But it's Kentucky who is somehow the bad guy. Even though the school in question wasn't kentucky, and no one associated with Kentucky was named in this in any way.

    Those other schools get a pass when it was THEIR school in trouble, but Kentucky gets blasted when we were just an innocent bystander.


    Evil Empire baby. The Empire is Striking Back and the rebels are screaming bloody murder.